U.S. border officers could face Canadian justice for serious crimes under pact

A U.S. border officer who commits an on-duty crime in Canada would generally face justice in an American court under a new binational agreement.

OTTAWA — A U.S. border officer who commits an on-duty crime in Canada would generally face justice in an American court under a new binational agreement.

But if the crime is murder, terrorism or sexual assault, a trial could take place in Canada, according to the agreement made public this week.

The fine print of the deal, tabled in Parliament, sets out a complex regime for determining officer accountability on both sides of the border under the Canada-U.S. preclearance scheme.

The arrangement will expand the American customs presence on Canadian soil and is expected to see Canada establish similar operations in the United States.

Currently, passengers flying to American cities through eight major Canadian airports can be precleared there by U.S. Customs and Border Protection officers. The new arrangement expands the concept to land crossings and rail and marine services, with the aim of making travel between the two countries more speedy and secure.

In the rail mode, for example, this could mean preclearing passengers and their luggage in Canada before travellers leave the train station, thereby avoiding a stop at the Canada-U.S. border, the federal government says.

Mutual respect of both countries’ sovereignty and laws is “a fundamental principle” of the agreement, Public Safety Canada said in response to questions about the accountability provisions.

In general, the U.S. would have primary jurisdiction over its preclearance officers for offences committed while performing official duties in Canada. Canada, meanwhile, would have primary criminal jurisdiction over acts committed by U.S. preclearance officers outside of work, including when they are commuting to and from the job.

However, Canada would have jurisdiction over “serious cases of on-duty conduct, notably cases of murder, aggravated sexual assault and terrorism,” in cases where U.S. officials agree such charges are warranted under U.S. law and Canada has asked Washington to waive its jurisdiction.

In other serious cases of on-duty conduct, the U.S. would have jurisdiction but Canada could ask the Americans to waive it.

The arrangement is reciprocal, so the same principles would apply for any Canada Border Services Agency officers performing preclearance duties on U.S. soil.

A binational council of senior Canadian and U.S. officials will meet regularly to monitor implementation of the criminal liability framework, Public Safety says.

Josh Paterson, executive director of the British Columbia Civil Liberties Association, says the wording allays some concerns about how criminal acts by U.S. officers would be handled.

However, the association has questions about how Canadians might seek redress for less serious infringements of their rights by U.S. officers, such as inappropriate use of force or unreasonable searches.

“I don’t see an answer to that in this agreement,” Paterson said. “How are those issues going to get resolved for Canadians?”

The association also has concerns about provisions that allow U.S. officers to carry guns in Canada during land, rail and marine preclearance operations — though not in Canadian airports.

“In most settings where these officers are operating, Canadian law enforcement is close at hand,” Paterson said. “It seems to be going too far to offer these U.S. agents the ability to carry firearms and to use them on Canadian soil.”

The entire preclearance scheme is “an affront to Canadian sovereignty,” said Green party Leader Elizabeth May.

It is important to move goods and people across the border efficiently, she said, but “it doesn’t require U.S. officials on Canadian soil, U.S. border agents carrying guns.”

Just Posted

A lesson in excellence and success

Mary Kemmis, president of the Prairie Division of Black Press Media, and… Continue reading

Gravel operations could cloud pristine trout stream, say conservationists

Border Paving proposes to excavate below the waterline near the Raven Rriver

Alberta government firing election commissioner who was investigating leadership

EDMONTON — Alberta’s United Conservative government is firing the province’s election commissioner,… Continue reading

Canadian universities encourage exchange students in Hong Kong to head home

Some Canadian universities are urging their exchange students in Hong Kong to… Continue reading

First-time novelist Ian Williams wins $100K Scotiabank Giller Prize

TORONTO — First-time novelist Ian Williams singled out a special member of… Continue reading

Central Albertans help families during holidays with Christmas Wish Breakfast

It takes a community to help a community. And Sunday morning at… Continue reading

Your community calendar

Nov. 19 The Mountview Sunnybrook Community Association will hold its AGM at… Continue reading

Opinion: The buck stops with Red Deer city council

Red Deer city council has taken measures to distance itself from decisions… Continue reading

Alberta government firing election commissioner who was investigating leadership

EDMONTON — Alberta’s United Conservative government is firing the province’s election commissioner,… Continue reading

Canadian universities encourage exchange students in Hong Kong to head home

Some Canadian universities are urging their exchange students in Hong Kong to… Continue reading

First-time novelist Ian Williams wins $100K Scotiabank Giller Prize

TORONTO — First-time novelist Ian Williams singled out a special member of… Continue reading

Campus under siege as Hong Kong police battle protesters

HONG KONG — Police tightened their siege of a university campus where… Continue reading

US angers Palestinians with reversal on Israeli settlements

WASHINGTON — The Trump administration on Monday said it no longer considers… Continue reading

Pence aide’s testimony renews focus on VP’s Ukraine role

WASHINGTON — He knew nothing about the Ukrainian backchannel, his aides say.… Continue reading

Most Read