Crime victims bill an ineffective piece of fluff

Time will certainly judge the Canadian victims of crime bill of rights that was tabled last week in the House of Commons by the federal government.

Time will certainly judge the Canadian victims of crime bill of rights that was tabled last week in the House of Commons by the federal government.

There are criticisms of Bill C-32, in part because it does not provide a legal recourse to victims of crime should their rights be violated.

In other words, for the most part there’s no real teeth to the bill. It’s a touchy-feely piece of legislation full of principles but no grit.

But there is one thing in the bill that would change the Canada Evidence Act in such a way as to be of deep concern to those who may find themselves in certain terrible circumstances, such as domestic violence.

Currently, the act allows spouses the right to refuse to testify, except for in a few specific cases such as sexual assault or crimes against children. The act views a married couple as one person.

But the victims bill of rights would result in a change to the Evidence Act, so that a spouse could be compelled to testify against a spouse.

As a result, if there’s now a chill in the air felt by domestic violence victims, it’s understandable. And by victims, let’s be clear here — for the most part, we are talking about women.

While studies do show that men and women are at risk almost equally of violent crime, men are much more likely to be assaulted by a stranger, while women are much more likely to be assaulted by someone they know.

A Statistics Canada report, Family Violence in Canada: A Statistical Profile, 2009, says:

“Most men are not abusive to their families. However, when family violence does occur, the victims are overwhelmingly female: 83 per cent of all police-reported domestic assaults are against women. This pattern is consistent for every province and territory across Canada.”

So here’s the problem — what are the chances that a spouse will not report domestic violence because they are terrified they could end up in court testifying against the assaulter?

Sometimes the solution can be a poison pill.

The change to the Evidence Act proposed in the victims of crime bill of rights may in fact prevent people from reporting crime they should be reporting. The dynamics of domestic violence crime are obviously different than other types of crime.

That’s because the victim could well end up in the same home again, and often do, of the accused — for financial reasons or because of children, for example. We can imagine how things could go.

The accused knows his/her spouse is going to be compelled to testify against them in court.

A reasonable person should conclude that a victim might be reluctant to, and even might never dare, report a crime of domestic violence.

Therefore we have a victims of crime bill that in fact suppresses victims from actually reporting crime in the first place.

Certainly compelling spouses to testify will make the work of police easier — but in the way they may not have to deal with a crime in the first place.

That’s wrong.

Mary-Ann Barr is the Advocate’s assistant city editor. She can be reached by email at or by phone at 403-314-4332.

Just Posted

Red Deer property taxes to go up 2.15 per cent in 2019

City council approves $369.8 million budget

Sylvan Lake council approves concept plan for new park

Pogadl Park will eventally be home to numerous ball diamonds and sports fields

One person dead after collision on Highway 2A

Pickup truck and grain truck collided on Highway 2A south of Carstairs

Updated: Trial stalls for man accused in fatal Canada Day 2016 crash

Defence lawyer argued relevant information received only hours before trial to begin

Trudeau says politicians shouldn’t prey on Canadians’ fears

The Prime Minister was speaking at a townhall in Ontario

UPDATE: B.C. boy, aunt missing for three days

The pair are missing from Kamloops

Liberal bows out of byelection after singling out Jagmeet Singh’s race

Karen Wang says she made comments online that referenced Singh’s cultural background

Shooter pleads guilty to manslaughter in Stettler

A Stettler man charged with second-degree murder has pleaded guilty to manslaughter.… Continue reading

Kentucky canoe outfit borrows photo of Trudeau family to market business

They are in a red canoe, all clad in life jackets, and Sophie Gregoire Trudeau and Ella-Grace are waving

Police chief confirms all three Ottawa bus victims were on board when it crashed

OTTAWA — All three people killed in last week’s deadly bus accident… Continue reading

Theresa May wins no-confidence vote after Brexit deal rejection

UK PM can keep her job, after House of Commons voted 325-306

Alberta doctor accused of sexual assault asked to voluntarily give up practice

College says Dr. Barry Wollach should discontinue his practice, given the seriousness of the allegation against him

Speedy acceptance of Saudi shows refugee system’s flaws

Who would not wish Rahaf Mohammed well? The 18-year-old Saudi wants to… Continue reading

Most Read