Flawed comparisons guised as fact regarding pension plan

Flawed comparisons guised as fact regarding pension plan

Re: “Facts should guide decision on Canada Pension Plan,” Letter, Dec. 3.

In the Dec. 3 publication of The Advocate, flawed comparisons were utilized in a letter to the editor.

He stated correctly that AIMCO, the provincial body that administers the Heritage Fund and public pensions, earned a 2.3 per cent rate of return for the calendar year of 2018 (Jan. 1 to Dec. 31).

He also states the CPP Investment Board achieved a rate of return of 11.6 per cent.

However, this CPP reporting period was for the fiscal year of April 1, 2017, to March 31, 2018, as reported in the CPP Investment Board’s 2018 annual report.

Had this 9.3 per cent difference in rate of return between the two plans been true for the same time frame, you would have heard it throughout the media, as the investment managers of AIMCO would have been fired by the AIMCO board of directors.

However, this did not happen. Why? It simply isn’t true.

Upon checking any investment chart for these two distinctly different one-year time frames, one would quickly realize that in layman’s terms, he is comparing apples to an elephant.

People with even the slightest financial acumen would never compare the rate of return of two totally different and unique one-year time frames in an investment performance analysis.

After spending 32 years in the financial management world, I have come to know that both AIMCO and the CPPIB have achieved stellar long-term investment performance above their benchmarks. (The better comparison methodology due to different year-end reporting periods.)

There is much to consider in a possible withdrawal from CPP by the province. However, long-term investment performance between these two plans is not one of them.

In the letter, he speaks of how easy it is to manipulate undiscerning citizens and that we must not allow ourselves to be deceived by misleading information, half-truths and bias. Instead, only essential facts and verifiable information should be our guide.

Yet he is the author of the very things he espouses to be scandalous. He speaks of facts, yet over half of his letter is either his own politically biased opinion or half-truths.

“This is the danger,” as he succinctly wrote, especially when they are guised as “essential facts and verifiable information.”

He asserts that the province has a revenue problem, not a spending problem. A recent Royal Bank of Canada report stated the Alberta government spends approximately $500 more per person every year on program expenses than Quebec.

How can this be, when Quebec has a costly subsidized provincial daycare program? However, Alberta taxpayers are already spending $500 more per year on other program expenses than Quebec.

The blue ribbon panel of experts that studied Alberta’s finances concluded Alberta taxpayers would save more than $10 billion every year if government brought spending in line with similar provinces.

The panel chairman summed up the report with the statement, “Alberta has a spending problem.”

All we have heard from the Opposition and union leaders is that “the report is flawed,” with no facts to support their assertions. Covering up Alberta’s spending problem with higher taxes is not the solution the majority of Albertans are looking for in this weaker economy.

Another 18,200 Alberta jobs were lost in November, increasing the number of Albertans unemployed to more than 185,000, according to Statistics Canada.

It is necessary to question and speak out. After 32 years of being unable to do so publicly because of corporate policy, I’m discovering that retirement does have advantages.

The letter witer is correct: “It’s foolish to believe just because somebody says so,” especially with today’s politicians, leaders and various questionable information sources. As my mother used to say: “Do your homework.”

Ken Hayward is a Red Deer County resident.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Canadian drivers may not be as courteous as they thing, says a new survey.
Black Press file photo
83% of Alberta drivers admit to speeding: survey

97% of drivers admit to aggressive or road rage-like behaviour

Council approved a $3 million grant and a $19 million loan Tuesday to help keep Westerner Park sustainable. (Advocate file photo)
Red Deer city council approves $22M to keep Westerner Park viable after emotional debate

It’s vital ensure future success for the huge economic generator, says mayor

Red Deer Rebels goalie Chase Coward tries to find a loose puck during WHL action at the Centrium earlier this season. (Photo by ROB WALLATOR/Red Deer Rebels)
Changes on the horizon for Red Deer Rebels next season

New coach, roster adjustments among top priorities for Sutter this offseason

Renovations and construction have begun at Red Deer Dream Centre. (Photo contributed)
Renovations underway at Red Deer Dream Centre

Christian-based addictions treatment centre

Alberta Premier Jason Kenney. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jason Franson
Here is a list of latest COVID-19 restrictions in effect in Alberta

New mandatory health restrictions are now in effect in Alberta. Additional restrictions… Continue reading

An Empire Day/Victoria Day gathering of school children on Ross Street by the Cenotaph in the 1920s. On the right hand side, are members of the Red Deer Citizens Band (forerunner of the Red Deer Royals). (Photo via Red Deer Archives)
Victoria Day event helped after war

One hundred years ago, on May 24, 1921, a major community event… Continue reading

Gwynne Dyer
Gwynne Dyer: Independence is a one-way gate

Nicola Sturgeon, First Minister of Scotland declared in 2014 that the referendum… Continue reading

Boston Bruins left wing Nick Ritchie (21) and Washington Capitals defenseman Brenden Dillon (4) battle for the puck during the first period of an NHL hockey game, Tuesday, May 11, 2021, in Washington. (AP Photo/Nick Wass)
Raffl’s late goal pushes Capitals past Bruins, 2-1

Raffl’s late goal pushes Capitals past Bruins, 2-1

Chicago Blackhawks left wing Alex DeBrincat (12) celebrates with teammates after scoring a goal during the second period of an NHL hockey game against the Florida Panthers in Chicago, Saturday, May 1, 2021. (AP Photo/Nam Y. Huh)
Toews’ question chases Chicago Blackhawks into offseason

Toews’ question chases Chicago Blackhawks into offseason

Wheeler has two goals, two assists as Winnipeg Jets clinch third in North Division

Wheeler has two goals, two assists as Winnipeg Jets clinch third in North Division

Depleted Raptors drop a 115-96 decision to Leonard and Clippers

Depleted Raptors drop a 115-96 decision to Leonard and Clippers

Denis Shapovalov, of Canada, tosses the ball for a serve to Ilya Ivashka, of Belarus, during the Miami Open tennis tournament Saturday, March 27, 2021, in Miami Gardens, Fla. THE CANADIAN PRESS/AP/Wilfredo Lee
Canadian Felix Auger-Aliassime upsets Diego Schwartzman at Italian Open

Canadian Felix Auger-Aliassime upsets Diego Schwartzman at Italian Open

Philadelphia Flyers' James van Riemsdyk (25) and Sean Couturier (14) celebrate past New Jersey Devils' Yegor Sharangovich (17) after a goal by van Riemsdyk during the third period of an NHL hockey game, Monday, May 10, 2021, in Philadelphia. (AP Photo/Matt Slocum)
Flyers drop from trendy East favorite to another lost season

Flyers drop from trendy East favorite to another lost season

Most Read