Supreme Court Justice Richard Wagner (left) confers with his colleague Supreme Court Justice Morris Fish in Ottawa, Dec. 10, 2012. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Fred Chartrand

Ottawa launches independent review of Canada’s beleaguered military-justice system

Ottawa launches independent review of Canada’s beleaguered military-justice system

OTTAWA — Former Supreme Court justice Morris Fish has been tapped to lead an independent review of Canada’s military-justice system, which is struggling with a variety of challenges — including over its handling of sexual-assault cases and treatment of victims.

Defence Minister Harjit Sajjan announced Fish’s appointment on Monday as he launched the review, which is required by law about every 10 years to ensure the justice regime is meeting the needs of both Canada and the Canadian Armed Forces.

“Efforts have been underway for some time to prepare for the next independent review,” Sajjan said in a statement, adding Fish “will examine the military-justice system and provide recommendations on how we can continue to evolve the system so it reflects current Canadian values.”

Fish, who served on the Supreme Court from 2003 to 2013, has until June 2021 to table his final report in Parliament.

The mandatory review comes at a critical time for the military-justice system, which has been embroiled in a number of battles in recent years amid questions and challenges to its legitimacy, credibility and constitutionality.

The most recent example is the suspension of four courts martial, including one involving an officer accused of sexual assault, after three military judges raised concerns about an order last year from chief of the defence staff Gen. Jonathan Vance.

Vance’s order placed responsibility for disciplining military judges with another senior officer he appointed, which the judges said violated their own independence and thus undermined the accused service member’s right to a fair trial.

Vance suspended his order in September to prevent more cases from being affected, but he has indicated that will apply only until the military’s appeal court weighs in on its constitutionality.

Defence officials have not said why Vance issued the October 2019 order, but the timing coincided with what was considered at the time to be a key test of the system: the unprecedented court martial of Canada’s top military judge, colonel Mario Dutil.

That court martial eventually fell apart, with military prosecutors withdrawing all charges against Dutil in March after his deputy recused himself from the case over a conflict of interest and refused to appoint any of the military’s other judges for similar reasons.

There has also been growing frustration over delays in the implementation of a declaration of victims’ rights passed by Parliament last year. Sajjan refused to commit to a timeline when he was grilled about the declaration at a recent parliamentary committee meeting.

“I wish these regulations could be done almost immediately, but we also committed to consulting with the victims so that the regulations are done appropriately,” Sajjan told the House of Commons defence committee on Nov. 2.

“This is actually something we committed to and we need to make sure that we do that well.”

Retired colonel Michel Drapeau, one of Canada’s foremost authorities on military law, welcomed Fish’s appointment even as he listed many ways in which the system should be reformed — starting with implementing the declaration on victims’ rights.

While victims in the civilian system have access to the provisions of the Canadian Victim Bill of Rights, Drapeau said victims of crimes prosecuted in the military-justice system — whether the victim is a civilian or Canadian Armed Forces member — do not have the same support.

Drapeau, who has long argued that military judges are not independent and questions whether coroner’s inquests should investigate the deaths of troops outside combat rather than boards of inquiry, said Fish’s experience on the Supreme Court gives him confidence in the upcoming review.

“By virtue of his training and virtue of his of his performance as a Supreme Court justice, he’s got the capability and he’s got the capacity to say what needs to be said and let the chips fall where they may,” Drapeau said.

“I have full confidence if we are to have an independent review of the National Defence Act, I couldn’t think of anyone better at this stage to do that. His past record speaks for itself.”

This report by The Canadian Press was first published Nov. 16, 2020.

Lee Berthiaume, The Canadian Press


Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau leaves the House of Commons on Parliament Hill in Ottawa, on Monday, Nov. 30, 2020. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Justin Tang
Conservatives push for parliamentary committee study into failed vaccine deal

OTTAWA — The federal Conservatives are calling for a parliamentary committee to… Continue reading

(Red Deer Advocate file photo).
Registrations for Red Deer rec programs delayed

Sign-up for sports and culture programs starts Jan. 12

(Red Deer Advocate file photo).
Red Deer County seeks public feedback on draft budget

Minimal impact on ratepayers was the goal

(Advocate file photo).
RDC’s The Nutcracker is being videotaped for online viewing

COVID-19 presents challenges for live performance

Trail RCMP report three impaired driving investigations. Photo: Black Press file
New drunk driving rules allow police to impose tougher penalties immediately

New impaired driving regulations started on Tuesday

Idyllic winter scenes are part of the atmosphere of the holiday season, and are depicted in many seasonal movies. How much do you know about holiday movies? Put your knowledge to the test. (
QUIZ: Test your knowledge of holiday movies and television specials

The festive season is a time for relaxing and enjoying some seasonal favourites

Toronto police respond to an incident at St. Michael’s College School, in Toronto, Nov. 19, 2018. The trial of a teen accused of sexually assaulting two students at a prestigious Toronto high school is set to resume today. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Tijana Martin
Trial resumes for teen accused in St. Michael’s College School sex assault case

Defence lawyers for a teen accused of sexually assaulting two students at… Continue reading

Minister of Health Patty Hajdu responds to a question during question period in the House of Commons on Parliament Hill in Ottawa on Monday, Nov. 30, 2020. The Trump administration is keeping silent about Canada blocking its plan to import prescription drugs from north of the border. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick
Trump admin silent after Hajdu pushes back on U.S. plan to raid Canada’s drug cabinet

WASHINGTON, D.C. — The Trump administration is keeping silent about Canada blocking… Continue reading

Quebec City mayor Regis Labeaume, right, speaks at the inauguration of a memorial to the 2017 mosque shooting, Tuesday, December 1, 2020 in Quebec City. From the left, Luce Pelletier, artist who designed the memorial, MP Joel Lightbound, Boufeldja Benabdallah, and MNA Joelle Boutin.THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jacques Boissinot
Quebec City’s memorial to 2017 mosque shooting victims symbolizes defeat of hatred

Quebec City has inaugurated a memorial to the victims of the 2017… Continue reading

A scene from last year’s Light the Night fundraiser at the Stettler Town and Country Museum. This year’s rendition is on a drive-through basis only, but it still promises to be a not-to-be-missed seasonal highlight. (Independent file photo)
Stettler Town and Country Museum hosts ‘Light the Night’

This year’s rendition is drive-through only, but will still prove to be a dazzling display

Alberta restaurants face new regulations aimed at stopping the spread of COVID-19, Photo from Trolley 5 Brewery and Restaurant Facebook page
Restaurants working under new restrictions Central Alberta

Starting last Friday, any area in the province with more than 50… Continue reading

Opinion piece
Opinion: A down payment on recovery, details to come

Just to be clear: Justin Trudeau’s government has not acquired the ability… Continue reading

(Black Press File Photo)
Rimbey woman gathering Christmas gifts for seniors at Valleyview Manor

Margaret Tanasiuk says she doesn’t want anyone to feel forgotten on Christmas morning

Mike Miltimore, seen in Kamloops, B.C., in an undated handout photo, says the Gretsch electric guitar that a woman brought into his store is from 1955 and similar to one played by country music legend Chet Atkins before he developed his signature series of guitars. THE CANADIAN PRESS/HO-Mike Miltimore
Guitar made in 1950s worth more than B.C. family imagined

KAMLOOPS, B.C. — When Renee Latheur decided to take an old guitar… Continue reading

Most Read