Murder trial ends in mistrial

Daniel Boyd Sawyer was on trial for second-degree murder

A second-degree murder trial bogged down repeatedly with evidence issues has ended in a mistrial.

Justice Bill Hopkins declared the trial was over for Daniel Boyd Sawyer Monday afternoon after the jury was called back to Red Deer Court of Queen’s Bench.

Defence lawyer Chris Archer confirmed Monday night the judge had “discharged the jury and directed a mistrial.”

Defence lawyers and Crown prosecutors will be back in court Tuesday morning to discuss how to proceed.

Daniel Boyd Sawyer was on trial for second-degree murder for his role in the death of Alan Beach, 31, following a fight outside the Blarney Stone Pub on Nov. 18, 2015.

Sawyer is accused of repeatedly stabbing Beach, who later died in hospital from his injuries.

The seven-woman, five-man jury first heard evidence Nov. 15.

But after only two days of testimony, the trial gave way to increasingly lengthy voir dires in which evidence issues were discussed without the jury present.

It soon became clear that an early estimate that the trial would wrap up around Dec. 7 was going to be well off the mark.

Dec. 12, the jury, which hadn’t heard any evidence in two weeks, was told it would not be needed until Jan. 7.

One witness testified in the morning before the jury — now down to four men and six women — was once again dismissed until Wednesday afternoon when it would be given an update on the status of the trial.

Instead, the jurors found out they were being discharged.

Barbara Hanson testified she saw a man come into the bar covered in blood and clutching a knife after hearing noise outside the pub in the Village Mall.

“There was a lot of commotion at the door at one point around 8:30 (p.m.),” she testified.

Hanson said after the ruckus, a man came into the bar and yelled for somebody to call police.

A short time later, stabbing victim Beach came in with another man. Beach was bleeding from wounds to his face, ribs and leg.

“There was lots of blood on his ribs, and his jeans were ripped and that was the part that was bleeding the most.”

Hanson said she could see a knife, with a design on it, in Beach’s right hand. He headed into a nearby washroom. He came out shortly after and handed the knife and something else she did not see clearly to a blond woman, who then left the bar.

Beach went back into the bathroom. She next saw him being wheeled out on a stretcher by emergency responders.

Hanson said she was interviewed by RCMP at the scene and again the following morning.



pcowley@reddeeradvocate.com

Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter

Court

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

More Albertans are recovering from COVID-19

69 more recoveries Tuesday, bringing the total to 6,048

Mountain snowpack deeper than usual, but flooding will depend on rain

Big floods in 2013 and 2005 both followed major rainfalls in mountains

VIDEO: Procession to honour Snowbirds Capt. Jennifer Casey comes to Halifax

Snowbirds service member died in a crash in Kamloops one week ago

Calgary bans businesses that claim to change sexual orientation or gender identity

Calgary bans businesses that claim to change sexual orientation or gender identity

Canada outspends Ireland, Norway in new pledging on Venezuelan refugee crisis

Canada outspends Ireland, Norway in new pledging on Venezuelan refugee crisis

‘I can’t live on:’ Daughter of man fatally shot by Regina police seeks answers

‘I can’t live on:’ Daughter of man fatally shot by Regina police seeks answers

Alberta legislature to resume with COVID work, other bills, sitting into July

Alberta legislature to resume with COVID work, other bills, sitting into July

Walt Disney World presenting plans for reopening parks

Walt Disney World presenting plans for reopening parks

‘Amazing Race Canada’ wins big on second night of Canadian Screen Awards

‘Amazing Race Canada’ wins big on second night of Canadian Screen Awards

Quebec to loan up to US$200 million to struggling Cirque du Soleil

Quebec to loan up to US$200 million to struggling Cirque du Soleil

UNB board votes to strip name from law faculty building over links to slavery

UNB board votes to strip name from law faculty building over links to slavery

Most Read