TV show gets man new crack at lawsuit against job-promising agency

A man who failed in a lawsuit against a company he said had promised to find him a job can have another crack at suing in light of a TV program that cast doubt on whether the defendants had told the truth, Ontario's top court ruled Tuesday.

TORONTO — A man who failed in a lawsuit against a company he said had promised to find him a job can have another crack at suing in light of a TV program that cast doubt on whether the defendants had told the truth, Ontario’s top court ruled Tuesday.

In what the Appeal Court called “most unusual” circumstances, the justices said a lower court was wrong to deny Golam Mehedi a chance to reopen his case given the post-trial broadcast.

“It is plain that the proposed new evidence was not available at the time of the first trial or the first appeal,” the Appeal Court ruled.

“The new evidence is cogent in that it is apparently credible and, if accepted, would probably have affected the result at trial.”

Mehedi had claimed that Toronto-based Job Success — run by M.A. Hameed, Wendell Lacombe and owner Dale Smith — had promised to find him a job paying $70,000 a year within two months, in exchange for a $3,700 fee.

In June 2011, the trial judge threw his case out, saying no one had made any promises to Mehedi. The judge said he found Hameed and Lacombe had been credible witnesses and called Mehedi’s job expectations “unrealistic and unreasonable.”

Mehedi turned, without success, to the Court of Appeal in January 2012.

A month later, however, CBC’s “Marketplace” broadcast an episode called “Recruitment Rip-off” that cast doubt on the trial evidence Hameed and Lacombe had given. The program used hidden cameras in an effort to show how a recruitment agency known as Toronto Pathways was exploiting the unemployed — mainly new immigrants — by promising to find them good jobs in exchange for fees, according to court records.

In one scene, a “Marketplace” staffer asks Lacombe if he is providing a job-finding guarantee to which he responds, “Absolutely. And we are very good at it.” In another segment, Smith acknowledges Toronto Pathways and Job Success are the same business.

Metro newspaper later reported Smith made similar statements to a reporter posing as a Job Success client. The paper said he had faced at least 10 small-claims actions.

Mehedi asked to reopen his lawsuit so he could enter the new material as fresh evidence, arguing the defendants were “slick liars who perjured themselves at trial,” according to court records.

However, in November, Ontario Superior Court Justice Kevin Whitaker ruled against him.

“I am not persuaded that this is an appropriate case to exercise my discretion to reopen this matter that had already been tried,” Whitaker ruled. “Even if the new evidence was allowed, I do not believe that that would reasonably affect the outcome.”

Mehedi turned again to the Appeal Court.

This time, the province’s top court agreed with him, saying Whitaker’s reasons for refusing to reopen the trial were inadequate.

The Appeal Court ordered the trial judge to take another look at the case, decide on whether to admit the fresh evidence, and if so, whether it would lead to a different outcome.

Just Posted

The City of Red Deer is reaching out to the community to see if anyone wants to move and maintain the Scout Hut from 1937. The land it sits on is needed for a women’s shelter expansion. (Photo by LANA MICHELIN/Advocate staff).
City of Red Deer is calling for proposals for preserving, moving Scout Hut

The 47th Avenue land it sits on is needed for women’s shelter expansion

Students at Olds College will be learning what’s new in agricultural technology at the facility’s Smart Farm. (Photo contributed)
New agricultural technologies explored by students at Olds College

Olds College is launching a new SmartFarm program to help farmers and… Continue reading

Red Deer Rebels forward Zach Smith tips a shot off the post against Edmonton Oil Kings netminder Sebastian Cossa Saturday night at the Centrium. (Photo by BYRON HACKETT/Advocate Staff)
Rebels name new assistant coach, open WHL season on Oct. 1

Rebels will play home opener on Oct. 2

Bobby-Jo Stannard, community development superintendent with the City of Red Deer, and Kelly Andres, city community facilitator, say response to the first mural has been extremely positive. (Photo by SUSAN ZIELINSKI/Advocate staff)
Mural artists making downtown Red Deer vibrant

Preparing for Meet the Street arts and culture festival

Softwood lumber is pictured in Richmond, B.C. File photo by THE CANADIAN PRESS
While lumber prices drop, relief isn’t exactly on the way for consumers

Consumers in Alberta won’t see the benefit of falling lumber prices any… Continue reading

Red Deer South MLA Jason Stephan's decision to travel to Arizona for a holiday has been sharply criticized by many.
Advocate file photo
Jason Stephan: Quebec’s actions undermine interests of Alberta

Prior to serving as a MLA, I structured many commercial partnership agreements.… Continue reading

FILE - Great Britain’s Andrew Matthews, from left to right, Ben Simons, Toby Olubi and Lamin Deen celebrate after their second-place finish in a four-man World Cup Bobsleigh race in Whistler, British Columbia, in this Saturday, Nov. 25, 2017, file photo. British Bobsleigh and Skeleton announced Thursday, June 17, 2021, that the four-man team of Deen, Simons, Olubi and Matthews has been upgraded to the gold medal for a race that occurred Nov. 25, 2017 in Whistler, Canada. The Russian crew that beat them that day has since been disqualified. (Darryl Dyck/The Canadian Press via AP, File)
Britain upgraded to World Cup bobsled gold from 2017 race

Driver of Russian sled was sanctioned for doping violations

Leylah Annie Fernandez, of Canada, returns a shot Marie Bouzkova, of the Czech Republic, in round 1 of the Rogers Cup women’s tennis tournament in Toronto, Monday August 5, 2019. Leylah Annie Fernandez lost 6-4, 3-6, 7-6 (3) to No. 2 seed Ons Jabeur of Tunisia in the second round of the Viking Classic Birmingham on Thursday. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Mark Blinch
Canadian Leylah Annie Fernandez loses third-set tiebreaker against Ons Jabeur

Jabeur now heads to the quarterfinals at the WTA Tour 250 grass-court event

Feist performs during the Polaris Music Prize gala in Toronto on September 18, 2017. Canadian singer-songwriter Leslie Feist is hitting the road with what’s described as an intimate and “unconventional production” featuring all new music.THE CANADIAN PRESS/Chris Donovan
Leslie Feist to debut new music in ‘unconventional’ and intimate ‘Multitudes’ show

Calgary-raised artist will debut show at Kampnagel Festival in Germany

Letter: Improvements coming to two intersections in Red Deer to help cyclists

A letter in the Advocate on June 9 with complaints about cyclists… Continue reading

Opinion: Trudeau tight-lipped on Constitution attack

When exactly did Canada become a Constitution-bashing country? For nearly 30 years,… Continue reading

Gwynne DYer
Opinion: Western countries giving out vaccines to poor nations

At the recent G7 summit, U.S. President Joe Biden promised to distribute… Continue reading

Most Read