The NDP is asking House of Commons Speaker Anthony Rota for an emergency debate on anti-pipeline blockades, in a Feb. 18, 2020 story. (Photo by THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Trudeau caught in middle of clash over energy, environment, Indigenous demands

OTTAWA — The competing demands of natural resource development, environmental protection and Indigenous reconciliation appear poised for a head-on crash — with Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s minority government caught in the middle as Parliament resumes Tuesday.

The NDP is asking House of Commons Speaker Anthony Rota for an emergency debate on anti-pipeline blockades that have shut down swaths of the country’s train system and interrupted traffic on highways and bridges for more than a week.

The blockades are in support of Wet’suwet’en hereditary chiefs who oppose a natural-gas pipeline project that crosses the First Nation’s territory in northern British Columbia.

Trudeau faces a blockade of a different sort — from his own Liberal backbenchers — over another energy project.

Many Liberal MPs are openly campaigning against approval of Teck Resources’ proposed Frontier oilsands mine in Alberta, which they see as antithetical to Trudeau’s pledge to combat climate change.

Cabinet must decide by the end of this month whether to approve the project and risk the wrath of Liberal MPs and voters concerned about climate change, or nix it and risk raising “roiling western alienation to a boiling point,” as Alberta Premier Jason Kenney has warned.

Either issue is politically explosive but the combination makes for something of a perfect storm for Trudeau’s fragile minority.

NDP House leader Peter Julian wrote to Rota on Monday to request that emergency debate on anti-pipeline blockades.

“The prime minister’s refusal to take more substantive and timely action has allowed tensions to rise, put significant pressure on the Canadian economy and threatened jobs across the country,” Julian wrote.

“He has said that no relationship is as important to him as Canada’s relationship with Indigenous Peoples but those words must be backed up by actions,” he added, calling for a “swift and just resolution.”

Trudeau, who was overseas last week trying to drum up support for Canada’s bid for a seat on the United Nations Security Council, spent hours Monday holed up with some of his cabinet ministers trying to figure out a way to end the blockades quickly and peacefully. He has said governments in Canada do not order the police to clear out protesters but it was unclear Monday what other action the government might take to end the standoff.

The Conservatives, who’ve called for police enforcement of court injunctions against the protests, have an opposition day on Thursday and may use that opportunity to further pressure the government over its perceived inaction on the blockades, if the issue isn’t resolved by then.

Or they could pressure the government to approve Teck’s Frontier project. Conservative MPs have echoed Kenney’s contention that the project would create thousands of jobs and bolster Alberta’s struggling economy and that rejection would be a blow to national unity.

But many Liberal MPs aren’t buying those arguments.

Toronto MP John McKay says Liberal caucus members are “darn close” to unanimous in their opposition to the Teck mine.

“My guess is that (Trudeau) will not go against the views of caucus,” he says, adding that he sympathizes with Trudeau’s having to make a “lose-lose” decision.

Some aren’t convinced the project will ever be built, pointing to Teck CEO Don Lindsay’s admission that the mine will only proceed if oil prices substantially increase and the company obtains joint-venture partners.

Nor are they buying Kenney’s portrayal of the project as the sole saviour of Alberta’s economy. They note that there are some 20 other oilsands projects that already have approval and are ready to go but are on ice because they’re not economically viable given low world oil prices.

University of Alberta environmental economist Andrew Leach says some of those other projects could be viable at much lower oil prices than Teck but they are on hold because of production limits imposed by the Alberta government.

“It’s easier for Premier Kenney to be able to say it’s not happening because of the federal regulatory process than for him to say … the provincial government hasn’t given final approval or, in the general case, it’s not happening because of broader economic circumstances that are sort of beyond his control and don’t have an obvious someone else to blame,” Leach says.

This report by The Canadian Press was first published Feb. 17, 2020.

Pipeline

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

One new COVID-19 case confirmed for Red Deer

Red Deer has one new confirmed case of COVID-19, which brings the… Continue reading

Red Deer Catholic Regional Schools reveals three-phase layoff plan

Red Deer Catholic Regional Schools has announced a three-phase layoff process after… Continue reading

A message from the Advocate publisher

In good times and bad, The Red Deer Advocate has been here… Continue reading

RDSO’s April concert is pushed back into the fall

No decisions yet on what will happen to the June 5 finale

Hospital parking fees suspended during COVID-19 pandemic

Alberta Health Services has been directed to temporarily suspend parking fees during… Continue reading

Alberta Health Services provides COVID-19 prevention tips

Alberta Health Services has a number of recommendations for people amid the… Continue reading

Alberta government website has latest COVID-19 statistics

Red Deer Advocate readers can stay up to date on the COVID-19… Continue reading

Alberta suspends environmental reporting requirements over COVID crisis

Alberta suspends environmental reporting requirements over COVID crisis

Internal audit of Scheer’s expenses turns up money on school, clothes, minivan

Internal audit of Scheer’s expenses turns up money on school, clothes, minivan

Alberta announces new COVID-19 rules for workers at long-term care centres

Alberta announces new COVID-19 rules for workers at long-term care centres

N.L. health minister urges safe use of dating apps during pandemic

N.L. health minister urges safe use of dating apps during pandemic

Staying home offers chance to declutter, but what to do when you can’t donate?

Staying home offers chance to declutter, but what to do when you can’t donate?

Trump says he expects Russia, Saudis to cut oil production

Trump says he expects Russia, Saudis to cut oil production

Most Read