Legal experts decry retroactive Conservative law but say it can’t be stopped

Legal and parliamentary experts say there’s nothing to stop the Harper government from retroactively rewriting a law to absolve RCMP wrongdoing and stuffing the changes in an omnibus budget bill — even as police investigate.

OTTAWA — Legal and parliamentary experts say there’s nothing to stop the Harper government from retroactively rewriting a law to absolve RCMP wrongdoing and stuffing the changes in an omnibus budget bill — even as police investigate.

“There is no restraint on Parliament’s legislative powers other than legislative jurisdiction under the Constitution Act 1867 and the charter,” former House of Commons law clerk Rob Walsh said in an email Thursday.

In simpler terms, “there’s nothing wrong with it,” according to Ned Franks, a professor emeritus at Queen’s University and parliamentary procedure expert

“As I’ve often said about this government, it’s unorthodox, but you can get away with it,” Franks told The Canadian Press.

Bill C-59, currently on the fast track to be passed by Parliament in the next four weeks, includes amendments backdated to October 2011 that would retroactively remove all elements of the now-defunct long-gun registry from Canada’s access to information law.

The unprecedented move was prompted by a finding of wrongdoing against the RCMP by federal information commissioner Suzanne Legault and the Conservative get-out-of-jail-free legislative move is drawing howls of outrage from opposition MPs and academics.

“This is banana-republic behaviour,” NDP Leader Tom Mulcair said in an interview. “This is Canada, it’s not Panama. It’s absolutely reprehensible what they’re doing, the technique itself is reprehensible.”

Both the NDP and the Liberals have presented motions to have House of Commons committees call the information commissioner and others to explain what’s going on, although Conservative majorities on the ethics and public safety committees may stymie the effort.

“I can guarantee you that as the official Opposition, the NDP’s going to use every single tool at its disposal in this case,” Mulcair said.

The Ontario Provincial Police have confirmed they are investigating the RCMP’s alleged breach of the Access to Information Act after receiving the file from the Public Prosecution Service of Canada.

That investigation won’t deter the government from pushing through its latest, 167-page budget bill — including the non-budget-related gun registry changes.

“Royal assent was given to a law passed by Parliament years ago requiring the destruction of the data from the long-gun registry,” Stephanie Henderson, a spokesman for the Conservative House leader, said in an email.

She said the government is committed to passing the budget bill before Parliament’s summer recess begins by June 23 — and the fall election to follow.

The information commissioner, in a special report to Parliament last week, called the Conservative move a “perilous precedent” that could be used by future governments to retroactively rewrite laws on everything from spending scandals to electoral fraud.

The charter prohibits changing the law retroactively to make something illegal that was legal at the time.

“It doesn’t prohibit the reverse, however: retroactive decriminalization of acts that were criminal when committed,” said Walsh, the former Commons law clerk.

Nonetheless, Walsh noted that L.J.M. Cooray in “The Rule of Law” has written that “Retrospective 1/8retroactive 3/8 legislation destroys the certainty of law, is arbitrary and is vindictive, (being invariably directed against identifiable persons or groups). Such laws undermine many characteristics of the rule of law.”

Variations on the same sentiment came from every legal expert reached by The Canadian Press.

Michel Drapeau, a law professor at the University of Ottawa, former Canadian Forces colonel and expert in access-to-information law, said the majority government is likely unstoppable.

“Can they do it? The answer is yes. Is it legal? The answer is you can probably find a way, but it’s against every precedent, against any notion, against any principle that laws should not be retroactive.”

Just Posted

Climate change’s impact on outdoor hockey discussed in Red Deer

Red Deer River Watershed Alliance held a forum Friday at the Alberta Sports Hall of Fame

Collision between Red Deer transit bus and truck investigated by RCMP

No one on bus was hurt, truck driver had minor injuries

Eckville man facing about 80 child sexual exploitation charges in court

More than half a million photos and videos found on electronic devices

Good-bye ice and snow, hello potholes on Red Deer roads

City workers will be spending 20 hours a day on various road repairs

Red Deer woman wins $1 million in lottery

A Red Deer woman spent $5 on a lottery ticket and became… Continue reading

WATCH: Fashion show highlights Cree designers

The fashion show was part of a Samson Cree Nation conference on MMIW

Puddle splashing: A rite of spring

Is there anything more fun than driving through water-filled potholes in the… Continue reading

Special evaluations can help seniors cope with cancer care

Before she could start breast cancer treatment, Nancy Simpson had to walk… Continue reading

Home renovator Mike Holmes oversees reno for paralyzed Humboldt Broncos player

AIRDRIE, Alta. — One of Canada’s most recognizable home renovators has acted… Continue reading

The endless war against invasive species

Group looks to protect native ecological environments in Alberta

WATCH: Fashion show highlights Cree designers

The fashion show was part of a Samson Cree Nation conference on MMIW

Flyers, Blackhawks, Sabres and Lightning to Europe in ‘19-20

Jakub Voracek was psyched at the mere suggestion the Philadelphia Flyers might… Continue reading

Danish receiver Nielsen looking to defy the odds again, this time at CFL combine

TORONTO — He’s coming to the CFL’s national combine as a definite… Continue reading

Mom with kids on YouTube channel suspected of child abuse

MARICOPA, Ariz. — A woman who operated a popular YouTube channel featuring… Continue reading

Most Read