Debate can be a turning point

Ontario’s political leaders face off tonight in a crucial debate, but can a 90-minute televised confrontation still move votes in an era when social media reigns and many electors will reach a verdict without sacrificing a warm spring evening?

Ontario’s political leaders face off tonight in a crucial debate, but can a 90-minute televised confrontation still move votes in an era when social media reigns and many electors will reach a verdict without sacrificing a warm spring evening?

Against all odds, the answer remains “yes.”

In fact, a well-timed debate moment can carry right into the next Parliament.

It was only three years ago that Jack Layton essentially catapulted to opposition leader with a well-honed charge against a gobsmacked Liberal leader, Michael Ignatieff.

The late NDP leader seized on an issue that is still a matter of fierce debate between his party and Liberals today, even in a dramatically redrawn House of Commons with Tom Mulcair and Justin Trudeau having replaced the 2011 antagonists.

Ignatieff was inexplicably caught off guard by Layton telling him he had the worst attendance record in the Commons — even though the story had only recently been highlighted in national media.

“Most Canadians, if they don’t show up for work, they don’t get a promotion,’’ Layton told Ignatieff.

The remark worked on a number of levels.

It played to Ignatieff’s perceived sense of entitlement, his caricature of a man who had come home for political power who didn’t need to work to gain Canadians’ trust.

New Democrats are using the same argument against Trudeau.

But the issue is larger.

Mulcair is doing his job as an Opposition leader, and doing it well.

But he won’t be running for another four years as Opposition leader.

There is at least anecdotal evidence that Mulcair’s work holding the Conservatives accountable is not being noticed outside the closed shop that is Ottawa because the NDP Leader still has work to do to make himself known to Canadians, a problem the oft absent Trudeau does not have.

Mulcair’s questioning of Harper has played to rave reviews from the handful who are actually watching him, those in the media outlet offices across the street, a gang that feverishly tweets question period bon mots back and forth with rooting interventions from party workers.

To most Canadians, question period is where maturity and decorum go to die and, if they think of it at all, they think of a bunch of adult jerks rolling around in a metaphorical sandbox.

But Mulcair is doing what an Opposition leader is elected to do.

Trudeau, as the leader of a tiny third party in a majority government, does not get the time or prominence in the afternoon theatre to make a difference and he is banking on the fact that most voters see Ottawa under Harper as the problem, not the solution.

So he goes to where the votes are.

Since last autumn’s throne speech, there have been 91 question periods.

According to the NDP, Mulcair has been there for almost two of three (64.8 per cent), Harper less than half the time (44 per cent), while Trudeau has missed almost two of three (38.5 per cent).

But New Democrats say their leader can walk and chew gum at the same time, getting out to meet voters and doing the job of diligent opposition leader.

In an online ad, the NDP says in the first 387 days since Trudeau was elected leader of the Liberal party, Mulcair had spent 146 days on the road, attending 394 events in 94 cities in 124 ridings, while still finding time “to show up to work on the Hill.’’

And then, in a nod to the Layton line: “Meanwhile, Justin Trudeau expects Canadians to promote him for ducking his responsibilities in Parliament?’’

The Trudeau team shrugs.

They maintain no one can credibly attack Trudeau’s work ethic, as New Democrats attacked Ignatieff’s. Ignatieff was an opposition leader in a minority Parliament, Trudeau presides over a third party in a majority Parliament. The dynamic is not comparable.

Whether voters believe their politicians should more regularly clock into the Commons for their work shifts or realize Ottawa is most attractive when one is leaving it is something that will play out next year federally.

Provincially, the focus will be on appearance — particularly that of Progressive Conservative Leader Tim Hudak and NDP Leader Andrea Horwath who must look like they could be premiers, not opposition leaders.

Neither party leader can script a Layton-Ignatieff moment, but it is that unpredictability that draws us to debates. And sometimes a moment emerges that an opposition party so relishes, it can be not only a springboard to electoral gain but a narrative to ride well into the next legislature.

Tim Harper is a national affairs writer. His column appears Monday, Wednesday and Friday. tharper@thestar.ca Twitter:@nutgraf1

Just Posted

Physicians urge Ottawa to pay another $21B over decade for seniors health care

OTTAWA — Physicians are calling on the federal government to shell out… Continue reading

‘I didn’t want to do something frivolous’: Sting’s play to make Toronto debut

TORONTO — Drawing Canadian theatregoers to a politically charged musical about an… Continue reading

Japan, EU sign trade deal to eliminate nearly all tariffs

TOKYO — The European Union and Japan signed a landmark deal on… Continue reading

Statistics Canada reports manufacturing sales up 1.4 per cent in May

OTTAWA — Statistics Canada says manufacturing sales increased 1.4 per cent to… Continue reading

Former Mountie who fired Taser at Robert Dziekanski drops appeal of sentence

VANCOUVER — The former RCMP constable who fired a Taser at a… Continue reading

CFIA inspects after video shows pigs crammed into B.C. transport truck

The video shows pigs piled on top of one another in a transport truck on a “sweltering” hot day last week

Cubs’ Kyle Schwarber falls to Bryce Harper in Home Run Derby final

WASHINGTON — Nationals Park was eerily quiet late Monday when Kyle Schwarber… Continue reading

Lava crashes through roof of Hawaii tour boat, injuring 23

HONOLULU — An explosion caused by lava oozing into the ocean sent… Continue reading

Banff holds blessing ceremony with Indigenous elders before letting bison roam

BANFF, Alta. — Several Indigenous elders were flown by helicopter into the… Continue reading

Research expedition looks at unseen depths of Labrador Sea ecosystem

ST. JOHN’S, N.L. — Last summer, a team of scientists returned from… Continue reading

Protesters camped outside Saskatchewan legislature taking province to court

REGINA — Protesters camped outside the Saskatchewan legislature say they are taking… Continue reading

British PM accepts key amendments from hardline Brexiteers

LONDON — British Prime Minister Theresa May on Monday accepted amendments to… Continue reading

‘City of icebergs:’ Study says 100s of Arctic glaciers shrinking, disappearing

The statistics in her recently published paper say it all: hundreds of… Continue reading

U.S. hits back with WTO challenge against Canada’s retaliatory tariffs

OTTAWA — The United States fired back Monday at the Canadian government’s… Continue reading

Most Read


Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $185 for 260 issues (must live in delivery area to qualify) Unlimited Digital Access 99 cents for the first four weeks and then only $15 per month Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $15 a month