Facts should guide decision on Canada Pension Plan

Consider Premier Jason Kenney’s threat to withdraw from the Canada Pension Plan.

AIMCO, the provincial body that administers the Heritage Fund and public pensions, earned a 2.3 per cent return in 2018, whereas the CPP had a return of 11.6 per cent.

Norway’s Heritage Fund has over $1 trillion; the Alberta Heritage Fund has less than $13 billion.

Alberta sends tax money collected in the province to Ottawa, which then redistributes the money to the provinces as equalization payments, according to a set formula, which by definition, has to be fair to all; otherwise, it would be difficult to understand its existence.

Some provinces naturally contribute more, and others receive more. Unknown to many Albertans, this present equalization formula was the creation of the Harper government and Kenney was a key minister at this time.

Our revenue problem could be reduced with political will. Albertans have the lowest personal taxes in Canada. We are the only province without a sales tax. The UCP has pledged to reduce corporate taxes to eight per cent over four years.

The UCP squashed the carbon tax and reduced our oil royalties.

Clearly, we have a revenue problem, not a spending problem. Creating panels to study our finances and our options in lieu of CPP is only wasteful expenditure when the solution is staring us in the face, and at less cost to the taxpayer.

The following question was posed in the Red Deer Advocate to its subscribers: “Should Alberta leave the Canadian Pension Plan and start its own system?”

Of the respondents, 73.29 per cent voted in favour. The question remains: How many people voted?

It is very easy to manipulate undiscerning citizens. We must not allow ourselves to be deceived by misleading information, articulate emotion, half-truths and our own bias.

Instead, only essential facts and verifiable information should be our guide. Ignore double-speak. Those who control the information will attain the expected results. This is the danger.

Government is mandated to govern in its citizens’ best interests. It is necessary to question and speak out. It’s foolish to believe just because somebody says so.

Larry Melnychuk, Red Deer

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

City’s COVID-19 cases jump to nine from six

Central zone active cases remains lowest of all zones

City of Red Deer trims staff by five per cent to deal with new economic realities

Downsizing of the municipal workforce will cut the annual budget by $7 million

Boys and Girls Club haunted house cancelled

Popular spookfest postponed because of pandemic health restrictions

Demand at Catholic Social Services jumps during pandemic

Provincial fundraising campaign launched

QUIZ: A celebration of apples

September is the start of the apple harvest

Murray, Nuggets hang on in Game 3, cut Lakers’ lead to 2-1

Murray, Nuggets hang on in Game 3, cut Lakers’ lead to 2-1

Indians clinch post-season berth; Braves claim NL East title

Indians clinch post-season berth; Braves claim NL East title

Major League Rugby to kick off fourth season in March 2021 with 13 teams

Major League Rugby to kick off fourth season in March 2021 with 13 teams

Mickelson and late-night range session key for DeChambeau

Mickelson and late-night range session key for DeChambeau

Toronto FC learns rest of rejigged MLS schedule, with a busy October ahead

Toronto FC learns rest of rejigged MLS schedule, with a busy October ahead

Andreescu out for rest of tennis season to focus on health and training

Andreescu out for rest of tennis season to focus on health and training

Cole has sharp playoff prep as Yankees rout Blue Jays 12-1

Cole has sharp playoff prep as Yankees rout Blue Jays 12-1

Jeff steps down as FC Edmonton coach, will stay on in player development role

Jeff steps down as FC Edmonton coach, will stay on in player development role

Most Read