Pair in alleged Via plot urge Supreme Court to deny hearing in terror case

OTTAWA — Two men who were found guilty of terrorism offences in a high-profile case argue there is no need to revisit an appeal court’s decision to order a new trial.

In newly filed legal submissions, Raed Jaser and Chiheb Esseghaier urge the Supreme Court of Canada to reject a federal application for a hearing on whether the lower court of appeal was right to overturn their convictions.

Jaser and Esseghaier were found guilty in 2015 of terror-related charges arising mainly from an alleged al-Qaida-inspired plot to crash a Via Rail passenger train.

Both men appealed their convictions. Counsel for Jaser and a court-appointed lawyer for Esseghaier argued the jury that convicted them was improperly constituted.

In August last year, the Ontario Court of Appeal ordered a fresh trial for the men.

The appeal court said Jaser was improperly denied his preferred option for jury selection. It also said that if Jaser should have a new trial, Esseghaier was also entitled to one.

Following the decision, the Public Prosecution Service of Canada said it would proceed with a new trial, but noted it had 60 days to decide whether to seek permission to appeal from the Supreme Court.

In a subsequent submission to the top court, federal lawyers noted Jaser and Esseghaier were convicted of the most serious terrorism offences in Canadian law after nearly nine months of pre-trial motions and a three-month jury trial.

“Overturning these convictions on the basis of a technical error that had no appreciable effect on the conduct of the trial is a triumph of form over substance,” the submission said.

“Where, as here, there is no actual demonstrable prejudice to the fairness of the trial, the verdict properly reached by the trier of fact after a long and arduous trial should not so easily be set aside.”

The Supreme Court is expected to decide in coming weeks whether to hear the case.

Both Esseghaier and Jaser say the court should dismiss the federal application and let their new trial go ahead.

“The Crown has failed to identify any error of law in the decision of the Court of Appeal, much less one that raises an issue of national importance,” says Esseghaier’s submission.

He takes issue with the suggestion the serious nature of the alleged offences should prompt the Supreme Court to grant leave to appeal.

“The Crown has not advanced any argument as to why only serious cases involving overturned convictions, as opposed to convictions that are upheld on appeal, are sufficient to satisfy its new proposed test for leave,” Esseghaier’s brief says.

“Profoundly serious cases are, sadly, not an uncommon occurrence in the Canadian criminal justice system.”

In his submission to the court, Jaser also rejects the notion that the gravity of the alleged offences would warrant a high court hearing.

“The seriousness of the allegations cannot transform an unimportant legal issue into an important one.”

This report by The Canadian Press was first published Jan. 9, 2020.

Jim Bronskill , The Canadian Press

Via rail terror plot

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Even in ‘worst-case scenario,’ Westerner Park can now operate until early 2021, says CEO

Mike Olesen is grateful for $2 million from the City of Red Deer

Dental services for developmentally disabled shuttered in Red Deer

Marwayne Dental Clinic closes to Red Deer and central Alberta patients

Red Deer building permits on the rise

Building permit applications returned to their seasonal average after slowing in May,… Continue reading

Three patients dead: Edmonton hospital declares full COVID-19 outbreak

EDMONTON — A hospital in Edmonton is no longer admitting patients due… Continue reading

CMHC reports annual pace of housing starts in Canada increased in June

OTTAWA — Canada Mortgage and Housing Corp. says the annual pace of… Continue reading

Westerner Park uncertainty won’t affect Red Deer Rebels

New lease agreement for Centrium in the works

Ponoka hotel asks town for $4,684 tax break

Request leads to lengthy debate

Military helicopter training near Rocky Mountain House this weekend

Three CH-146 Griffon helicopters will be training in central Alberta over the… Continue reading

Fun and Flowers: Rimbey and Area Love My Garden Tour this July

“Every garden is as unique as the gardener who created them.”

Opinion: Restart our economic engine by supporting oil and gas

“The country isn’t going to recover unless the oil and gas sector… Continue reading

Opinion: COVID costs need restraining

Bill Morneau muttered it best himself on Wednesday as he tabled documents… Continue reading

UPDATE: Alberta RCMP Major Crimes Unit investigating suspicious death in Leduc

Death of Jacob Michael Chitze, 19, ruled a homicide; RCMP seek video of house party altercation.

Fateful meeting has Vancouver’s Stuart Macdonald on Korn Ferry Tour

Stuart Macdonald wasn’t quite sure what Golf Canada’s Derek Ingram wanted to… Continue reading

Most Read