A matter of integrity

If anyone enjoys the cut and thrust of partisan debate, it would be two former Wildrose MLAs from Central Alberta, Joe Anglin and Kerry Towle. Anglin has been regarded as sort of a lone wolf for some time now, so it’s fitting that if he could not sit as a member of the Wildrose Party for which he was first elected, he would sit as an independent.

If anyone enjoys the cut and thrust of partisan debate, it would be two former Wildrose MLAs from Central Alberta, Joe Anglin and Kerry Towle.

Anglin has been regarded as sort of a lone wolf for some time now, so it’s fitting that if he could not sit as a member of the Wildrose Party for which he was first elected, he would sit as an independent.

Towle, on the other hand, is more naturally bent toward the team. The Innisfail-Sylvan Lake MLA a joiner, not a loner. So her defection on Monday to the governing Conservatives carries double importance. Probably more than double.

It takes a huge amount of stress to make a committed partisan switch teams. So I look to the factors behind Monday’s events to help explain why Anglin, Towle and Ian Donovan of the Little Bow riding left their party.

They did not leave the party in disarray. It was that way before they left.

Read what you like into this: on Monday, the Wildrose caucus passed a motion that was defeated by party membership at the party’s annual meeting.

Former Tory— now Wildrose MLA — Rob Anderson said on Monday that caucus would follow the policy they voted on, not what was passed by the party in general at its annual conference.

What does that tell you? It tells me there’s serious a divide between the members the party elected and the people who took out party memberships.

NDP Leader Rachel Notley said that Monday’s defections were “not a good sign of democracy in the province.”

I disagree. I say it’s a very strong sign of a resurgence of democracy in this province. I wish we could have more of this, including (maybe even especially) at the federal level.

Wildrose Leader Danielle Smith had a brief statement for the press and took no questions later. But she mentioned two prominent Conservative MLAs who had earlier crossed the floor to join Wildrose.

She spoke darkly that Donovan and Towle will have to answer for their decision to abandon the party that got them elected. Not so much Heather Forsythe and Rob Anderson, who went the other way. Anglin would remain beneath her radar.

I say it’s a good day for democracy when elected members switch parties. I say it’s a good day when an MLA decides constituents and personal values should govern a member’s voting pattern in the legislature, not party membership.

Both Towle and Smith mentioned that Wildrose is a party of free votes. Smith is balancing denial of the will of party members and the public line on the issue. Towle is balancing an espousal of free votes, while joining a government that is measurably less free in that regard.

Wildrose has only two female members left of its 14 remaining MLAs, and Forsythe has already said she will not run again.

Wildrose membership watered down a policy statement on protecting the equality of minority groups, particularly gay, lesbian and transgendered people. Elected MLAs, who know their constituents and the facts on the ground better than the party card-holders, actively rejected their will.

Smith says she won’t be leading the party if it doesn’t win the next election. Is that confidence in the party’s promise or an ability to read writing on the wall that party members cannot seem to decipher?

In my version of democracy, any group can create a political party with a declared set of values and seek candidates who would reflect those values. But once elected, the members are beholden first to their voters, not the party.

I’m not about to suggest that any of the five MLAs who crossed the floor since the last election (Anderson, Forsythe, Anglin, Donovan and Towle) did so to gain perks or score points. I have no basis to believe that was their motivation.

Rather, I believe such decisions can show integrity to personal values. We should have more of this, both federally and provincially.

The more that party leaders (and party membership) understand that elected members are not the property of their party whips, the better.

For their part, the party leaders have not gotten the memo. But I sense a sea change among an electorate that is tired of being tuned out between elections.

We want more voter participation in elections, but why bother if elected members are simply forced to a party line rather than what people want?

Notley was a bit too cynical Monday, describing the forces that brought Towle and Donovan to the Conservatives. She said phase one of the Tory plan is “break your promises.” Phase two, she said, is to “become Wildrose.”

When even the Wildrose leader and her MLAs don’t want what the Wildrose Party membership says they should want — and a couple left the party because of it — I don’t think the Tories will want to be Wildrose.

When you think about it, as things stand now, neither will Alberta voters.

Greg Neiman is a retired Advocate editor. Follow his blog at readersadvocate.blogspot.ca or email greg.neiman.blog@gmail.com.

Just Posted

Red Deer officials will allow Calgary to trial alcohol in parks

The result could determine if local rules are relaxed

RDSO plays ‘rousing’ Scottish tunes to celebrate Robbie Burns Day

Violinist Kai Gleusteen will solo at the Jan. 26 show at RDC Arts Centre

Updated: Sylvan Lake council adopts waterfront plan

Sustainable Waterfront Area Redevelopment Plan to guide development for next 20 years

Driver who backed into Red Deer pizzeria sentenced

David Andrew Amstutz sentenced for failing to remain at the crash scene

Shaw getting ready to raise prices for its main residential service, CEO says

CALGARY — Residential customers of Shaw Communications Inc. will likely see a… Continue reading

Rare ‘super blood wolf moon’ takes to the skies this Sunday

Celestial event happens only three times this century

Company issues lifetime ban after man jumps from cruise ship

Nick Naydev posted the video last week showing him standing on the balcony of the Symphony of the Seas

Unruly passenger forces B.C.-bound flight to divert to Calgary

Police say charges are pending against a woman in her 40s

Inflation rises as higher airfares, veggie prices offset cheaper gas

Statistics Canada says inflation accelerated to two per cent in December

Canadian tattoo artist inks Toronto skyline on Blue Jays pitcher Stroman

Marcus Stroman found a way to show his appreciation for Toronto when… Continue reading

Team World sweeps opening day against Team North America at Continental Cup

LAS VEGAS — Team North America has some serious ground to make… Continue reading

SXSW to screen ‘Run This Town,’ which includes Rob Ford character

TORONTO — A drama that features a portrayal of the late Toronto… Continue reading

Fans buy ‘Little House on the Prairie’ star’s memorabilia

GENOA TOWNSHIP, Mich. — More than 200 items belonging to “Little House… Continue reading

Paying down debt should be priority for low income workers, say experts

TORONTO — Investment planning can often be seen as a luxury for… Continue reading

Most Read