Common sense prevails

By a narrow 4-3 margin, the Supreme Court of Canada got it right this week when it ruled that Hutterites must have their photographs on driver’s licences – just like everyone else.

By a narrow 4-3 margin, the Supreme Court of Canada got it right this week when it ruled that Hutterites must have their photographs on driver’s licences – just like everyone else.

The Hutterian Brethren of Wilson Colony, located east of Lethbridge, had argued that the photo requirement violated their religious beliefs and their rights under the Canadian Charter of Human Rights.

The high court agreed that the requirement is an infringement, but said it’s a reasonable one and thus is allowed.

The provincial government had previously tried to accommodate the Southern Alberta colony by offering to leave the photo off the licence itself, while requiring a picture for the data bank. However, that generous offer was rejected.

Had the Supreme Court ruled in favour of the Hutterites, that might have opened the door — morally, if not legally — to all sorts of requests for special treatment by people with a variety of religious beliefs.

For instance, if you think it’s reasonable for Hutterites not to have their pictures on driver’s licences, why should Muslim women who wear the burka uncover their faces when they vote?

Similarly, if Hutterites were allowed not to have their photographs on driver’s licences, perhaps Sikh inmates should be allowed to go into prison with their kirpans (ceremonial swords or daggers).

If society were to take religious rights to ridiculous extremes, parents who put their faith in witch doctors instead of physicians might be allowed to deny their children life-saving treatment.

Of course, in a pluralistic country like Canada, religious differences and freedoms must be respected — to a point.

But when those differences actually create extraordinary inequalities, then the courts must step in to even things up.

Allowing any cultural or religious group to avoid having their photos on driver’s licences would be unfair to other Canadians.

As well, as Chief Justice Beverley McLachlin has written: “The goal of setting up a system that minimizes the risk of identity theft associated with driver’s licences is a pressing and important public goal.

“The universal photo requirement is connected to this goal and does not limit freedom (of) religion more than required to achieve it.”

If there is anything wrong with the Supreme Court’s recent ruling, it is simply what’s wrong with a lot of decisions by the court: It was made without releasing any reasons for refusing the appeal.

That is a huge cop-out that ought not to be allowed.

That said, this week at least, the Supreme Court deserves a pat on the back for embracing a common-sense solution.

If only Hutterites had been allowed to refuse to have their photos taken, then non-Hutterites would have suddenly become second-class citizens.

And that would hardly create a picture of fairness in the minds of most Canadians.

Lee Giles is an Advocate editor.

Just Posted

Red Deer area businesses recognized at Business of the Year Awards night

“It’s an honour just to be nominated.” The popular words echoed throughout… Continue reading

Child sex offender should get 12 years: Crown prosecutor

Stuart Peter Hunt has pleaded guilty to 10 child sexual exploitation and pornography charges

Legalizing cannabis cost estimate for Red Deer just under $400k

Although the province of Alberta has announced $11.2 million for cannabis legalization,… Continue reading

WATCH: Every square tells a story: Edmonton expert is exploring Red Deer’s quilting history

Community members can bring in family heirloom quilts for documentation

WATCH: Two weeks away from Canadian Finals Rodeo in Red Deer

In just two weeks, Ponoka’s Shayna Weir will compete with the best… Continue reading

Facebook’s election ‘war room’ takes aim at fake information

MENLO PARK, Calif. — In an otherwise innocuous part of Facebook’s expansive… Continue reading

Military to overhaul morale-boosting trips after review finds serious problems

OTTAWA — Canada’s top general is overhauling military morale-boosting tours after an… Continue reading

Police hand out a few hefty fines for allegedly violating Cannabis Act

The celebratory mood that marked the legalization of recreational cannabis lost a… Continue reading

PHOTO: Say goodbye to City Hall Park flowers

A sure sign that winter is on its way is when City… Continue reading

PHOTO: Chew On This! campaign draws attention to national poverty

Lunch bags were being handed out in front of The Hub downtown… Continue reading

Wickenheiser, Pegula reflect NHL’s trend toward diversity

BUFFALO, N.Y. — With a laugh, Kim Pegula’s competitive nature kicked in… Continue reading

Harry and Meghan bring rain to drought-stricken Outback town

DUBBO, Australia — The Duke and Duchess of Sussex were jokingly thanked… Continue reading

TV Review: A Roseanne Barr-less ‘The Conners’ is a triumph

NEW YORK — Can there be a “Roseanne” without Roseanne? The answer… Continue reading

Most Read