EI system no longer works

The Conservative government says Canadians receiving an income under the Employment Insurance program will be required to lower their standards when looking for work or risk losing their benefits.

The Conservative government says Canadians receiving an income under the Employment Insurance program will be required to lower their standards when looking for work or risk losing their benefits.

It’s a small step, but it should be the start of a major overhaul of a system that often seems to reward seasonal workers in regions with high unemployment, while punishing those who live in low-unemployment areas. As numerous studies have concluded, Canada’s EI system is not only inequitable, it discourages labour mobility and encourages dependency, even while thousands of jobs are unfilled in areas of high unemployment.

Canadians looking for work while collecting EI are currently entitled to turn down jobs that are “unsuitable,” which could be work in a different city or in a different occupation with dramatically lower pay. The federal government intends to redefine the term “suitable” in a way that would require unemployed workers to accept different or lower-paying jobs, although the precise terms haven’t been revealed, which will lead to unnecessary and likely extreme speculation.

It shouldn’t mean that a laid-off engineer would have to take a job on the bottle line in a brewery. If a professional is out of work, presumably he or she would use their unemployment benefits as a stop-gap measure while looking for work in the same field, even if it means relocating.

Nor should it mean a 50-year-old shoe salesman will have to start digging ditches, but the salesman might have to take a different job, even if it pays less.

A 2007 survey by the Canadian Federation of Independent Business found 22 per cent of its members had difficulty hiring someone in the past year because they felt potential employees would rather collect EI benefits. Another 16 per cent said they had workers who asked to be laid off because they wanted to collect EI.

The rates were much higher in places such as Newfoundland and Prince Edward Island, despite the fact economic conditions were strong when the survey was conducted.

EI benefits are easier to obtain, and for longer periods, in regions with high unemployment than in low unemployment areas, thus creating different classes of jobless. The disparity ignores the fact workers and employers pay the same premiums, regardless of the unemployment rate.

The 2008 recession, for example, hit Ontario hard, yet its unemployed workers received fewer benefits and less job-training assistance than other areas of the country where unemployment is chronic. The disparity in the way benefits are paid is another form of transfer payment, except the result is not equalization, but perpetuation of the status quo.

In a normal labour market, the unemployed in an economically challenged region would move to greener pastures elsewhere in the country, but the EI system encourages the unemployed to sit tight, particularly seasonal workers who have grown comfortable with seven months of full time work, followed by a period on EI.

Employment Insurance, which is funded by employers and employees, is sometimes called a pillar of Canada’s social safety network, but its original intent has become distorted over the decades. It was established in the aftermath of the Great Depression when the prevailing attitude was any job was a good job, and unemployment was a badge of shame.

Attitudes to work have changed since then, but no one should expect the system to subsidize their wages in a seasonal industry, or to write cheques for those who don’t want to dirty their hands. EI is a worthy and necessary program, but it needs to be reworked for the 21st century, rather than serve as a political tool that reinforces geographical disparity and soft attitudes about the value of work.

An editorial from the Winnipeg Free Press.

Just Posted

Red Deer boat launches closed due to rising water levels

More thawing ice and snow means a higher Red Deer River and… Continue reading

Candles, flowers, messages of support at scene of Toronto van attack

TORONTO — Candles, flowers and messages of support are being left this… Continue reading

Sentencing hearing for second-degree murder in woman’s online beating death

WINNIPEG — A sentencing hearing is underway for a teenager who pleaded… Continue reading

Canadian firm linked to Facebook data scandal defends its political work

OTTAWA — The co-founders of a Canadian company at the centre of… Continue reading

G7 ministers probe threats of ‘dark’ internet in wake of daylight van attack

TORONTO — Security ministers from the G7 countries are discussing how to… Continue reading

WATCH: Central Alberta dancers take over Red Deer College with their moves

Danceworks Central Alberta Dance Festival is now in its 38th year

Toronto in mourning day after van attack left 10 dead, 15 injured

TORONTO — Shock gave way to grief in Toronto on Tuesday as… Continue reading

2 approaches to turning recycled materials into art

What have you not seen recycled into an art form? Everything from… Continue reading

How a small P.E.I. police force is using humour to charm the internet

KENSINGTON, P.E.I. — A police force in a tiny Prince Edward Island… Continue reading

Habana, World Cup winner & Springbok record-holder, retiring

Bryan Habana, the lightning-fast South Africa wing and World Cup winner with… Continue reading

Canadians head home after U-17 soccer tournament called off due to violence

Canada coach Bev Priestman was preparing her team for a game Sunday… Continue reading

TV’s ‘Homeland’ feels challenge of competing with real world

WASHINGTON — Members of the cast of TV’s “Homeland” call it “spy… Continue reading

As Osoyoos Indian Band flourishes, so too does Okanagan’s wine tourism

Indigenous practices have driven growth of South Okanagan’s wine history and agricultural influence

Opioid treatment gap in Medicare: methadone clinics

One in three older Americans with Medicare drug coverage is prescribed opioid… Continue reading

Most Read


Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $185 for 260 issues (must live in delivery area to qualify) Unlimited Digital Access 99 cents for the first four weeks and then only $15 per month Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $15 a month