University of Ottawa hockey team probe was part of legal strategy

The University of Ottawa is refusing to release a pair of investigative reports into misconduct that led to the suspension of its men’s hockey team, revealing for the first time that the probe was launched as part of a pre-emptive legal strategy.

OTTAWA — The University of Ottawa is refusing to release a pair of investigative reports into misconduct that led to the suspension of its men’s hockey team, revealing for the first time that the probe was launched as part of a pre-emptive legal strategy.

As a result, the varsity players find themselves in the odd situation of having participated willingly in an investigation, overseen by a major law firm, that was aimed at protecting the university from possible lawsuits.

Police in Thunder Bay have charged two players with sexual assault in connection with an incident involving a 21-year-old woman during a road trip in February 2014. The team was initially suspended for the remainder of the 2013-14 season, and now the men’s hockey program has been put on hold through 2015-16.

The remaining 22 players are represented in a $6-million class-action lawsuit against the university that alleges their reputations were unnecessarily tarnished.

Lawrence Greenspon, the lawyer representing the players in the suit, said it’s “fundamentally wrong” to withhold the reasons behind the suspension.

“If you’re going to punish somebody for something that you said they did wrong, you have to at least disclose to them the basis for the punishment … it’s fundamental fairness to human beings,” Greenspon said in an interview.

“You’re clearly punishing these guys, you’re clearly affecting their lives, and you’re refusing to release the results of the investigation that they say is the basis for this punishment.”

Last June, university president Allan Rock told a news conference that independent investigator Steven Gaon had delivered a report. Rock said the university fired hockey coach Real Paiement based on the finding he did not inform school officials about the Thunder Bay incident.

In a subsequent letter to the Globe and Mail, Rock said the investigation also “disclosed widespread behaviour that was disreputable and unbecoming of representatives of uOttawa and suggested an unhealthy climate surrounding the team.”

Gaon was actually hired and directed by the law firm Norton Rose Fulbright Canada, which in turn had been retained by the university.

“Norton Rose Fulbright..retained an independent investigator to probe the facts underlying the allegations, in order to be in a position to give legal advice to the university on potential legal claims arising from the men’s hockey team matter,” the firm said in a submission to Ontario’s information commissioner in December.

The Canadian Press lodged a complaint with the commissioner’s office after the university refused to release any part of the investigation’s findings under the province’s freedom of information law.

In May, Gaon delivered not one, but two reports — one about allegations of sexual misconduct, and the other on excessive drinking. Those reports were also prepared “for use in giving legal advice,” according to university lawyer David Bolger.

The university said in a June press release that Gaon’s findings would not be published “to avoid any interference with the ongoing police investigation and out of respect for the university’s privacy obligations.”

But in its submissions to the information commissioner, the university cites as its primary concern the fact that the records are considered legal advice.

“The records should not be disclosed. They are protected by solicitor-client privilege, both at common law and under the statutory exemption created by the Act,” the university wrote.

Anne-Marie Roy, president of the University of Ottawa’s student federation, said it is in the interest of the wider university community to have the information released.

“How are we supposed to hold this university accountable for cases of sexual violence if there’s absolutely no transparency, if we don’t know what’s actually happening?” said Roy.

“If there are serious findings in that report, how am I supposed to make sure that the University of Ottawa is properly taking steps to make sure that doesn’t reoccur?”

The university also cites concerns over privacy and the police investigation in its refusal to release the documents. It said the records are “replete with personal information about the members of the men’s hockey team and the men’s hockey team’s former coach,” “details about the alleged assault that have not been made public,” and “sensitive details about the alleged victim’s interactions with members of the men’s hockey team.”

“Given that the reports conclude that 1/8name(s) withheld 3/8 had changed their stories over time, there is a very real risk that the release of this information would result in 1/8name(s) withheld 3/8 colluding (intentionally or unintentionally) when they are called to give evidence,” reads the submission.

An edited copy of the sexual misconduct report was prepared by the university to see if there was an possibility of releasing them to The Canadian Press. But it concluded that “this would compromise the university’s ability to seek appropriate legal advice and be fully informed about its legal rights and responsibilities.”

It also worried that there would be a risk of the public deducing the identity of players, even with their names withheld.

The University of Ottawa released last summer an evaluation by two outside academics on the institution’s policies, practices and procedures.

Just Posted

Alberta slump cited in court process to sell dozens of office buildings

CALGARY — A major player in Calgary’s depressed office real estate industry… Continue reading

UK voters decide who they want to resolve Brexit impasse

LONDON — Britons who have endured three years of wrangling over their… Continue reading

Ethics law forbids ex-minister Philpott from paid work for First Nation

OTTAWA — The federal ethics law has put a crimp in Jane… Continue reading

Red Deer’s Dream Centre for addictions treatment is approved on appeal

Several conditions are attached to the approval

Your community calendar

Friday The Annual Old-Fashioned Country Christmas is being held Dec. 13 at… Continue reading

Hamilton welder to carry Canada colours at World Darts Championship in London

Canadian Matt Campbell is expecting a wild scene when he takes centre… Continue reading

More rowers come forward with complaints about coach, criticism of UVic

Sarah Craven had her sights set on the Olympics. The 21-year-old was… Continue reading

Eastwood on ‘Richard Jewell,’ criticism and finding stories

LOS ANGELES — For his film “Richard Jewell,” Clint Eastwood takes aim… Continue reading

Ryan Reynolds says he related to Peloton actress’ plight

NEW YORK — Ryan Reynolds says he relates to the social media… Continue reading

Derailed train in Saskatchewan released 1.5 million litres of oil: TSB

LANIGAN, Sask. — The Transportation Safety Board says Monday’s fiery Canadian Pacific… Continue reading

Alberta NDP wants new ethics review of government over election watchdog firing

EDMONTON — Alberta’s Opposition is renewing its attempt to have the ethics… Continue reading

Leonard scores 23 points to lead Clippers to 112-92 rout of Raptors

Clippers 112 Raptors 92 TORONTO — On a night Kawhi Leonard was… Continue reading

Most Read