(Black Press file photo).

New trial for couple convicted of unlawful confinement in citizen’s arrest

Ontario’s top court has ordered a new trial for a Caledon, Ont., couple found guilty of unlawful confinement after they tied up two young men caught stealing from their property.

In a unanimous ruling released Thursday, the Court of Appeal says the trial judge made mistakes in his instruction to the jury in the citizen’s arrest case.

The court says the judge failed to direct the jury on the issue of whether the two men consented to their prolonged confinement, as the couple alleged.

During the trial, court heard the two men were trying to steal stainless steel from the homeowners’ yard for the third night in a row in August 2008 when they were caught in the act.

The two men testified that the couple confronted them with a gun, held them hostage, assaulted them and demanded money in exchange for not calling the police.

The couple denied those allegations and said that after they tied up the men with zip ties, the pair pleaded with them not to call police and offered to repay them for the previous thefts.

They testified the men asked that their parents be called instead, and agreed to stay bound until their relatives arrived. As a result, they argued, the men consented to their continued confinement.

Prosecutors argued at trial that while the citizens’ arrest was initially legitimate, it became unlawful when the homeowners failed to call police as soon as reasonably possible, as required by law.

The appeal court noted that the trial judge referred to the issue of consent but said his instructions on the topic were “inadequate.” Instead, the appeal court said, the trial judge focused on the “wrong issue” — the couple’s obligation to contact the police as soon as possible.

“Even if the appellants failed to call the police forthwith — an issue that went to the continuing lawfulness of the complainants’ arrest — their confinement of the complainants was unlawful only if the complainants did not consent to it,” the three-judge panel said.

“If the appellants’ evidence were accepted, or if it at least left the jury in a state of reasonable doubt as to whether the complainants consented, they were entitled to be acquitted, and any concern about their failure to call the police forthwith was irrelevant.”

Nor did the trial judge explain that it was up to the Crown to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that there was no consent, the appeal court said.

“As a result, the jury may well have convicted the appellants despite having a reasonable doubt about consent,” it said. “The convictions cannot stand.”

This report by The Canadian Press was first published Nov. 15, 2019.

Paola Loriggio, The Canadian Press

Just Posted

Alberta Premier set to make case directly to Trudeau for more federal action

OTTAWA — Alberta Premier Jason Kenney and Prime Minister Justin Trudeau are… Continue reading

Cenovus says capital spending to edge higher in 2020, production to rise

CALGARY — Cenovus Energy Inc. plans to increase its capital spending in… Continue reading

Canada charges Volkswagen over faking car emissions tests

OTTAWA — The Canadian government said Monday that it is charging Volkswagen… Continue reading

Canadian actor aboard cruise ship saw beginning of New Zealand volcano eruption

A Canadian man says he is still “shaky” from the experience of… Continue reading

WATCH: CP Holiday Train supports Lacombe Food Bank

Madeline Merlo and JUNO Award nominee Scott Helman both performed

Your community calendar

Friday The Annual Old-Fashioned Country Christmas is being held Dec. 13 at… Continue reading

Kyle Lowry among celebs to make onstage cameos in ‘The Nutcracker’

Toronto Raptors all-star Kyle Lowry is set to be a pointe guard… Continue reading

Opinion: City’s health-care needs ignored once again

Whether it’s services for those struggling with addictions, or patients who need… Continue reading

Canadians say ‘not enough’ to anti-doping agency sanctions on Russia

The latest sanctions levied against Russia by the World Anti-Doping Agency don’t… Continue reading

Canadian prize juries wrestle with tension between politics and literature

With every literature prize comes some contention over which texts are most… Continue reading

Marie Fredriksson of Swedish pop duo Roxette dies at 61

STOCKHOLM — Marie Fredriksson, the female half of the Swedish pop duo… Continue reading

Eagles rally past Manning, Giants 23-17 in OT

PHILADELPHIA — Eli Manning isn’t done yet. Neither are the Philadelphia Eagles.… Continue reading

Freeland heads to Mexico in effort to finalize new NAFTA revisions

OTTAWA — Deputy Prime Minister Chrystia Freeland is to meet American and… Continue reading

Most Read