Guardrails as ‘spears:’ Canadian town sues U.S. company for $500 million

Authorities across Canada are awaiting test results from the U.S. before deciding what to do about thousands of safety devices with alleged defects that could cause guardrails to rip through cars and motorists instead of protecting them in crashes.

TORONTO — Authorities across Canada are awaiting test results from the U.S. before deciding what to do about thousands of safety devices with alleged defects that could cause guardrails to rip through cars and motorists instead of protecting them in crashes.

In the interim, several provinces have stopped installing the units, which would cost tens of millions of dollars to remove, while the town of Stratford, Ont., has launched a proposed $500-million class action against the manufacturer.

At issue is Trinity’s ET Plus — the end unit of the guardrail — which is supposed to absorb impact and guide the rail so a crashing vehicle isn’t slamming into the rigid steel end.

The lawsuit, filed in Ontario Superior Court on behalf of all affected Canadian jurisdictions, alleges Trinity Industries secretly made unauthorized changes to the ET Plus about 10 years ago and failed to warn anyone about “serious failures” it knew about.

“Rather than absorbing the crash energy as originally intended, designed and tested, the guardrail becomes a rigid spear that impales the vehicle and its occupants, often severing limbs,” the suit states.

In an interview, Stratford lawyer Matt Baer said Trinity, which operates primarily out of Dallas, Tex., changed the design to save money on manufacturing.

“Now when you hit them, they don’t properly move the guardrail away from the car,” Baer said. “It’s quite dangerous.”

Trinity’s Toronto lawyer Mike Eizenga refused to comment, citing his company’s policy.

However, in a recent filing with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Trinity noted the Stratford lawsuit as one of several legal actions related to ET Plus — the others are all in the U.S. — but said the actions were “without merit.”

“We intend to vigorously defend our products and our long-standing reputation for ethical and honest business practices against allegations based on fiction rather than fact,” Theis Rice, senior vice-president of Trinity Industries, said in a statement last month.

Joshua Harmon, a federal whistleblower who won a fraud suit against Trinity in Texas in October that could see the company forced to pay US$700 million, said in an interview Wednesday that at least 200 deaths and injuries can be attributed to the ET Plus in the U.S.

In November, U.S. highway authorities ordered new crash testing of the ET Plus. Results are pending.

At least 42 states have stopped installing the units while Virginia is pondering a product recall while at least three Canadian provinces have now removed Trinity products from their approved list.

Alberta, for example, stopped installing them in October but has no plans to replace the estimated 1,000 units in service, a chore that would cost as much as $20 million.

“We haven’t had any problems with it specifically — to date it has performed the way the testing said it would,” said Jamie Friesen, spokesman for Alberta Transportation.

“(But) once it came to light that there were problems with the testing and the actual product itself, we did remove it from our approved product inventory.”

Nova Scotia and Quebec, which has about 4,500 of the units installed, have also withdrawn approval of ET Plus.

Brian Taylor, with Nova Scotia Transportation, said the province was unaware of any issues with its installed systems but was watching U.S. developments closely.

A spokesman for Ontario’s Ministry of Transportation said any decisions would come after final test results from the U.S. are in.

While it’s unknown how many of the units are in use, Bob Nichols said Ontario was not aware of any safety performance issues in the province.

“We are cautiously optimistic,” Nichols said.

Just Posted

Despite warnings, plenty of temptations to thieves left in vehicles

Lock It or Lose It campaign still finding plenty of valuables left in plain sight

Official: 3rd pilot helped on next-to-last Lion Air flight

JAKARTA, Indonesia — The chairman of Indonesia’s transportation safety agency confirmed Thursday… Continue reading

Oil prices, Alberta election call cloud Stampede chuckwagon auction expectations

CALGARY — Chuckwagon drivers and sponsors are hoping for the best as… Continue reading

‘It has to send a message:’ Broncos families await sentencing for truck driver

Kevin Matechuk says he will never, never forgive the semi driver who… Continue reading

MPs continue voting marathon as Tories protest shutdown of Wilson-Raybould motion

OTTAWA — Members of Parliament are continuing their marathon voting session as… Continue reading

World No. 4 golfer Rory McIlroy to play at RBC Canadian Open this summer

HAMILTON — Rory McIlroy is — finally — coming to Canada. The… Continue reading

Daniels: ‘Pain and anger’ around ‘Empire’ in recent weeks

LOS ANGELES — “Empire” co-creator and executive producer Lee Daniels says the… Continue reading

NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh to publish memoir ahead of federal election

TORONTO — NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh is set to release a memoir,… Continue reading

Why Solar: Canada needs to get its collective house in order

Canada needs to get a grip. The country has one of the… Continue reading

Gardening: Take care when making plant purchases

After a cold February, the longer sunny days and warmer weather triggers… Continue reading

Canadian pair fifth after short program at figure skating worlds

SAITAMA, Japan — Canada’s Kirsten Moore-Towers and Michael Marinaro are fifth after… Continue reading

Director Kim Nguyen tackles financial ‘madness’ in ‘The Hummingbird Project’

TORONTO — As Quebec filmmaker Kim Nguyen tells it, “The Hummingbird Project”… Continue reading

Most Read