RCMP terrorism sting based on ‘deceit and tricks,’ must be condemned: lawyer

Illegal police tactics during an undercover operation that led a couple to be found guilty of terrorism-related offences endanger public rights, shock the conscience of Canadians and must be strongly condemned, says a statement of defence filed in B.C. Supreme Court.

VANCOUVER — Illegal police tactics during an undercover operation that led a couple to be found guilty of terrorism-related offences endanger public rights, shock the conscience of Canadians and must be strongly condemned, says a statement of defence filed in B.C. Supreme Court.

John Nuttall and his common-law wife Amanda Korody were convicted last year, but the convictions are on hold while their lawyers argue that the RCMP entrapped their clients to plant what they believed were pressure-cooker bombs at the B.C. legislature.

Nuttall’s lawyer, Marilyn Sandford, told the court Tuesday that the Mounties used deceit and tricks at virtually every stage of an elaborate sting.

The law is designed to capture people on the periphery of terrorist action but not directly involved in an offence.

Sandford said police aided and abetted terrorist activity by helping the couple design, construct and transport the homemade explosives.

“It matters not that the RCMP knew the devices would not explode,” she said. “The RCMP knowingly facilitated terrorist activity.”

Nuttall and Karody were arrested in July 2013 after an undercover operation that began five months earlier.

Sandford criticized what she called a lack of oversight on the operation, suggesting it would not have continued for as long had it been properly communicated to RCMP superiors in Ottawa.

“Clearly, there is something inherently problematic about (police) setting up a pretend terrorist group,” she said. “All of this ought to have been carefully considered.”

The sting went from gathering intelligence about Nuttall, whose outspoken views on radical Islam had already flagged him to police, to an operation designed to see whether undercover operators could induce him to commit terrorist acts, Sandford said.

“There’s nothing inherently wrong with targeting (a suspect) … based on these facts. But it’s the nature of the operation and the direction it took that became problematic,” she said.

“Once their investigations had not uncovered anything as far as evidence of actual criminal activity they couldn’t then leapfrog into providing the opportunity. And that’s exactly what happened.”

The statement of defence said Nuttall and Korody were promises new lives, future work, care for their cat, payment of debt and assistance going through drug withdrawal.

The lonely and isolated pair were misled about basic tenets of their new faith and their fears were stoked by suggestions that powerful terrorist associates were keeping tabs on them, the statement said.

Closing arguments are scheduled to run until the end of next week and the Crown is expected to start making its final case on Thursday.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Weinstein conviction sends right message, says advocate

“Don’t stay in silence because we can make this end one day”

One actor tackles 33 zany characters in CAT’s social satire, Fully Committed

Ash Mercia is taking on an actor’s biggest challenge

Sylvan Lakers asked for playground input

Town has set aside $250,000 to replace Centennial Park playground

Alberta legislature resumes: Focus on jobs and bill to punish protesters

EDMONTON — A new legislature sitting has begun with the Alberta government… Continue reading

Your community calendar

Feb. 19 A Liberation of Holland event is being held at the… Continue reading

Bucks defeat Raptors in battle of Eastern Conference heavyweights

Bucks 108 Raptors 97 TORONTO — Khris Middleton scored 22 points as… Continue reading

Monahan, Backlund score 2G each, Flames beat Bruins 5-2

Flames 5 Bruins 2 BOSTON — Sean Monahan scored a pair of… Continue reading

Canadian Pacific obtains injunction to end Mohawk rail blockade in Kahnawake

MONTREAL — Canadian Pacific Railway obtained an injunction Tuesday aimed at ending… Continue reading

Alberta legislature resumes: Focus on jobs and bill to punish protesters

EDMONTON — A new session of the Alberta legislature began Tuesday with… Continue reading

Red Deer realtor is Century 21’s best seller worldwide

Nobody sold more units than Gavin Heintz among company’s 139,000 realtors

Red Deer District Community Foundation looking for volunteer board members

The Red Deer & District Community Foundation is looking for new board… Continue reading

Feds seek 21 months for Hot Pockets heiress in college scam

BOSTON — Prosecutors are seeking nearly two years in prison for an… Continue reading

Most Read