Police settle lawsuit by protester for $50,000

HARTFORD, Conn. — Connecticut officials have agreed to pay $50,000 to settle a lawsuit by a sobriety checkpoint protester whose camera recorded state troopers making up what he said were bogus charges against him, a civil liberties group announced Friday.

The lawsuit in federal court centred on the encounter between Michael Picard, of East Hartford, and three troopers — Trooper John Barone, Master Sgt. Patrick Torneo and Sgt. John Jacobi — at a sobriety checkpoint in West Hartford on Sept. 11, 2015. An internal affairs investigation cleared the troopers of any wrongdoing.

“In a free society, it is normal and necessary for people to protest the government, including police,” Picard said in a statement Friday. “I hope my story sends a message to police departments that they cannot ignore the constitution without consequences.”

The lawsuit was brought on Picard’s behalf by the American Civil Liberties Union of Connecticut, which announced the settlement.

Messages seeking comment were left with state police and the state attorney general’s office, which defended the troopers in the lawsuit.

Picard alleged the troopers fabricated charges against him, not knowing they were being recorded by his camera after they seized it. The officers also seized Picard’s legally carried pistol.

The troopers are heard, but not seen, on Picard’s recording calling a Hartford police officer to see if he or she had any “grudges” against Picard, initiating an investigation of him in a police database and discussing a previous protest Picard organized, the lawsuit said.

After finding that Picard had a valid pistol permit, Barone tells the other troopers they have to “cover” themselves, and either Torneo or Jacobi said, “Let’s give him something,” the lawsuit said.

The troopers wrote Picard infraction tickets for illegal use of a highway by a pedestrian and creating a public disturbance — charges that were later dropped by prosecutors.

“Michael was exercising his peaceful, lawful right to protest when Connecticut State Police seized his camera without a warrant and undermined his First Amendment right to protest and record them,” said Dan Barrett, legal director of the ACLU of Connecticut. “Police must understand, and this agreement shows, that they ultimately must answer to the Constitution.”

The state police internal affairs investigator, Stavros Mellekas, now the commanding officer of state police, wrote in his report that the troopers were justified in issuing the infractions. He cited reports about Picard waving a gun at the scene and evidence that he illegally stood on a highway on-ramp.

Picard is also suing Stamford’s police chief over Picard’s 2018 arrest for protesting the arrest of a friend, who was charged while warning people that police were ticketing drivers for cellphone use.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Peaceful anti-racism protest scheduled in Red Deer Monday at noon

A peaceful protest is scheduled at noon at Red Deer City Hall… Continue reading

Sylvan Lake RCMP put out call to help find missing man

Vehicle found in Rocky Mountain House area

‘It’s unsettling:’ Ranchers and feedlots worried about future impact of COVID-19

CREMONA, Alta. — A cacophony of bellowing cattle makes it hard to… Continue reading

Protests spark virus fears in US; South Korea sees new cases

MIAMI — Protests around the U.S. against police brutality have sparked fears… Continue reading

Feelings of guilt are behind America’s racial anguish

It’s been a bad week in the United States: six nights of… Continue reading

Canada’s Olympic, Paralympic athletes return to sport with help of $5 million

TORONTO — Canada’s Olympic and Paralympic athletes will return to sport with… Continue reading

MLS players agree to concessions to return to action at Orlando tournament

TORONTO — MLS players have approved taking part in a summer tournament… Continue reading

Ricky Martin makes ‘Pausa’ to channel newly found anxiety

NEW YORK — The world paused and for the first time in… Continue reading

A superhero kid with autism shines in new PBS Kids’ series

NEW YORK — There’s a new crop of superheroes coming to our… Continue reading

SpaceX’s historic encore: Astronauts arrive at space station

SpaceX Dragon capsule pulled up to the station and docked automatically

Ottawa pledges millions to promote holiday travel in Canada during pandemic

Funding announced include $30 million originally earmarked for attracting foreign visitors

Most Read