Red Deer Lawyer Andrew Phypers
Photo from Advocate Law

Red Deer lawyer going to Supreme Court to argue against minimum sentences for fentanyl trafficking

Andrew Phypers says minimum sentences interfere with sentencing judge’s decision making

A Red Deer lawyer is heading to the Supreme Court of Canada to argue a case involving minimum prison sentences for fentanyl trafficking.

The high court has agreed to jointly hear the appeals of two men who received stiffer penalties when Alberta’s Court of Appeal ruled that convictions for wholesale fentanyl trafficking should carry a minimum sentence of nine years.

Andrew Phypers and Calgary lawyer Jared Craig represent Patrick Douglas Felix, who was sentenced to two concurrent 10-year terms.

The original sentencing judge gave him a seven-year sentence in March 2019 after Felix pleaded guilty to two counts of trafficking fentanyl and two counts of trafficking cocaine in Fort McMurray.

According to court records, Felix sold undercover RCMP officers nearly 2,400 fentanyl pills and 2.5 kilograms of cocaine worth about $173,000 in what was described as a “sophisticated fentanyl and cocaine trafficking operation.”

Felix told police undercover officers he was making $40,000 to $60,000 per month from the business.

In a separate case, Cameron O’Lynn Parranto was sentenced to two consecutive seven-year terms on counts of trafficking in fentanyl as a result of the minimum penalty.

Parranto was arrested in Edmonton in 2016 and police recovered fentanyl pills, cocaine, morphine, methamphetamine, oxycodone and a loaded handgun.

He is represented by Edmonton lawyer Paul Moreau.

Phypers is looking forward to a chance to argue his case in the highest court in the land. Only about six per cent of leaves to appeal — in which lawyers make their case why their issue should be addressed by the court — are granted.

“It’s an exciting opportunity, because very few lawyers get to attend to the Supreme Court of Canada,” said Phypers, who has practised law since 2012.

“It is also exciting because we’re challenging start-point sentence as a valid sentencing tool.”

While Phypers and Craig will focus specifically on fentanyl sentencing, if they prevail, it will have much wider implications.

“It will really be a challenge to start-point sentencing as an instrument to sentencing,” said Phypers.

There is no set starting point for sentences for most crimes. Drug crimes are among the exceptions.

For instance, the sentence starts at three years for someone convicted of commercial-scale cocaine or methamphetamine trafficking, increasing to four years for a wholesale trafficker.

If the drug is heroin, a commercial-scale trafficker’s sentence starts at five years.

Starting-point sentences are also in place for sexual assaults. Someone convicted of a “major sexual assault” faces a minimum of three years.

Among the problems with setting minimum sentencing points, is it they are not consistent across Canada, said Phypers.

“Alberta will sentence different than B.C. Alberta will sentence different than out east. It’s a very uneven application nationally of how people are sentenced in drug sentences.”

Alberta is on par with some provinces, but tougher than others.

“What we will argue is it should be an individualized process, best left behind in the hands of the sentencing judge,” he said.

“The sentencing judge is in the best position to see the personal circumstances of the offender and the gravity of the offence, instead of this uneven application based on the type of offence it is.”

Phypers said starting points have a “chilling effect” on a judge’s ability to impose what they see as a fit punishment.

In their leave to appeal, Phypers and Craig write that starting-point sentencing acts as both a “straight jacket” that limits individualized sentencing, and a “blunt instrument” used to justify longer prison sentences.

The starting-point system also “leads to increased rates of incarceration for marginalized socio-economic groups — those suffering from poverty, mental health issues and addiction.

“In certain cases, it perpetuates systematic discrimination.”

As usual, the Supreme Court gave no reason for agreeing to hear the matter.

The court will likely not hear Phypers’ and Craig’s case for six months to a year from now.



pcowley@reddeeradvocate.com

Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter

fentanylSupreme Court

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

A stainless steel monolith is set up along the eastern slopes of the Rocky Mountains in Alberta, in a Jan. 15, 2021 story. (Photo by THE CANADIAN PRESS)
Alberta monolith comes with message to save eastern slopes of Rocky Mountains

Installed it with the help of volunteers after getting permission from private landowners

Harvest Meats is recalling a brand of Polish sausages. (Photo by Canadian Food Inspection Agency)
Harvest Meats recalls sausages over undercooking

Recall affects customers in Alberta

TSA officers wear protective masks at a security screening area at Seattle-Tacoma International Airport Monday, May 18, 2020, in SeaTac, Wash. Airlines say they are stepping up security on flights to Washington before next week’s inauguration of President-elect Joe Biden. Delta, United and Alaska airlines said Thursday, Jan. 14, 2021 they will bar passengers flying to Washington from putting guns in checked bags. (AP Photo/Elaine Thompson)
Most major US airlines ban guns in luggage for DC flights

Bans start Saturday and run through Inauguration Day until Jan. 23

Art McDonald, then the new head of the navy, addressed the audience at the Royal Canadian Navy change of command ceremony in Halifax on June 12, 2019. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Andrew Vaughan
New defence chief apologizes to victims of military sexual misconduct, hate

McDonald promised to work to root out discrimination and harassment

The provincial government released its 2021 wheat midge forecast recently. (File photo by The Canadian Press)
2021 forecast shows increase in wheat midge risk in parts of Alberta

The provincial government’s wheat midge forecast for 2021 shows an increase in… Continue reading

Lesser Slave Lake UCP MLA Pat Rehn. (Facebook)
Updated: Jason Kenney kicks Lesser Slave Lake MLA out of caucus

Pat Rehn will not be permitted to run for UCP nominations

FILE - In this July 26, 2019, file photo, China’s Sun Yang leaves the pool deck following the men’s 4x200m freestyle relay heats at the World Swimming Championships in Gwangju, South Korea. The World Anti-Doping Agency says a Swiss court has overturned an eight-year doping ban against Chinese swimmer Sun Yang and ordered the case back to the Court of Arbitration for Sport for a second time but with a different chairman of the judges. (AP Photo/Mark Schiefelbein, File)
Swiss supreme court details anti-China bias of Sun judge

Hostile social media posts by Court of Arbitration for Sport judge Franco Frattini

FILE - In this Saturday, March 7, 2020, file photo, Minnesota Wild defenseman Matt Dumba passes the puck during the first period of an NHL hockey game against the Los Angeles Kings in Los Angeles. Bonding between veterans and youngsters has been a time-honored tradition in hockey. But in yet another setback related to the relentless COVID-19, NHL protocols aiming to curb the virus spread and keep the schedule on track could make that vital off-ice development of camaraderie more difficult. (AP Photo/Mark J. Terrill, File)
Mentors wanted: Virus limits vet-rookie time away from rink

Bonding between veterans and youngsters has been a time-honoured tradition

FILE - In this Jan. 30, 2020 file photo, NFL Super Bowl 54 football game halftime performer Jennifer Lopez answers questions at a news conference in Miami. Lopez will give a musical performance on the West Front of the U.S. Capitol when Biden is sworn in as the nation’s 46th president next Wednesday. (AP Photo/David J. Phillip)
Stars return to inauguration, with J.Lo, Gaga set to perform

Foo Fighters, John Legend and Bruce Springsteen will offer remote performances

An example of a child’s artwork during the COVID-19 pandemic is shown in a handout. Many of the children’s drawings show people alone, haunted by shadowy spectres, or worse, their own thoughts.The researcher behind the childart.ca project says the virtual gallery of illustrations by Canadian kids and teenagers showcases a wide variety of visions of the pandemic. THE CANADIAN PRESS/HO-childart.ca
‘This is too much’: Art shows children’s struggles during pandemic, says researcher

Recurring themes include confined figures, screaming faces and gory imagery

blessing
Bentley Blessing Pantry continues to faithfully serve the community

‘We just wanted to make everyone aware that we are still here to serve you throughout this coming year.’

FILE - In this file photo dated Sunday, Nov. 29, 2020, Pope Francis holds his pastoral staff as he arrives to celebrate Mass, at St. Peter's Basilica. Pope Francis has changed church law to explicitly allow women to do more things during Mass, Monday Jan. 11, 2021, while reaffirming they cannot be priests. (AP Photo/Gregorio Borgia, FILE)
Pope says women can read at Mass, but still can’t be priests

Pope says women can read at Mass, but still can’t be priests

Winnipeg Jets' Patrik Laine (29) and Kyle Connor (81) celebrate Laine’s goal during opening game first period NHL action against the Calgary Flames, in Winnipeg, Thursday, Jan. 14, 2021. Laine scored his second goal of the game in overtime, and the Winnipeg Jets started their season with a 4-3 win over the Calgary Flames Thursday. THE CANADIAN PRESS/John Woods
Laine’s three-point night earns Winnipeg Jets 4-3 OT win over Calgary Flames

Laine’s three-point night earns Winnipeg Jets 4-3 OT win over Calgary Flames

Shin Wook Lim, 45, is shown in this undated police handout photo. A former Taekwondo Canada coach has been found guilty of sexual assault and other sex-related offences involving a teenage student. Shin Wook Lim pleaded not guilty to 15 charges involving two female students, including sexual assault and sexual interference. THE CANADIAN PRESS/HO - Toronto Police Services
Former Taekwondo Canada coach found guilty of sex-related offences involving student

Former Taekwondo Canada coach found guilty of sex-related offences involving student

Most Read