Kingsley qualifies initial positive assessment of elections law overhaul

One of the few electoral law experts to give high marks to the Harper government’s proposed overhaul of the Canada Elections Act is now offering a much more qualified assessment of the reforms.

OTTAWA — One of the few electoral law experts to give high marks to the Harper government’s proposed overhaul of the Canada Elections Act is now offering a much more qualified assessment of the reforms.

Jean-Pierre Kingsley, former national chief electoral officer, said Tuesday that at least two key provisions must be dropped and others changed in order to preserve the integrity of the electoral system.

When Bill C-23 was first introduced, Kingsley gave it a grade of A-minus.

However, he refused Tuesday to say if he’d stick with that grade if his recommended changes are not made.

Moreover, Kingsley told the committee he agrees with the testimony of his successor, chief electoral officer Marc Mayrand, who eviscerated the bill during an appearance before the committee earlier this month.

Canada’s election laws are built on the values of “participation, fairness, impartiality, accountability and fairness,” Kingsley said, but the bill falls short of those values on several fronts.

Two particular provisions — eliminating vouching and muzzling the chief electoral officer — “will impact very negatively on the values of participation, impartiality and transparency” and must be dropped, he said.

Doing away with the practice of allowing people to vouch for voters who don’t have proper identification would disenfranchise seniors, aboriginals, youth and transients who don’t have adequate ID, Kingsley said.

“This will directly affect the constitutional right to vote of a significant number of Canadians without justification.”

He similarly urged the government to drop a provision that would allow the chief electoral officer to communicate with the public only about the mechanics of voting.

“The chief electoral officer must retain the authority to reach out to all Canadians, to speak to them about our electoral democracy, the importance of our constitutional right to vote and the methods and the values at the core of our electoral system,” Kingsley said.

“Let me be clear,” he added. “Absent the rescinding of the proposed section … Canadians will lose their trust and their confidence in our elections. That is not acceptable.”

Kingsley said other changes are also “essential.”

He zeroed in on a provision that would allow political parties to exempt from their campaign spending limits any money spent to raise donations from people who have donated at least $20 over the previous five years.

Making a pitch for donations inevitably involves touting the reasons why donations are deserved “and this can only constitute advertising for or against a party or a candidate,” he said.

Moreover, he said such a provision would be impossible to monitor or verify and it would favour richer, established parties, to the detriment of poorer and especially new parties.

Kingsley also questioned why the bill ignored repeated calls by past and current elections watchdogs for the power to compel testimony during investigations of electoral wrongdoing and the power to audit the books of political parties.

His criticism was tempered with praise for some other parts of the bill.

He lauded creation of a mandatory registry for all automated campaign phone calls in an effort to stamp out the kind of fraudulent calls that marred the 2011 campaign. He also praised the proposed increase in penalties for impersonating an elections official.

Thousands of voters complained in 2011 about receiving misleading robocalls from purported Elections Canada officials directing them to the wrong polling station.

The proposed legislation, introduced Feb. 4, would effectively split Elections Canada in two, separating the chief electoral officer who administers the rules from the commissioner who investigates and enforces those rules.

The commissioner would operate out of the office of the director of public prosecutions, who is answerable to the federal justice minister.

Kingsley said the impact on the commissioner’s independence and ability to investigate is “neutral,” but he suggested the proposed regime would be less cost effective and investigations would likely take longer.

Just Posted

Former prison employee pleads guilty to role in inmate escape

Corrections Canada employee smuggled cash into prison for inmate who later escaped

Gesundheit! Stifling a sneeze can cause injuries in rare cases, experts say

TORONTO — With cases of flu continuing to rise in Canada, there’s… Continue reading

‘Reprehensible’: Trudeau abortion policy raises ire of U.S. right

WASHINGTON — In what’s almost certainly a first in the lengthy history… Continue reading

Japan public TV sends mistaken North Korean missile alert

TOKYO — Japan’s public broadcaster mistakenly sent an alert warning citizens of… Continue reading

Replay Red Deer Jan. 14: Watch news highlights in pictures

Stories mentioned: Red Deer RCMP seize large quantity of cocaine: Read more… Continue reading

Beer Canada calls on feds to axe increasing beer tax as consumption trends down

OTTAWA — A trade association for Canada’s beer industry wants the federal… Continue reading

Central Albertans recall Hawaii’s false missile alert

Former Red Deer councillor Paul Harris was hanging out at the Ka’anapali… Continue reading

This robotic maid takes us one step closer to ‘The Jetsons’

Imagine this: You’re rushing to get ready for work — juggling emails,… Continue reading

Milan line offers canine couture for pampered pooches

Milan has long been the world’s ready-to-wear fashion leader. Now, dogs are… Continue reading

Kim Kardashian West and husband Kanye welcome baby girl

NEW YORK — It’s a girl for Kim Kardashian West and her… Continue reading

Advocate poll takers oppose plastic bag ban

Red Deer Advocate readers like their plastic bags. In an Advocate poll,… Continue reading

Photo: Chilly work in Veterans’ Park

What a chilly job but somebody has to do it.… Continue reading

Boy, 15, one of three hit in Vancouver shooting

Police believe a man in his 20s was the target of the shooting

Most Read


Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $185 for 260 issues (must live in delivery area to qualify) Unlimited Digital Access 99 cents for the first four weeks and then only $15 per month Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $15 a month