Judge rejects groups’ attempt to have Quebec secularism law suspended

Judge rejects groups’ attempt to have Quebec secularism law suspended

MONTREAL — Quebec’s secularism law will continue to apply in full, Superior Court Justice Michel Yergeau ruled Thursday in rejecting a bid by religious and civil liberties groups to have the legislation suspended.

Lawyers representing a national Muslim organization, a civil liberties group and a university student who wears an Islamic head scarf had asked for a judicial stay of the central parts of the law, known as Bill 21. The legislation prohibits some public sector workers, including teachers and police officers, from wearing religious symbols at work.

Thursday’s decision means Bill 21 will remain in effect until a trial judge rules on the wider challenge to the legislation, which could take several years.

The applicants argued Bill 21 is causing serious, immediate harm to religious minorities across the province, but Yergeau said they failed to demonstrate the law is creating enough damage to warrant a stay for the duration of the court challenge.

Yergeau noted in his written ruling that the applicants were severely limited in their stay application because Bill 21, adopted in June, invokes the Canadian Constitution’s notwithstanding clause. That clause prevents citizens from challenging the law for violating fundamental rights and liberties protected by the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.

Therefore, lawyers had to try and use arguments rooted outside the charter to convince a judge that Bill 21 was causing serious harm to religious minorities.

The applicants could not argue, for example, that Bill 21 violates a Muslim woman’s freedom of religion or her right to be free from discrimination on the basis of her religion — two rights guaranteed under the charter.

Instead, lawyers for the National Council of Canadian Muslims, the Canadian Civil Liberties Association and student Ichrak Nourel Hak, had to be creative. They argued the law was causing serious harm to religious minorities because it encroached on federal jurisdiction, it was impermissibly vague and because it violated a citizen’s right to participate in their democratic institutions.

Yergeau said those arguments did not justify the stay, and he rejected claims the law itself was causing harm to Muslim women or to other religious minorities.

The stay application included sworn testimony from people who claimed the law encouraged Islamophobia in Quebec society and limited employment opportunities for religious minorities.

“They are claiming discrimination on the basis of religious practices that the applicants liberally choose to adhere to,” Yergeau wrote. “Hostile looks from members of society or hurtful comments … are the result of deplorable excesses and an incivility that this law also seeks to stem.”

Elisabeth Gosselin, spokeswoman for the minister of immigration, diversity and inclusiveness, said the government is satisfied with the ruling.

“This ensures that law … will continue to apply,” she said. “The Quebec government is determined to defend the legitimacy of this law so that it continues to have full effect. A significant and representative majority of Quebecers supports this law, which puts an end to a debate that has continued in Quebec for more than 11 years.”

Mustafa Farooq, executive director of the Muslim council, said his organization has not decided whether to appeal.

“No one ever said that defending our civil liberties would be easy” he said in a statement. “We are reviewing the decision now, and are considering our options to appeal.”

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Alert logo
Red Deer man arrested for child luring

A Red Deer man was arrested on Jan. 21 for an alleged… Continue reading

Mark Jones, Child Advocacy Centre CEO, takes a call. The centre has surpassed its latest fundraising goal. (Black Press file photo).
Central Alberta Child Advocacy Centre surpasses latest fundraising goal

One-Day Challenge sold $65,000 in 50-50 tickets

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau speaks during a news conference on the COVID-19 pandemic outside his residence at Rideau Cottage in Ottawa, on Tuesday, Jan. 26, 2021. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Justin Tang
Cancel travel plans, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau urges Canadians

OTTAWA — Canadians should cancel any non-essential travel plans they might have,… Continue reading

Jessica Swainson of Red Deer is of three local filmmakers who benefited from $20,000 of project funding from TELUS Storyhive. (Screenshot by Advocate staff).
Three Red Deer filmmakers each receive $20,000 to spotlight local heroes

Adam Jasper, Linda Pidhirney and Jessica Swainson received funding

Charlyn Stanley and her seven-year-old daughter Kaia look at vegetables being sold during at the Gasoline Alley Farmers Market in November. ( File photo by Advocate staff)
Central Alberta farmers market now open three days a week

Shoppers supporting Gasoline Alley Farmers Market

Terrance Josephson of the Princeton Posse, at left, and Tyson Conroy of the Summerland Steam clash during a Junior B hockey game at the Summerland Arena in the early spring of 2020. (John Arendt - Summerland Review)
QUIZ: How much do you know about hockey?

Test your knowledge of Canada’s national winter sport

(Photo submitted)
Central Alberta researchers recognized for studies in agricultural sciences

Jessica Sperber of Ponoka and David MacTaggart of Lacombe awarded prestigious scholarship

(Photo submitted)
Ponoka RCMP receives new police puppy trainee

Detachment says goodbye to ‘Maja’ and welcomes ‘Neutron’

Conservative MP Tracy Gray rises during question period in the House of Commons on Parliament Hill in Ottawa on Friday, Jan. 31, 2020. The Opposition Conservatives are urging the federal government to push back on President Joe Biden’s protectionist Buy American plan.THE CANADIAN PRESS/Justin Tang
Opposition urges Liberal government to push back against Biden’s Buy American plan

DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA — The Opposition Conservatives are urging the federal government… Continue reading

Quebec Crown prosecutor Francois Godin speaks to reporters outside a courtroom, Thursday, Nov. 5, 2020 in Quebec City. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jacques Boissinot
Quebec City Halloween night stabbing suspect returns to court for brief hearing

QUEBEC — The 24-year-old man accused in the Quebec City Halloween night… Continue reading

European Commission President Ursula Von Der Leyen addresses European lawmakers during the presentation of the program of activities of the Portuguese Presidency on a plenary session at the European Parliament in Brussels, Wednesday, Jan. 20, 2021. THE CANADIAN PRESS/AP/Francisco Seco, Pool
Canada’s vaccine deliveries further threatened as Europe mulls export controls

OTTAWA — Prime Minister Justin Trudeau says he remains confident in Canada’s… Continue reading

Conservative MP Tracy Gray rises during question period in the House of Commons on Parliament Hill in Ottawa on Friday, Jan. 31, 2020. The Opposition Conservatives are urging the federal government to push back on President Joe Biden’s protectionist Buy American plan.THE CANADIAN PRESS/Justin Tang
If Canada can survive four years of Trump, it can navigate the new Buy American: PM

DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA — Prime Minister Justin Trudeau says after the last… Continue reading

Nova Scotia’s provincial flag flies in Ottawa, Friday July 3, 2020. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Adrian Wyld
Mistaken identity: Porn allegation dropped against Nova Scotia doctor after mix-up

HALIFAX — In a bizarre case of mistaken identity, Halifax police blamed… Continue reading

Art Kempf, originally from the Stettler area but now living in Lacombe, is pictured here with his late wife Lillian. Art’s 100th birthday is coming up on Feb. 22nd.
photo submitted
Former Stettler area resident Art Kempf will be celebrating a very special day next month

Kempf, now a Lacombe resident, marks his 100th birthday on Feb. 22nd

Most Read