Supreme Court to rule on Harper government’s sentencing law for gun crimes

The Supreme Court of Canada is set to rule Tuesday on a key part of the Conservative government’s tough-on-crime agenda. The high court will deliver its ruling in a pair of cases involving mandatory minimum sentences for gun crimes.

OTTAWA — The Supreme Court of Canada is set to rule Tuesday on a key part of the Conservative government’s tough-on-crime agenda.

The high court will deliver its ruling in a pair of cases involving mandatory minimum sentences for gun crimes.

The Ontario Court of Appeal struck down the law in 2013, calling it “cruel and unusual punishment,” so the provincial attorney general and its federal counterpart are appealing the ruling.

The Appeal Court struck down both the three-year mandatory minimum for a first offence of possessing a loaded prohibited gun, as well as the five-year sentence for a second offence.

The Ontario and federal governments are urging the Supreme Court to reverse that ruling, arguing the law does not breach the charter protection against cruel and unusual punishment.

The new sentencing rules were enacted in 2008 as part of a sweeping omnibus bill introduced by the federal Conservatives.

The Ontario ruling is already binding in the province, and can be taken into consideration by judges in other provinces in similar cases.

Tuesday’s ruling will settle the matter nationally.

The high court has agreed to hear two cases, one on each of the two sentencing provisions.

In one case, a young Toronto man with no criminal record was sentenced to three years in prison after pleading guilty to possession of a loaded firearm.

The judge said that had there not been a law calling for a mandatory minimum, he would have sentenced Hussein Nur to 2 1/2 years.

“Parliament’s increase of the mandatory minimum from one year to three years was a forceful response to the dangers posed by the proliferation of handgun possession and a determination to combat this ’serious and growing societal danger,”’ Ontario and the federal government argue in their factum.

“It was open to Parliament to create an aggravated form of firearm possession with enhanced punishment.”

In the second case, Sidney Charles pleaded guilty to firearms offences after he was found in his rooming house bedroom with a loaded and unlicensed semi-automatic handgun. He was sentenced to five years because he had two previous convictions.

In defending the mandatory sentence for repeat offenders, Ottawa and Ontario argue that it is not overly punitive.

“The overall effect of raising some offenders’ sentences to five years is within a reasonable range of legislative choice, particularly given the importance of denouncing and deterring this dangerous conduct which puts the public at risk,” they argue in their factum.

After several cases in which it clashed with the Conservatives in several key policy areas, the Supreme Court recently sided with Ottawa in its recent ruling that said it had the right to legislate the destruction of Quebec’s gun registry data.

The high court upheld the notion that Parliament has the power to make criminal law under the Constitution, as long as it operates within the law.

That win for the Conservatives came after several losses at the Supreme Court. They included rejecting its appointment of Quebec judge Marc Nadon to its ranks, rejecting Parliament’s right to reform the Senate on its own and upholding the right of Vancouver’s controversial Insite safe-injection facility to stay open when the government wanted it shut down.

Just Posted

Drug bust: Red Deer RCMP seize drugs, cash, vehicles

Criminals are getting creative. Red Deer RCMP have seized cash and vehicles… Continue reading

Red Deer Dream Centre opponents won’t appeal its approval

Red Deer’s subdivision and development appeal board approves project

Tough economy reflected in central Alberta municipal budgets

Municipal councils are keeping tax rate increases low to provide some economic relief

Proposed Red Deer 2020 operating budget would require a 2.5 per cent tax increase

A recommended $385.7 million budget will be discussed next month by council

Jason Kenney’s approval rating down: poll

A new poll shows Premier Jason Kenney’s honeymoon may be ending. The… Continue reading

Your community calendar

Friday The Annual Old-Fashioned Country Christmas is being held Dec. 13 at… Continue reading

Survey results suggest Ponoka residents are happy to live in the town

Survey interviewed 400 randomly selected residents

Extension of Molly Bannister Drive is unwanted

Re: “Survey seeks public input on contentious plan,” Dec. 11. Congratulations to… Continue reading

Opinion by Joe Ceci: Jason Kenney is raising your taxes and hoping you won’t know it’s him

Re: “Rural Alberta RCMP detachments getting 500 new positions,” Dec. 5. Jason… Continue reading

Hamilton welder to carry Canada colours at World Darts Championship in London

Canadian Matt Campbell is expecting a wild scene when he takes centre… Continue reading

More rowers come forward with complaints about coach, criticism of UVic

Sarah Craven had her sights set on the Olympics. The 21-year-old was… Continue reading

Eastwood on ‘Richard Jewell,’ criticism and finding stories

LOS ANGELES — For his film “Richard Jewell,” Clint Eastwood takes aim… Continue reading

Ryan Reynolds says he related to Peloton actress’ plight

NEW YORK — Ryan Reynolds says he relates to the social media… Continue reading

Most Read