Proposal to eliminate most preliminary inquiries panned by Red Deer lawyer association

Federal government considering dropping most preliminary inquiries to ease court backlog

A proposal to eliminate preliminary hearings in almost all criminal cases is not the answer to court backlogs says a Red Deer representative for criminal defence lawyers.

Under Bill C-75, introduced in Parliament in late March, preliminary inquiries, would be unavailable unless the criminal offence carries a maximum penalty of life in prison.

The government estimates the move would eliminate almost 90 per cent of the 9,100 preliminary hearings held in Canada each year. The move is meant to carve into a backlog of court cases that has been drawing increasing attention.

How slowly the wheels of justice turn has taken on a new urgency in the courts since a 2016 Supreme Court of Canada decision. The court set deadlines for when cases must go to trial or be resolved: 18 months to get from charges to trial in provincial court with no preliminary inquiry and 30 months for trials in superior court with some exceptions.

It is not uncommon for defence lawyers to make Jordan applications when they believe their client’s right to a timely trial has been violated.

Red Deer defence lawyer Jason Snider does not believe eliminating most preliminary hearings – which are used to determine if the Crown has enough evidence to go to trial – will do what the government hopes.

Preliminary inquiries routinely streamline the court process by determining relatively early in the court process that there is not enough evidence to go to trial and use up valuable court time on a weak case, said Snider, president of the Red Deer Criminal Defence Lawyers Association.

Snider called the proposal to ditch most preliminary inquiries a “false economy.”

Preliminary inquiries are a useful way to resolve cases without having them elevated to the Court of Queen’s Bench, which is already short of judges and has lengthy wait times for trials, he said.

“My experience with preliminary inquiries is that a third to half of the files I have that go through a preliminary inquiry are resolved without ever having had to go to trial.”

Most of the cases that wind up in the criminal justice system result in convictions of some kind. However, accused are routinely only found guilty of some of the charges laid against them.

“A lot of time it’s just a matter of what the appropriate level of criminal responsibility is and determining that,” said Snider, who is also a former Red Deer Crown prosecutor.

“Sometimes, that just requires a couple of witnesses for a preliminary inquiry not a full-blown trial.”

Snider offers an example from his own experience. A client was facing 14 different charges in relation to an incident where she fled from police.

At the preliminary inquiry, his client pleaded guilty to the flight-from-police charge and one other and the Crown prosecutor dropped the remaining counts.

If a preliminary inquiry was not an option, the case would have been set for trial in Court of Queen’s Bench, with a multi-day trial date set likely 18 months down the road. At trial, the matter would likely have been resolved within hours of the trial starting, leaving a block of wasted court days.

Pushing more cases into Court of Queen’s Bench, which is already short of judges, would likely have a ripple effect through the court system.

Unlike provincial court judges, who spend 90 per cent of their time on criminal cases, Court of Queen’s Bench justices deal with criminal matters only about a quarter of their time. Justices spend a lot of time dealing with family matters, civil cases, wills and estates.

Increasing justices’ criminal workload means it will take longer to get decisions in other cases, he said.

Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter

Editor note — An incomplete version of this story appeared in Friday’s Red Deer Advocate.

Just Posted

Red Deer property taxes to go up 2.15 per cent in 2019

City council approves $369.8 million budget

Sylvan Lake council approves concept plan for new park

Pogadl Park will eventally be home to numerous ball diamonds and sports fields

One person dead after collision on Highway 2A

Pickup truck and grain truck collided on Highway 2A south of Carstairs

Updated: Trial stalls for man accused in fatal Canada Day 2016 crash

Defence lawyer argued relevant information received only hours before trial to begin

Trudeau says politicians shouldn’t prey on Canadians’ fears

The Prime Minister was speaking at a townhall in Ontario

UPDATE: B.C. boy, aunt missing for three days

The pair are missing from Kamloops

Liberal bows out of byelection after singling out Jagmeet Singh’s race

Karen Wang says she made comments online that referenced Singh’s cultural background

Shooter pleads guilty to manslaughter in Stettler

A Stettler man charged with second-degree murder has pleaded guilty to manslaughter.… Continue reading

Kentucky canoe outfit borrows photo of Trudeau family to market business

They are in a red canoe, all clad in life jackets, and Sophie Gregoire Trudeau and Ella-Grace are waving

Police chief confirms all three Ottawa bus victims were on board when it crashed

OTTAWA — All three people killed in last week’s deadly bus accident… Continue reading

Theresa May wins no-confidence vote after Brexit deal rejection

UK PM can keep her job, after House of Commons voted 325-306

Alberta doctor accused of sexual assault asked to voluntarily give up practice

College says Dr. Barry Wollach should discontinue his practice, given the seriousness of the allegation against him

Speedy acceptance of Saudi shows refugee system’s flaws

Who would not wish Rahaf Mohammed well? The 18-year-old Saudi wants to… Continue reading

Most Read