PMO sought, obtained details on confidential audit: Duffy trial

The word 'confidential’ was splashed across the work mandate of the independent audit into Mike Duffy’s Senate expenses, with explicit terms that limited the circle of access.

OTTAWA — The word ‘confidential’ was splashed across the work mandate of the independent audit into Mike Duffy’s Senate expenses, with explicit terms that limited the circle of access.

And yet information still found its way into Stephen Harper’s office in March 2013, via political figures who had no role in the Senate-commissioned audit.

Duffy’s fraud, breach of trust and bribery trial heard Tuesday about how the PMO sought and obtained details on the firm Deloitte’s examination of Duffy’s expenses.

Defence lawyer Donald Bayne spent hours on the Deloitte issue in an aggressive cross-examination of Harper’s former chief of staff, Nigel Wright.

It’s all part of a defence strategy that seeks to tear down the argument that Duffy was responsible for a scheme that would see someone else repay his $90,000 in living and travel expenses.

“This is conspiratorial collective action that your group is taking, to have Deloitte write a report that says their work is done,” Bayne said during one testy exchange with Wright.

“You’re trying secretly to interfere with and approach secretly a strictly confidential audit, and you’re doing it with somebody who isn’t the client and has no connection to this process.”

Why is the Deloitte audit so significant? The trial has heard it was a critical component of the deal struck between the PMO and Duffy to have him admit to the public he had made a mistake claiming expenses for his home in suburban Ottawa. (Another part the deal would ensure Duffy never had to be out of pocket for the repayment.)

Wright has said that Sen. David Tkachuk, the former head of the powerful Senate internal economy committee, was the first to suggest that if Duffy repaid his expenses, he could be withdrawn from the Deloitte audit that was underway in Feb. 2013.

Emails filed with the court as evidence show Wright and other senior aides in the PMO discussing how Sen. Irving Gerstein was going to speak to a contact at Deloitte about the audit. That contact was company partner Michael Runia.

The Conservative Party is also a client of Deloitte.

“I have been on the phone constantly with Gerstein who has been trying to arrange the necessary commitments from Deloitte…,” parliamentary affairs manager Patrick Rogers wrote.

And in another email, Rogers writes. “The Senator will call back once we have Deloitte locked in.”

But Wright has disagreed emphatically with the characterization that he meddled or wanted to meddle in Deloitte’s audit of Duffy’s expenses.

Wright said he simply wanted the Senate committee to change the terms of the Deloitte audit to remove Duffy, since he says Duffy’s repayment of expenses would render the study moot.

He says when he couldn’t ascertain whether Tkachuk was making the plan happen, he dispatched Gerstein to approach his Deloitte contacts to see if the firm and Tkachuk were indeed talking.

As Wright put it, he wanted Gerstein to “close the loop between the contractor and the client here.”

Bayne was having none of this.

A subsequent PMO email lists information that Gerstein has apparently gleaned from his contact at Deloitte.

“Just heard from Gerstein,” Rogers writes. “Here’s the latest and most useful information yet from Deloitte. Any repayments will not change Deloitte’s conclusions because they were asked to opine on residency. However, they can’t reach a conclusion on residency because Duffy’s lawyer has not provided them anything.”

“Sir, your career is in business, there are agreements that are negotiated, contracts that are negotiated,” Bayne put to Wright. “If discussions are strictly confidential, they’re not to be leaked. As a lawyer, you know what strictly confidential means. You know what the words mean.”

“I know what their common sense meaning is, yes,” Wright responded.

After receiving the information about Deloitte through Gerstein, Duffy is counselled to no longer co-operate with the audit.

An auditor from Deloitte who appeared before the internal economy committee in 2013 denied anyone close to the audit divulged any information.

“He wanted to know if Sen. Duffy were to repay (his expenses), how much would it amount to,” Gary Timm said of Runia.

“I said I couldn’t tell him, I couldn’t disclose any confidential information to him — that was the gist of the conversation.”

The Canadian Press asked Gerstein this past June to explain his role in the Deloitte matter, but the senator did not respond to the question. He told the RCMP in 2013 that he had indeed contacted Runia, and that Runia told him that the Duffy audit would continue despite Duffy’s repayment.

Runia echoed Gerstein’s version in his own discussion with police.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

COVID-19. (Image courtesy CDC)
Alberta reports 1,731 new COVID-19 cases on Saturday

The province’s central zone has 992 active cases

Collin Orthner, manager at McBain Camera in downtown Red Deer, stands behind the store’s counter on Saturday. (Photo by Sean McIntosh/Advocate staff)
A few Red Deer businesses happy with Black Friday results

While this year’s Black Friday wasn’t as successful as it was in… Continue reading

Le Chateau Inc. is the latest Canadian firm to start producing personal protective equipment for health care workers, in a July 3, 2020 story. (Photo by THE CANADIAN PRESS)
Hundreds of millions of dollars for frontline workers yet to be released, says Alberta Federation of Labour

Information recently released by the Alberta Federation of Labour suggests more than… Continue reading

Red Deer RCMP say a 30-year-old man faces sexual charges against a teen. (File photo by Advocate staff)
Man killed in two-vehicle collision near Penhold, says Blackfalds RCMP

A 46-year-old man is dead following a two-vehicle collision on Highway 42… Continue reading

Idyllic winter scenes are part of the atmosphere of the holiday season, and are depicted in many seasonal movies. How much do you know about holiday movies? Put your knowledge to the test. (Pixabay.com)
QUIZ: Test your knowledge of holiday movies and television specials

The festive season is a time for relaxing and enjoying some seasonal favourites

Banff National Park. (The Canadian Press)
Study finds train speed a top factor in wildlife deaths in Banff, Yoho national parks

EDMONTON — A study looking at 646 wildlife deaths on railway tracks… Continue reading

Cows on pasture at the University of Vermont dairy farm eat hay Thursday, July 23, 2020, in Burlington, Vt. Canadian dairy farmers are demanding compensation from the government because of losses to their industry they say have been caused by a series of international trade deals. THE CANADIAN PRESS/AP-Lisa Rathke
Feds unveil more funding for dairy, poultry and egg farmers hurt by free trade deals

OTTAWA — Canadian egg and poultry farmers who’ve lost domestic market share… Continue reading

Chief Public Health Officer of Canada Dr. Theresa Tam speaks during a news conference on the COVID-19 pandemic in Ottawa, on Friday, Nov. 20, 2020. Canada's top doctor says the country is still on a troubling track for new COVID-19 infections as case counts continue mounting in much of the country. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Justin Tang
COVID-19 cases in Canada remain on troubling course, Tam says, amid rising numbers

Canada’s top doctor says the country is still on a troubling track… Continue reading

hay
Hay’s Daze: Giraffe knows filling wishes can sometimes be a tall order

Last weekend, I had a lovely breakfast. “So what?” you may say.… Continue reading

A person enters a building as snow falls in Ottawa, Sunday, Nov. 22, 2020. Ottawa has been successful in limiting the spread of COVID-19 during its second wave thanks to the city’s residents who have been wearing masks and staying home, said Ottawa’s medical officer of health Dr. Vera Etches. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Justin Tang
People to thank for Ottawa’s success with curbing COVID-19: health officer

The city’s chief medical officer said much of the credit goes to the people who live in Ottawa

NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh asks a question during question period in the House of Commons on Parliament Hill, in Ottawa, Thursday, Nov. 26, 2020. NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh says tonight's public video gaming session with Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez is about reaching young people where they hang. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick
NDP leader stoked over ‘epic crossover’ in video gaming sesh with AOC

Singh and AOC discussed importance of universal pharmacare, political civility, a living wage

A south view of the Ward Hunt Ice Shelf breaking apart is seen from Ward Hunt Island, Nunavut, in an Aug. 20, 2011, handout photo. The remote area in the northern reach of the Nunavut Territory, has seen ice cover shrink from over 4 metres thick in the 1950s to complete loss, according to scientists, during recent years of record warming. Scientists are urging the federal government to permanently protect a vast stretch of Canada's remotest High Arctic called the Last Ice Area. THE CANADIAN PRESS/HO-CEN/Laval University, *MANDATORY CREDIT*
Scientists urge permanent protection of Last Ice Area in Canada’s High Arctic

Tuvaijuittuq has the thickest and oldest ice in the Arctic

In this file photo, a lotto Max ticket is shown in Toronto on Monday Feb. 26, 2018. (By THE CANADIAN PRESS)
No winning ticket for Friday night’s $55 million Lotto Max jackpot

No winning ticket was sold for the $55 million jackpot in Friday… Continue reading

Most Read