Edmonton's High Level Bridge is lit in red and white in honour of the victims of Ukraine International Airlines Flight PS752, outside the Alberta Legislature Building in Edmonton on Wednesday, Jan. 8, 2020. Lawyers representing the City of Edmonton argued the city decided not to light a local bridge in colours that would represent the cause of an anti-abortion group in Alberta because the issue risked polarizing the region, an Edmonton judge heard Friday. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Codie McLachlan

Lighting bridge in colours for anti-abortion group ‘polarizing’, Edmonton lawyers say

Lighting bridge in colours for anti-abortion group ‘polarizing’, Edmonton lawyers say

EDMONTON — Lawyers representing the City of Edmonton say the city decided not to light a bridge in colours requested by an anti-abortion group because it risked polarizing the community, a judge heard Friday.

The Alberta March for Life Association asked a judge last year to review the city’s decision to cancel lighting the High Level Bridge in 2019 in the group’s requested colours — pink, blue and white — after the city initially approved the request.

A lawyer for the Justice Centre For Constitutional Freedoms, which is representing the association, said the pink and blue colours would have represented unborn boys and girls.

The bridge stretches over the North Saskatchewan River and is outfitted with 60,000 programmable lights that are often lit to recognize major events and cultural celebrations.

Documents filed in court say Jerry Pasternak, vice-chairman of the association, asked for the bridge to be lit to recognize the association’s annual March for Life, which the group has been co-ordinating in Edmonton since 2008.

The city approved the request in March, but later cancelled it in April, a month before the scheduled march, citing the “polarizing nature of the subject matter.”

James Kitchen, a lawyer for the Justice Centre For Constitutional Freedoms, told court that Edmonton is home to a diverse population with a wide variety of views, values and beliefs, including people with pro-life views.

“The expression of pro-life opinions is part of the diversity of expression found in a free society, and is protected by the charter,” Kitchen said. He pointed to section 2 (b) of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms that gives Canadians the fundamental freedom of expression.

Kitchen also argued that the city has lit the bridge for causes in the past that promoted sexual and gender diversity, LGBT Pride, and various Islamic holidays and celebrations.

He noted that the city has also lit the bridge in association with International Pregnancy and Infant Loss Awareness Day and disability awareness campaigns.

Kitchen said Edmonton’s decision last year unjustifiably violated the association’s freedom of expression and that the policy the city uses to manage the lighting of the bridge violates free expression.

Lawyers representing the city countered that the city has permitted the group to gather for its annual march, including closing roads. They said that shows that freedom of expression was not suppressed.

They argued that lighting the bridge — which is owned by the city and maintained with tax dollars — makes some citizens interpret the lights as a message from the City of Edmonton.

“Various postings (against the lighting of the bridge) on Twitter represent a microcosm of community at large,” said Shayne Abrams, a lawyer representing the city.

She pointed to a frenzy that erupted on social media when the city announced it would light the bridge for the anti-abortion group.

“These (messages) show that the message of March For Life polarizes the community and shows that some citizens take the lights as a message from the city,” Abrams said.

She agreed many topics that engage public discourse can be polarizing but argued that some do it in an extreme way.

“The one we are talking about (abortion) is one of those. What the city is doing, by using the word ‘risk’, they are trying to set a minimal level,” Abrams said.

Abrams said there is a benefit to refusing to light the bridge for particular causes because it can limit detrimental effects of polarization.

The court adjourned Friday evening with no word on when a decision would be made.

This report by The Canadian Press was first published Nov. 13, 2020.

______

This story was produced with the financial assistance of the Facebook and Canadian Press News Fellowship

Fakiha Baig, The Canadian Press

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Alberta’s chief medical officer of health, Dr. Deena Hinshaw, said growing COVID-19 case numbers continue to be a concern in the province. (Chris Schwarz/Government of Alberta)
Alberta announces 1,077 new COVID-19 cases Thursday

There are currently 14,052 active cases in the province

Head coach Jason Chatwood, left, sports one of the Sylvan Lake Gulls’ first on-field hats next to Aqil Samuel, general manager and president of baseball operations, earlier this year.
Sylvan Lake Gulls ticket sales off to flying start

With the inaugural season quickly closing in, the Sylvan Lake Gulls hit… Continue reading

Photo by Chris Schwarz/Government of Alberta)
Alberta’s chief medical health officer publicly criticizes staffer who leaked info

EDMONTON — Alberta’s chief medical officer of health, dealing with rocketing COVID-19… Continue reading

The RCMP major crimes unit is investigating after a person was found dead at a residence on Stewart Street in Red Deer’s Sunnybrook neighbourhood Wednesday afternoon. (Photo by Sean McIntosh/Advocate staff)
Red Deer RCMP investigating suspicious death in Sunnybrook

A ‘deceased adult’ was found by officers

A detail from Canyon Light, an oil painting by Joan Clement, in the Scale exhibit by members of the Red Deer Art Club. It’s showing at the Viewpoint Gallery in the city’s Culture Services Centre. (Contributed image).
Outdoor art gallery and scavenger hunt is on in Red Deer next month

But First Friday receptions and patio concerts are postponed

Mahomes vs. Brady spices up Thanksgiving holiday week

Mahomes vs. Brady spices up Thanksgiving holiday week

Cowboys miss chance for NFC East lead with another home loss

Cowboys miss chance for NFC East lead with another home loss

Arsenal, Leicester, Hoffenheim advance in Europa League

Arsenal, Leicester, Hoffenheim advance in Europa League

Keegan Messing performs during the Men's Short program at the 2020 Canadian Tire National Skating Championships in Mississauga, Ont., Friday, Jan. 17, 2020. If the world figure skating championships do go ahead in a bubble in March in Sweden, there is a good chance Canada won't be there. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Frank Gunn
Canada might not compete at world figure skating championships – if they happen

Canada might not compete at world figure skating championships - if they happen

A piece of hockey history is up for sale, with a rare Vancouver Millionaires sweater, seen in an undated handout photo, hitting the auction block. The cream and maroon wool cardigan is believed to have belonged to Hall of Fame goalie Hugh Lehman, who backstopped the Millionaires to a Pacific Coast Hockey Association championship in 1922-23. THE CANADIAN PRESS/HO-Lelands Auction, *MANDATORY CREDIT*
Hockey history up for sale as 97-year-old Vancouver Millionaires sweater hits auction

Hockey history up for sale as 97-year-old Vancouver Millionaires sweater hits auction

Canada’s Nembhard scores 11 points off the bench in Gonzaga debut

Canada’s Nembhard scores 11 points off the bench in Gonzaga debut

Mighty Heart is breezed by exercise rider Des McMahon, at Woodbine Racetrack in Toronto, Thursday, Oct. 15, 2020. Woodbine Entertainment says it has officially cancelled the rest of its thoroughbred racing season following discussions with the Ontario government. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Chris Young
Woodbine Racetrack ends horse racing season after talks with provincial government

Woodbine Racetrack ends horse racing season after talks with provincial government

As Alberta’s COVID-19 cases rise, so does tension over world junior championship

As Alberta’s COVID-19 cases rise, so does tension over world junior championship

Most Read