Quebec judge who asked woman to remove hijab in court offers apology

Quebec judge who asked woman to remove hijab in court offers apology

Quebec judge who asked woman to remove hijab in court offers apology

MONTREAL — A Quebec judge who refused to allow a Muslim woman to appear in court wearing a hijab apologized on Tuesday, more than five years after the incident occurred.

A letter of apology from Quebec court Judge Eliana Marengo was read out at a hearing of the province’s judicial council as part of a hearing to determine whether the disciplinary process against her should be ended.

In the letter, Marengo apologizes for having refused to hear Rania El-Alloul’s 2015 case unless she removed her hijab.

Marengo told El-Alloul at the time the courtroom was a secular space and she was violating rules requiring suitable dress.

In the letter read on Tuesday, Marengo told El-Alloul that the comment she made, which included comparing the hijab to a hat or sunglasses, “was simply meant to exemplify how the rules of decorum are generally applied in the courtroom, and was most certainly not meant to disrespect you or your beliefs,” she wrote.

“Finally, Ms. El-Alloul, I would like to offer you my most sincere apologies, which I hope you will accept.”

Marengo acknowledged that she was wrong in her interpretation of the law and promised to apply the rules correctly in the future.

In a letter of response read during Tuesday’s hearing, El-Alloul, who had gone to court in 2015 to reclaim a seized vehicle, said she accepted the apology because “this is what my faith teaches me.”

“I hope she understands the pain she caused me and why it is so important for her to account for her actions,” she said in reference to Marengo.

El-Alloul said her main motivation in pursuing the matter was to obtain a judgment affirming the right to wear religious clothing in court, which was granted by Quebec’s highest court in 2018.

“Our justice system is not made for some and not others,” she said. ”No, this is a democracy where everyone is to be treated equally before the law.”

The apology is the latest step in a long legal saga. The judge’s 2015 comments triggered numerous complaints to the Conseil de la magistrature, the judicial council that hears complaints against Quebec-appointed judges.

It decided some were founded and formed a committee to investigate Marengo’s conduct in June 2016.

Marengo asked Quebec Superior Court to force the judicial council to end its investigation, arguing it had breached the principle of judicial independence, but lost in February 2017 and on appeal a year later.

In October 2018, the Court of Appeal ruled in a separate case that obliging El-Alloul to remove her Muslim head scarf was a violation of her fundamental rights. It said in a unanimous decision that citizens who wear religious attire cannot be denied access to justice and that freedom of religious expression doesn’t stop at the courtroom door.

Tuesday’s hearing of the judicial council was called to evaluate Marengo’s request to end the disciplinary procedures launched against her following the incident.

The proposal, which included the apology, was jointly submitted by lawyers representing Marengo and those assigned to the investigation.

At the hearing, lawyers argued in favour of ending the process, citing the sincerity of Marengo’s apology, the fact that there have been no further complaints against her and the fact that the case has already served to clarify and highlight the rights of those with sincerely held religious beliefs.

However, the council also heard from one of the complainants in the process, who argued in a written submission that dismissing the case based on an apology would send a signal that judges could act with “impunity” as long as they apologized later.

The committee will review the evidence to decide whether the case meets the criteria for ending the process. No date was given for the decision.

This report by The Canadian Press was first published Sept. 8, 2020

Morgan Lowrie, The Canadian Press

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau holds a press conference at Rideau Cottage during the COVID pandemic in Ottawa on Tuesday, Dec. 1, 2020. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick
Feds spending plan heads to confidence vote as provinces seek more health-care cash

OTTAWA — Provinces are criticizing the federal Liberals for failing to signal… Continue reading

In this Tuesday, Oct. 27, 2020 file photo, Herman Termeer, 54, stands on the roof of his home as the Blue Ridge Fire burns along the hillside in Chino Hills, Calif. An overheating world obliterated weather records in 2020 — an extreme year for hurricanes, wildfires, heat waves, floods, droughts and ice melt — the United Nations’ weather agency reported Wednesday, Dec. 2, 2020. (AP Photo/Jae C. Hong)
UN calls on humanity to end ‘war on nature,’ go carbon-free

As an extreme year for hurricanes, wildfires and heat waves comes to… Continue reading

John Lambert
Military identifies remains of Newfoundland soldier killed in Belgium in 1917

OTTAWA — More than 100 years after a young soldier from Newfoundland… Continue reading

Military police officers carry a bag filled with money left behind by armed bank robbers, in Criciuma, Santa Catarina state, Brazil, Tuesday, Dec. 1, 2020. Dozens of criminals armed with assault rifles invaded the city in southern Brazil overnight and took control of the streets as they assaulted a local bank. (Guilherme Hahn/Futura Press via AP)
Massed Brazilian bank robbers attack another city, kill 1

RIO DE JANEIRO — A large gang of heavily armed bank robbers… Continue reading

(Black Press file photo.)
Red Deer city council holds closed-door discussion about proposed aquatics centre

Recommended design, cost and location won’t be made public until next spring

In this May 16, 2019, file photo, Salesforce chairman Marc Benioff speaks during a news conference, in Indianapolis. In a deal announced Tuesday, Dec. 1, 2020, business software pioneer is buying work-chatting service Slack for $27.7 billion in a deal aimed at giving the two companies a better shot at competing against longtime industry powerhouse Microsoft. (AP Photo/Darron Cummings, File)
Salesforce buying work-chat service Slack for $27.7 billion

SAN RAMON, Calif. — Business software pioneer is buying work-chatting service… Continue reading

Dr. Anthony Fauci, director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases speaks remotely during a Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee hearing on Capitol Hill on May 12, 2020 in Washington, DC. The committee is hearing testimony from members of the White House Coronavirus Task Force on how to safely open the country and get America back to work and school. (Win McNamee/Getty Images/TNS)
People magazine reveals its ‘2020 People of the Year’

LOS ANGELES — People magazine has named George Clooney, Dr. Anthony Fauci,… Continue reading

Zeke Thurston, of Big Valley, Alta., rides Lunatic Party during saddle bronc rodeo semi-final action at the Calgary Stampede in Calgary, Sunday, July 14, 2019. Thurston is among five Canadians competing in the 2020 world championship of rodeo Dec. 3-12 in Arlington, Texas. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jeff McIntosh
Rough ride to National Finals Rodeo for Canadians in pandemic season

Levi Simpson and his horse Stetson are about to trample the turf… Continue reading

Team Manitoba celebrate after defeating Team Ontario to win the Scotties Tournament of Hearts in Moose Jaw, Sask., Sunday, Feb. 23, 2020. Curling Canada wants Calgary's Canada Olympic Park to be a curling hub for the season's top events. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jonathan Hayward
CP NewsAlert: Calgary facility set to become curling hub during pandemic

CP NewsAlert: Calgary facility set to become curling hub during pandemic

Toronto FC coach Greg Vanney watches late in the second half of the team's MLS Cup soccer match against the Seattle Sounders on Sunday, Nov. 10, 2019, in Seattle. Vanney has stepped down as coach of Toronto FC. THE CANADIAN PRESS/AP Photo-Elaine Thompson
Toronto FC coach Greg Vanney steps down, says it’s the right time to move on

Toronto FC coach Greg Vanney steps down, says it’s the right time to move on

Hamilton Forge FC's Giuliano Frano (8) heads the ball against CD Olimpia's Jorge Benguche (9) during Scotiabank CONCACAF League 2019 second half soccer action in Hamilton, Ontario on Thursday, August 22, 2019. Forge FC looks to win its way into the Scotiabank CONCACAF Champions League on Tuesday when it takes on Haiti's Arcahaie FC in the quarterfinals of the CONCACAF League, a 22-team feeder competition that sends six clubs to CONCACAF's elite club tournament. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Peter Power
Forge FC loses penalty shootout to Haitian side in CONCACAF League quarterfinal

Forge FC loses penalty shootout to Haitian side in CONCACAF League quarterfinal

Public health must balance science and society: former top doctor

Public health must balance science and society: former top doctor

California boat captain indicted in fire that killed 34

California boat captain indicted in fire that killed 34

Most Read