A proposed gravel operation west of Innisfail is opposed by some residents who say excavation within a flood plain is ill-advised. (Black Press file photo).

Some Red Deer County residents oppose a gravel pit proposed for a flood-prone area

Howell’s Excavation co-owner says the proposal meets or exceeds standards

Some Red Deer County residents deeply oppose a gravel pit operation they say is proposed for a flood plain west of Innisfail.

The Medicine Flats Aquifer Committee, as well as some members of the Red Deer Fish and Game Association, fear flooding in the region will be exacerbated and groundwater contaminated from the proposed 121-acre operation.

The gravel pit, at Highway 54 and Range Road 20, about 14 kilometres west of Innisfail, has already been approved by Red Deer County and is now being considered by Alberta Environment.

But Dale Christian, a member of the aquifer committee, believes it would be ill-advised to allow more ground removal from an area that’s already prone to flooding.

She said the gravel substrate provides a natural reservoir for the storage of snow melt.

Provincial studies show river courses are already unstable in this area, she added, noting significant spring flooding happened in the area in 2005 and 2013, washing out roads and covering part of Highway 54.

Local conservationist Doug Wood fears potential damage to a popular fishing creek, formed by water seeping up from the ground.

“There is gravel all over Alberta — so why here?” he wondered.

“It would be wrong to permit this to proceed,” added Wood. “It’s against everything that the Alberta Fish and Game and other environmental groups advocate. ”

The gravel pit proposed by Howell’s Excavating Ltd. would entail up to 80 truckloads a day of gravel being removed in peak season. It would be used for road and construction projects.

Dusty Howell, a company co-owner, said the proposal meets or exceeds municipal and provincial standards.

Howell maintains only a small portion of the proposed site lies within the “fringe” of a flood plain — and none of it is on an actual flood way. If the gravel operation was going to be environmentally damaging, he said, the company would not have put it forward.

The 15- to 20-year gravel operation would include crushing, washing, sorting and mixing at the site.

While opponents fear asphalt operations could be applied for as a future variance, Howell said this will not happen: “We’re not in the asphalt business.”

The project was approved by the county by a narrow vote. But Dave Dittrick, assistant Red Deer County manager, noted Howell’s Excavating must live up to 29 municipal conditions if the project goes ahead.

The proposal must also pass provincial environmental testing. Dittrick said water studies are up to Alberta Environment, “it’s not our jurisdiction.”

Opponents of the project question how much scrutiny this proposal will get from the province, which only considers the perspective of “directly affected” residents — usually those living immediately adjacent to the pit.

Christian said several area residents are already dealing with heavy industrial noise, traffic, dust and “chaos” from other gravel pits.

She fears her family farm could now lose its water wells due to siltation from the pit “as we are down-gradient, and our cattle operation will suffer disproportionately.”

Others who depend on downstream drinking water should also be concerned, she added.

Red Deer County

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Anti-racism demonstration was not a ‘peaceful protest,’ as sides spar in Red Deer

Two groups that rallied in Red Deer on Sunday afternoon could only… Continue reading

Addressing anti-mask protests poses a challenge for leaders, experts say

Quebec’s COVID-19 case numbers hit their highest numbers since the end of May

Canada’s Kennedy to yesterday’s man: former PM John Turner dead at 91

Politicians and other public figures immediately began sharing memories

QUIZ: A celebration of apples

September is the start of the apple harvest

Five things to watch for in the Canadian business world in the coming week

The 2020 Global Business Forum in Banff, Alta., will be held as a special hybrid event

New tools, ideas needed to speed up housing strategy funding, CMHC president says

Slow turnaround time on some of its national housing strategy programs

Letter containing ricin sent to White House may have come from Canada: RCMP

The letter contained ricin, a toxic substance found naturally in castor beans

Nunavut reports first confirmed COVID-19 cases, saying both are mine workers

The territory says at this time, there is no evidence of transmission within site

B.C. migrant, undocumented workers rally for permanent residency program

The pandemic has shown how heavily Canada relies on migrant and undocumented workers

Wetaskiwin RCMP make arrests for Hit and Run to residence

Damage estimates are expected to be in excess of $20,000.

Former prime minister John Turner dead at 91

TORONTO — Former prime minister John Turner, whose odyssey from a “Liberal… Continue reading

Hay’s Daze: Happy to be left out of the picture

Talk about being out of the loop. Head in the sand. Uninformed,… Continue reading

Most Read