Judge questions cellphone bail ban

A visiting judge has raised questions about the practice in Red Deer provincial court of banning some people from having cellphones, pagers and Internet-capable computers while they are on bail or probation.

A visiting judge has raised questions about the practice in Red Deer provincial court of banning some people from having cellphones, pagers and Internet-capable computers while they are on bail or probation.

Prohibiting cellphones puts people in danger and increases the risk that they will violate their release conditions, Judge Judy Shriar said on Tuesday while hearing how a man awaiting trial on fraud charges ended up back in remand after failing to report to his bail review officer.

Defence counsel Andrew Phypers explained to the judge that his client had found a new job and left early in the morning to work out of town.

The had left a voice message with his bail review officer that morning, but could not be reached because he was prohibited from carrying a cellphone as one of his release conditions.

The accused man, who was on four separate recognizances, was consequently taken back to jail on a new charge of breaching his release conditions.

“Why can’t he have a phone? Everybody needs a phone,” Shriar said while accepting the man’s plea of guilty to a single count of breaching bail.

Shriar, who normally works in the Calgary Regional provincial court district, said she noticed while sitting in Red Deer on Tuesday that it is quite common for judges here to include bail or release conditions that prohibit people from using electronic devices including cellphones, pagers and Internet-capable computers.

She stated that the practice appears to be unique to Red Deer.

Such terms may be reasonable where an accused person is awaiting trial on child pornography and similar charges, said Shriar.

However, banning others from owning cellphones sets them up for breaches and can put them in danger, she said.

“I don’t like that condition. It’s going to set these guys up to go to jail again and again and again,” she said.

“I don’t know what he does for a living, but how can he not use a computer?”

Judges sitting in Red Deer have prohibited cellphones and other electronic devices where they were among the tools used in committing offences. In most of those cases, the terms include an exception allowing the devices for work purposes only.

In a separate case brought before Shriar on the same day, a cellphone was among the items seized from a man who pleaded guilty to possessing drugs for trafficking. Police identified the phone as bearing a number that undercover investigators used to set up a drug buy.

Shriar said any fears that cellphones are being misused for criminal purposes could be met by requiring that the phones be limited to the type that include a monthly bill detailing incoming and outgoing calls.

She crafted a new recognizance for the man accused of fraud, including restrictions on the type of phone he can carry and requiring that his computer access be limited to employment and banking purposes.

bkossowan@bprda.wpengine.com

Just Posted

PHOTOS: Aaron Goodvin sings at Westerner Days

Aaron Goodvin performed at Westerner Days Wednesday.… Continue reading

Severe thunderstorm watch in effect for Central Alberta

There’s a severe thunderstorm watch in effect for Red Deer and the… Continue reading

WATCH: Sun shines on Red Deer’s Westerner Days parade

George Young has been a Westerner Days parade marshal for about 28… Continue reading

Central Alberta receives funding for regional emergency training

Alberta Municipal Affairs announces $160,000 for training on top of $40,000 previously received

WATCH: Global FMX at Westerner Days

There are three freestyle motocross shows a day at Westerner Park this week

Study links air pollution to drop in national park visitors

DENVER — Visitors appear to be steering clear of some U.S. national… Continue reading

Banff’s bathroom bears returned to the park after 15 months of rehab in Ontari

Three cubs found abandoned in a washroom along the Trans-Canada Highway in… Continue reading

Canada could get caught in cross-fire of U.S. uranium investigation

Canada could get caught in the crossfire after the U.S. Department of… Continue reading

Trudeau shuffles familiar faces, adds new ones to expanded cabinet

OTTAWA — Prime Minister Justin Trudeau has unveiled his pre-election cabinet, shuffling… Continue reading

Canada’s premiers meet Indigenous groups, although three major groups decline

BOUCTOUCHE, N.B. — Canada’s premiers are meeting with Indigenous organizations in New… Continue reading

An updated list of federal cabinet ministers following Wednesday’s shuffle

OTTAWA — An updated list of federal cabinet ministers following Wednesday’s shuffle,… Continue reading

Most Read


Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $185 for 260 issues (must live in delivery area to qualify) Unlimited Digital Access 99 cents for the first four weeks and then only $15 per month Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $15 a month