File photo by THE ASSOCIATED PRESS Vegetable vendors wait for customers at a wholesale food market in Caracas, Venezuela, Monday, Jan. 28, 2019. Economists agree that the longer the standoff between the U.S.-backed opposition leader Juan Guaido and President Nicolas Maduro drags on, the more regular Venezuelans are likely to suffer.

Human-rights groups at odds over who is Venezuela’s legitimate leader

OTTAWA — Two of the world’s leading human-rights organizations have sharp differences over the decision by Canada and dozens of other democratic countries to support Venezuela’s opposition as the country’s legitimate government.

The gulf between Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch became evident in interviews this week as international calls intensified for Venezuela’s socialist president Nicolas Maduro to step down.

Canada, its Western Hemisphere allies in the Lima Group, the United States, and many across Europe are among the more than three dozen countries demanding Maduro’s ouster.

They recognize opposition lawmaker Juan Guaido as the country’s interim president and are calling for new elections after what they say was a fraudulent win by Maduro in a May 2018 election.

Alex Neve, Amnesty’s Canadian secretary-general, said it doesn’t support the stance taken by Canada and the Lima Group, and that a strictly neutral political position that upholds the status quo is the best way to protect the human rights of Venezuelans.

Tamara Taraciuk, the senior Americas researcher for Human Rights Watch, said her organization fully supports the Lima Group because getting rid of the Maduro government is the best way to end the abuse of Venezuelans’ human rights.

The debate is unfolding as the South American crisis escalated Thursday with a standoff at the Venezuela-Colombia border, where a Maduro-backed military was blocking the flow of United States aid into the country. Maduro blames the Trump White House for trying to engineer his overthrow.

Monday’s declaration from the Lima Group’s emergency meeting in Ottawa calls for a “peaceful” transition of power in Venezuela, and Foreign Affairs Minister Chrystia Freeland ruled out any military intervention.

“Amnesty doesn’t take a side on the political part of this tussle — who should or should not be in power,” Neve told The Canadian Press.

But the fact that Canada has chosen a side means it no longer has any ability to directly push the Maduro government to end human-rights abuses, including its targeting of children and journalists, he said.

“Human rights is not about regime change. Human rights is about whoever is in power, or whoever may be in power — what’s the strategy to ensure human-rights protection today, right now?”

But Taraciuk said Human Rights Watch supports the call by the Lima Group for Venezuela’s military to switch allegiance and back Guaido to force Maduro from power.

“We fully support that as a way to push the Venezuelan government to end its abuses,” she said. “This is not about siding with the government or siding with the opposition. It’s about siding with the hundreds of thousands of Venezuelans that took to the streets because they want to restore democracy and human rights in their country.”

Taraciuk said her organization has documented rights abuses committed against members of the Venezuelan military, by a government trying to keep them in line.

“This is not a conversation among equals inside Venezuela. You don’t have two equal sides sitting at the table talking,” she said.

At the end of January, U.S. President Donald Trump’s national-security adviser John Bolton told reporters that no options are off the table in dealing with the situation in Venezuela. That has rekindled fears of a repeat of past U.S. interventions in Latin American that gave rise to bloodshed, and ended up installing corrupt governments.

“I think the very real concern about the very serious human-rights violations that the Maduro government are responsible for cannot be overlooked or white-washed in any way,” said Neve. “Similarly, the dangers and perils, especially the past track records of U.S.-led and -encouraged intervention in Latin American states is not a rosy one. There’s very real reason to be concerned on both fronts.”

Taraciuk rejected any suggestion that the United States is flexing imperialist muscles, saying it is one of dozens of countries calling for peaceful change in Venezuela. She noted the Trump administration has imposed sanctions on Venezuelan oil exports to ratchet up pressure on Maduro.

Part of the Lima Group’s strength lies in the fact that it does not included the United States, said Taraciuk.

“It’s the first time since the crisis started deepening that we are seeing both things going hand in hand — this strong international pressure, including from the Lima Group, and internal massive peaceful demonstrations in favour of democracy and human rights in Venezuela.”

Just Posted

NEB gives Trans Mountain pipeline expansion its endorsement

CALGARY — The National Energy Board has endorsed an expansion of the… Continue reading

Regulator’s report unlikely to settle Trans Mountain pipeline expansion battle

CALGARY — An environmental group that tried to widen the scope of… Continue reading

Red Deer firefighter is recovering, thanks community for support

Firefighters who help together, stick together. Red Deer firefighter medic Ben Barthel,… Continue reading

Biathlon women sweep the podium for second time

Biathlon women took top four spots in Thursday’s 10-km race

Zion’s freak injury ripples in basketball, business worlds

DURHAM, N.C. — Soon after Zion Williamson’s shoe ripped apart, Nike’s stock… Continue reading

Fashion Fridays: Must-have wardrobe basics

Kim XO, helps to keep you looking good on Fashion Fridays on the Black Press Media Network

Rabbits saved from barn fire in Ponoka County

The Ponoka County East District Fire Department was called to a barn fire

Abel begins diving season on brink of record for most worlds medals

MONTREAL — Jennifer Abel could make history this summer in Gwangju, South… Continue reading

On eve of return to Toronto, former Raptors star DeRozan says he’s “moved on”

TORONTO — DeMar DeRozan has found closure. When the player once fondly… Continue reading

ACTRA to honour actress Jayne Eastwood who says being on set is her ‘happy place’

TORONTO — Looking back on her five decades in show business, Toronto… Continue reading

If proven, Smollett allegations could be a ‘career killer’

LOS ANGELES — Jussie Smollett is enmeshed in weekly drama on the… Continue reading

Ponoka host to Bayer Crop Science seed innovations trade show

The company held a trade show with seed crop science industry partners at the ag event centre

Gaudreau snaps goal drought to help Flames double up Islanders 4-2

CALGARY — The drought is over for Johnny Gaudreau. Gaudreau’s first goal… Continue reading

Federal government set to develop code of conduct for sport in Canada

OTTAWA — The federal government is developing a code of conduct for… Continue reading

Most Read