Internal docs shows many federal departments not meeting gender analysis targets

OTTAWA — The Trudeau Liberals’ promise to examine how their plans affect women and men differently hasn’t been fulfilled across the federal government, internal documents say.

Results from an internal survey conducted by Status of Women Canada measuring the implementation of “gender-based analysis plus” (GBA+, in the government’s jargon) found fewer than half of departments and agencies have a GBA+ plan, with most departments saying they lack the internal mechanisms to apply one.

Conservatives and Liberals alike have called GBA+ a useful way to think about what they’re doing and make sure nobody is accidentally left out of government plans.

Gender-based analysis is a tool used to think about how a certain policy might affect men and women in different ways, along with taking age, income, culture, ethnicity and other intersecting factors into account. If the analysis — ideally done early on in devising a new thing for the government to do — reveals one gender would experience disproportionately negative impacts, policy-makers have the opportunity to reshape things or otherwise mitigate those effects.

Trudeau instructed Status of Women Minister Maryam Monsef to make sure the government uses GBA+ more in decision-making and in 2017 the Liberals said they’d applied a gender-based analysis to a federal budget for the first time. But major gaps remain, according to the government’s own findings.

For example, in 2016, the Trudeau government made it mandatory that all memos to cabinet and Treasury Board submissions — which often form the basis of big spending or policy decisions — have a gender-based analysis. Fewer than half of departments have tracked whether this has indeed been done for these or other documents, according to the internal survey.

The findings also show 40 per cent of departments and agencies say they are not tracking how well they have implemented GBA+ and what effect it might be having.

“GBA+ is less integrated in some phases of the policy cycle,” the survey states, adding that departments and agencies reported significant barriers in getting data collected and analyzed separately for women and men in the first place.

Training in how to perform gender-based analysis is still not mandatory everywhere in the government, and is focused only on policy analysis, according to the survey results, which were presented in May 2018 to a committee of senior bureaucrats who deal with public-service management issues.

Sarah Kaplan, director of the Institute for Gender and the Economy at the University of Toronto, says she is not surprised to learn GBA+ has not been more widely applied, despite the Trudeau government’s oft-touted feminist agenda.

“My guess is that most of the people in the departments just see this as just an add-on to their already full schedules of things they’re supposed to be doing, so I’m guessing that’s why we’re not seeing the deeper implementation,” Kaplan said.

She pointed to the training government employees and officials are offered as one of the biggest culprits — training she says does not go far enough in offering practical tips on applying gender-based analysis early.

“The online training is really good at giving you a mindset of telling you, ‘These are some things to consider’ … but there’s much less in the training about what do you actually, technically do if you want to do this gender analysis,” Kaplan said.

The government’s struggle to apply a gender lens to policy decisions has been a long one. A plan for applying some form of gender-based analysis has been in place since 1995.

In 2016, auditor general Michael Ferguson released a report saying the government’s gender-based analyses were “not always complete, nor of consistent quality.”

A 15-year action plan was launched in response, and the government says it is working to implement GBA+.

“Our government continues to put gender at the heart of decision-making so that our policies better reflect the needs of all Canadians,” said Monsef’s spokesperson Braeson Holland.

“We are seeing significant progress across government, including seeing more staff in place to support GBA+. For example, policy analysts in 80 per cent of departments now take the online course offered through Women and Gender Equality Canada. We continue to see high uptake across government and will continue to work with our partners across government to promote uptake.”

Holland also pointed to a bill passed in December requiring that all future budgets and spending decisions undergo a GBA+ analysis.

But Kaplan said the way government has incorporated gender analysis in its budget planning needs improvement. Currently, a policy is first decided upon and then analyzed to measure impacts on gender, and then officials work out what to do about unexpected consequences.

“That’s a really impoverished way to do gender-based analysis because what you should really be doing is analysis on what are the needs out there, what are some of the inequalities, and then design your policy around those issues. And they’re not doing that at all.”

Kathleen Lahey, co-director of feminist legal studies at Queen’s University, says part of the problem is that the government doesn’t have enough people to do this work because the Conservatives eliminated many of their jobs when Stephen Harper was the prime minister, she said.

“The government has not yet re-established the tools that it needs so that the people in each of the policy modules can do the kind of analytical work that they need to do,” Lahey said. “There are significant gaps in our knowledge.”

Just Posted

NEB gives Trans Mountain pipeline expansion its endorsement

CALGARY — The National Energy Board has endorsed an expansion of the… Continue reading

Regulator’s report unlikely to settle Trans Mountain pipeline expansion battle

CALGARY — An environmental group that tried to widen the scope of… Continue reading

Red Deer firefighter is recovering, thanks community for support

Firefighters who help together, stick together. Red Deer firefighter medic Ben Barthel,… Continue reading

Biathlon women sweep the podium for second time

Biathlon women took top four spots in Thursday’s 10-km race

Zion’s freak injury ripples in basketball, business worlds

DURHAM, N.C. — Soon after Zion Williamson’s shoe ripped apart, Nike’s stock… Continue reading

Fashion Fridays: Must-have wardrobe basics

Kim XO, helps to keep you looking good on Fashion Fridays on the Black Press Media Network

Rabbits saved from barn fire in Ponoka County

The Ponoka County East District Fire Department was called to a barn fire

Abel begins diving season on brink of record for most worlds medals

MONTREAL — Jennifer Abel could make history this summer in Gwangju, South… Continue reading

On eve of return to Toronto, former Raptors star DeRozan says he’s “moved on”

TORONTO — DeMar DeRozan has found closure. When the player once fondly… Continue reading

ACTRA to honour actress Jayne Eastwood who says being on set is her ‘happy place’

TORONTO — Looking back on her five decades in show business, Toronto… Continue reading

If proven, Smollett allegations could be a ‘career killer’

LOS ANGELES — Jussie Smollett is enmeshed in weekly drama on the… Continue reading

Ponoka host to Bayer Crop Science seed innovations trade show

The company held a trade show with seed crop science industry partners at the ag event centre

Gaudreau snaps goal drought to help Flames double up Islanders 4-2

CALGARY — The drought is over for Johnny Gaudreau. Gaudreau’s first goal… Continue reading

Federal government set to develop code of conduct for sport in Canada

OTTAWA — The federal government is developing a code of conduct for… Continue reading

Most Read