Monica Klaus. Facebook photo

Judge: Parole for triple-murderers based on many factors

Jason Klaus and Joshua Frank could have faced life in prison with no parole for 75 years for the Castor-area murders

It should have been more.

Social media commenters and relatives of the murdered Klaus family were critical of the sentence handed their killers in a Red Deer courtroom on Wednesday.

Jason Klaus, 42, and Joshua Frank, 32, were sentenced to life in prison with no chance of parole for 25 years — the automatic sentence for first-degree murder. They were convicted of plotting and carrying out the murder of Gordon, Sandra and Monica Klaus in December 2013.

Related:

Murderers convicted

Strange stories

Crown prosecutors wanted the pair’s three-first-degree murder convictions served consecutively — one after the other — which would have meant they could not apply for parole for 75 years.

It is a sentence given two other Alberta triple murderers in the last year.

Derek Saretzky was sentenced last August to consecutive life sentences with no parole for 75 years for killing two-year-old Hailey Dunbar-Blanchette, her father Terry Blanchette and senior Hanne Meketech in the Crowsnest Past in 2015.

Consecutive life sentences with no chance of parole for 75 years were also given to Douglas Garland in February 2017. He violently kidnapped Alvin and Kathy Liknes and their five-year-old grandson, Nathan O’Brien, from the couple’s Calgary home on June 30, 2014, and murdered them at his Airdrie farm. He was convicted of three counts of first-degree murder and sentenced to consecutive life sentences in February 2017.

However, Justice Eric Macklin ruled Klaus’ and Frank’s sentences should be served concurrently — at the same time — meaning they can apply for parole in 25 years.

Extending ineligibility to 50 or 75 years would create sentences that were “unduly long and harsh,” he said.

It was not the decision that many in the packed courtroom wanted to hear.

Grant Berry, a relative of the Klaus family through Sandra, wrote in an email Thursday that “the Berry family feels justice has not been served for Sandi, Gordon and Monica Klaus.

“While we have nothing but gratitude and respect for the entire investigation process and court proceedings to determine a first-degree murder conviction, an opportunity to ensure both Jason and Josh would never cause harm again was missed.”

So what made Klaus’ and Frank’s case different?

Partly, it was the nature of their crimes. Garland killed a child and his offences including abduction, torture and dismemberment. Saretzky killed three people at different times and the case involved the cannabilization of a child.

While Klaus’ and Frank’s murders were “horrendous offences” they did not have the “unique and exceptional circumstances” of other cases, including Garland and Saretzky, says Macklin.

Parole does not end a sentence, he pointed out. It is only a modification of the sentence.

Even if granted parole — rare for multiple murderers — an offender is allowed out only under strict conditions and “necessarily involves control by the state for the rest of the offender’s life,” says Macklin.

Macklin tackled the perception by some that multiple murderers were getting off easy by not having parole extended.

That might “wrongly appear to victims’ families and members of the public that lives of one or more victims have been discounted in the process,” he says.

“In fact, that is not the case at all, as the number of victims is just one of numerous circumstances and factors which a court must consider in exercising its discretion.”

Macklin said he had no evidence that Klaus and Frank would pose a threat to the community in 25 years and should have their parole period extended.

He also spoke at length in court about hope — a murderer’s hope that one day they might be allowed out of prison.

Macklin cited the Grand Chamber of the European Court of Human Rights, which recognizes that criminals who pose a risk to society can be kept behind bars but maintains that the “denial of any hope of release would be inhumane and degrading.”

Canadian judges are expected to show restraint in meting out punishments and rehabilitation is one of the main objectives of sentencing.

“It has been held to be one of the of the fundamental moral values distinguishing Canadian society from the societies of many,” he writes, quoting case law.



pcowley@reddeeradvocate.com

Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter

 

Sandra and Gordon Klaus. Facebook photo

Just Posted

Is the fate of Red Deer’s Parsons House solely in the hands of the province?

Demolition of old police station next door to begin this fall

Fundraiser to help keep kids warm in Blackfalds

Community Warmth Fall Fundraiser

Piper Creek Foundation gets a new name

Red Deer subsidized housing program for seniors

Reveen returns to Red Deer

Presented by Friends of Red Deer Regional Hospital

2019 Winter Games will transform Red Deer: Olympic organizer

Team leader behind 2010 Vancouver Winter Olympics provides inspirational pep talk

WATCH: Red Deer students take part in annual run

Dawe/St. Pat’s Run reaches 40th anniversary

Smile Cookie fundraiser campaign for Reading College kicks off

Fundraising campaign runs Sept. 12-18 for program that helps children improve their reading

‘Nightmare that won’t end’: Storm evacuees can’t return yet

WILMINGTON, N.C. — Hundreds of people waited in long lines for water… Continue reading

New bridge collapses into river in rural Saskatchewan hours after opening

HYAS, Sask. — A rural politician in eastern Saskatchewan says he’s at… Continue reading

Halifax researchers tag great white shark in Atlantic Canada for first time

HALIFAX — For the first time in Atlantic Canadian waters, scientists have… Continue reading

Liberal riding association president blindsided by MP’s defection

OTTAWA — The president of an Ontario Liberal riding association says he… Continue reading

Pope gives bishops more decision-making options

VATICAN CITY — Pope Francis decreed on Tuesday that ordinary Catholics should… Continue reading

Hurricane rating system fails to account for deadly rain

TRENTON, N.C. — When meteorologists downgraded Hurricane Florence from a powerful Category… Continue reading

Glad company: Trailer for Disney’s ‘Mary Poppins Returns’

LOS ANGELES — A beloved nanny is preparing to take to the… Continue reading

Most Read