Budget penalizes taxpayers

There are enough conflicting messages contained in the Alberta budget to leave the average taxpayer dazed and confused for a week.

There are enough conflicting messages contained in the Alberta budget to leave the average taxpayer dazed and confused for a week.

And even when taxpayers have sorted through the maze of spending plans announced by Finance Minister Iris Evans, they likely won’t feel comforted.

Evans has offered up a budget long on uncertainty, short on stability and deep into the average Albertan’s pocket in one way or another.

And the potential exists for even more punitive plans down the road, if the Alberta economy continues to falter.

Basic economics teaches that spending is the engine of economic health and that the average consumer is responsible for firing that engine. In difficult times, when basic consumer activity won’t sustain the economy, spending declines, followed quickly by job losses.

At that point, either governments step in to stimulate spending (giving tax breaks or creating jobs by funding public and private projects, either through grants, low-cost loans or tax breaks), or the economy spirals. Part of the commitment is maintaining public service jobs.

History says economies do rebound on their own, but not without significant, lengthy hardship for the average person, and after much restructuring. That’s not what Canadians want or expect from their governments. They want strong, supportive economic leadership in good and bad times.

So why has the Conservative government of Alberta introduced its most punitive budget in a decade?

In the wake of 10 years of surplus budgets, let’s examine the tax increases, either contained in the budget, implied, or introduced in the weeks leading to its delivery:

• Education property taxes will rise significantly in all communities, as determined by the school boards in question. In Calgary, for example, that’s a 6.7 per cent hike for the average homeowner. How is that tolerable in communities where job losses are building, wages are being frozen or rolled back and future opportunities are disappearing?

• The province recently cancelled its natural gas rebate program, taking millions of dollars out of consumers’ hands.

• A previously announced municipal funding agreement will be trimmed by as much as $200 million. If municipalities want to retain these projects, they’ll have to fund them through their own debt, and ultimately by raising municipal taxes.

• Both alcohol and tobacco taxes will increase (not always a bad thing, but there is no evidence that this increased revenue will actually go to address alcohol and tobacco dependency issues).

In addition, some projects and services are being delayed or derailed:

• Several health construction projects, including the Lacombe continuing care-dementia care project.

• No new school construction, at least in Central Alberta.

• Chiropractic services will no longer be covered under the Alberta health plan.

• Wild Rose Foundation charity funding will be cut or redirected, making it more difficult for charitable groups to fund projects — and forcing them to go back to the public for yet more money, or constrict vital services.

Now consider the dire consequences if oil royalty revenue continues to slump: a projected $4.7-billion deficit this year continues to build, even though the new legal spending ceiling is the $7-billion sustainability fund.

Certainly there are some initiatives in the budget, for select communities.

But too much uncertainty remains — $215 million in government spending cuts this year and a further $2.2 billion if revenues don’t rebound.

For too long, Alberta gambled on the energy sector and won — and the mentality seems to have stuck. The provincial government’s new budget seems to mistake another roll of the dice for leadership.

John Stewart is the Advocate’s managing editor.

Just Posted

Red Deer College has been upgrading roofing, mechanical control systems, and lighting with $13 million in capital maintenance funding from the province. (Photo by Advocate staff)
$13 million in maintenance work underway at Red Deer College

Projects improve teaching, learning, and working spaces

Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau waits to take his seat at the EU-Canada Summit Monday June 14, 2021 in Brussels, Belgium. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Adrian Wyld
Trudeau to visit Pfizer on final day of international pandemic trip, begin quarantine

WTO looks at making it easier for developing countries to import expertise, equipment and ingredients for vaccines

Houses under construction in Toronto on Friday, June 26, 2015. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Graeme Roy
CMHC says annual pace of housing starts rose 3.2 per cent in May compared with April

Starts for apartments, condos and other multiple-unit housing projects rose

FILE - In this Wednesday, Nov. 30, 2013 file photo, customers leave an IKEA store in Plaisir, west of Paris. A French court has ordered home furnishings giant Ikea to pay more than $1.2 million in fines and damages Tuesday, June 15, 2021 over a campaign to spy on union representatives. (AP Photo/Remy de la Mauviniere, FIle)
Ikea fined $1.3 million over spying campaign in France

Convicted of receiving personal data obtained through fraudulent means in a habitual way

In this undated file photo released by the Taiwan Ministry of Defense, a Chinese PLA J-16 fighter jet flies in an undisclosed location. China sent a record 28 fighter jets, 14 of them J-16s, towards the self-ruled island of Taiwan on Tuesday, June 15, 2021, the island’s defense ministry said, the largest such display of force since China started flying planes towards the island last year. (Taiwan Ministry of Defense via AP)
China sends record 28 fighter jets toward Taiwan

Since last year, China has been flying fighter jets toward the island almost daily

Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau participates in a plenary session at the G7 Summit in Carbis Bay, England on Friday June 11, 2021. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Adrian Wyld
Canada donating 13M surplus COVID-19 vaccine doses to poor countries

Trudeau says the government will pay for 87 million shots to be distributed to poor countries

Opinion: Governments should come together to collaborate paid sick leave in Canada

If we let our guard down, COVID-19 is highly transmissible and will… Continue reading

Finnish players celebrate with their fans after the Euro 2020 soccer championship group B match between Denmark and Finland at Parken stadium in Copenhagen, Denmark, Saturday, June 12, 2021. Finland won 1-0. (Friedemann Vogel/Pool via AP)
Finland plays Russia with Euro 2020 knockout stage in reach

Finns played in their first ever game at a major soccer tournament

Scotland’s Allan Dell (1) is tackled by Canada’s Matt Heaton (7) and Lucas Rumball (6) during first half action of men’s international rugby in Edmonton, Alta., on June 9, 2018. Heaton, of Rugby ATL, Ben LeSage and Lucas Rumball, both of the Toronto Arrows, will co-captain Canada next month for rugby test matches in Wales and England. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jason Franson
Canada names 30-man roster for July rugby internationals against Wales, England

July test marks the first games for Canadian men since October 2019 at the Rugby World Cup

Montreal’s Deanna Bowen, seen in an undated handout photo, has won the $50,000 annual Scotiabank Photography Award. Award organizers say Bowen’s family history has been a central part of her work since the early 1990s. She’s descended from Alabama and Kentucky-born Black Prairie pioneer families from the central Alberta communities of Amber Valley and Campsie. THE CANADIAN PRESS/HO-Courtesy of the artist
Montreal’s Deanna Bowen wins $50,000 Scotiabank Photography Award

Bowen to receive solo exhibition at 2022 Scotiabank Contact Photography Festival

Treena Mielke
Montreal Canadiens goaltender Carey Price (31) blocks a shot by Vegas Golden Knights left wing William Carrier (28) during the second period in Game 1 of an NHL hockey Stanley Cup semifinal playoff series Monday in Las Vegas. (Photo by The Associated Press)
Canadiens take 4-1 loss to Vegas Golden Knights in Stanley Cup semifinal opener

Golden Knights 4 Canadiens 1 (Las Vegas leads series 1-0) LAS VEGAS… Continue reading

Philadelphia 76ers' coach Doc Rivers yells to his players during the first half of Game 4 of a second-round NBA basketball playoff series against the Atlanta Hawks, Monday, June 14, 2021, in Atlanta. (AP Photo/Brynn Anderson)
Young leads Hawks’ rally past Sixers with Embiid hurting

Hawks 103 76ers 100 ATLANTA — Trae Young overcame a cold start… Continue reading

Most Read