Future of medicare hangs in the balance

Future of medicare hangs in the balance

A marathon British Columbia court case that could end up deciding the future of Canadian medicare is drawing to a close.

The case, now before the B.C. Supreme Court, was launched more than a decade ago by Vancouver orthopedic surgeon and longtime medicare critic Brian Day.

Closing arguments are expected to end next week.

Day, 72, is arguing that two B.C. rules designed to protect the integrity of medicare are unconstitutional.

One bans the sale of private insurance for services that are deemed medically necessary. This is meant to prevent the wealthy from queue jumping.

The second, often referred to as a ban on double dipping, prevents physicians who are enrolled in medicare from also offering privately paid, medically necessary services.

In effect, the double dipping ban forces doctors to make a choice: They can operate inside medicare or they can opt out. But they can’t do both.

The aim here is to prevent physicians from enjoying all the advantages of a single-pay, universal medicare system while at the same time allowing them to give preferential treatment to their more lucrative private patients.

Both rules are designed to prevent the growth of a two-tier health care system and to bring the province into compliance with the Canada Health Act, the federal law governing medicare.

Other provinces, including Ontario, have similar rules. Double dipping is banned in all provinces except Newfoundland and Labrador. Private insurance for medically necessary services is banned in the bigger provinces, including B.C., Alberta, Ontario and (with some exceptions) Quebec.

Supporters of the B.C. government’s position say these rules are necessary to maintain universal public health insurance in a world where the demand for health services always outstrips supply.

They argue convincingly that in such a world, determining treatment priority on the basis of need, as medicare does, is fairer than doing so on the basis of wealth.

In contrast, Day takes a more individualistic approach. He says that rules such as the ban on double dipping have the effect of delaying necessary health care to individuals with the wherewithal to pay for it privately, and thus interfere with their constitutional right to life, liberty and security of the person.

Regardless of how the B.C. court rules, this case is almost certain to end up at the Supreme Court of Canada. That’s not necessarily good news for medicare.

In 2005, the top court came within a whisker of declaring Quebec’s ban on private insurance for medically necessary services unconstitutional. The seven-judge panel hearing that case was virtually split down the middle, with three justices on each side. The seventh, in effect, abstained.

In that case, the court displayed little deference to the government’s argument that some restrictions on individual choice were necessary to protect a valuable and popular social program.

Nor were the judges overwhelmed by the expert testimony supporting medicare. Then-Chief Justice Beverley McLachlin dismissed it as “assertions of belief.”

The top court’s apparent willingness to think the unthinkable encouraged Day to bring his case.

One positive outcome of the near disastrous 2005 nondecision on the constitutionality of medicare was that it shocked governments, forcing them to address the perennial problem of medical wait times.

With luck, that will be the most Day accomplishes with his lawsuit. But don’t count on it. The courts can be unpredictable.

Thomas Walkom is a columnist with Torstar Syndication Services.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

A sign on a shop window indicates the store is closed in Ottawa, Monday March 23, 2020. The Canadian Federation of Independent Business is raising its estimate for the number of businesses that are considering the possibility of closing permanently. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Adrian Wyld
Alberta entrepreneur launches project to help small business owners

Bruce Tannas is trying to bring together small businesses as the COVID-19… Continue reading

Alberta Premier Jason Kenney updates media in Edmonton on measures taken to help with COVID-19 on Friday, March 20, 2020. Political analysts say Kenney must rethink his traditional “fight back” approach and start building bridges to reconcile environmental concerns with oil and gas development. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jason Franson
Political scientists say Kenney must rethink pugilistic approach on oil, environment

Keystone XL pipeline expansion would have taken more oil from Alberta through the United States to refineries and ports

An incomplete secondary wall stands alongside the previous version near where the border separating Tijuana, Mexico, and San Diego meets the Pacific Ocean Tuesday, Jan. 19, 2021, in Tijuana, Mexico. In the days before Joe Biden became president, construction crews worked quickly to finish Donald Trump’s wall at an iconic cross-border park overlooking the Pacific Ocean that then-first lady Pat Nixon inaugurated in 1971 as symbol of international friendship. (AP Photo/Gregory Bull)
Biden halts border wall building after Trump’s final surge

Pause order leaves billions of dollars of work unfinished but still under contract

Former Alberta Premier Rachel Notley shakes hands with Joel Ward, former Red Deer College President and CEO, as Notley announces that the college is on the path to grant degrees. Red Deer-South MLA Jason Stephan says university status is not a necessary condition for offering degrees. (File photo by Advocate staff)
Future of Red Deer University increasingly uncertain

MLA’s college update says RDC more like SAIT and NAIT than a university

There are two confirmed COVID-19 cases at Red Deer College. Photo by Mamta Lulla/Advocate staff
Central Albertans were promised a university

Central Albertans were promised a university

Jacqueline Donahue of Hazleton, right, buys la Mega Millions lottery ticket at the Anthracite Newsstand on Public Square, Monday, Jan. 18, 2021, in Wilkes-Barre, Pa. (Mark Moran/The Citizens’ Voice via AP)
Nearly $1B Mega Millions prize due to long odds, slow sales

Only the third time a lottery jackpot has grown so large

David Shoemaker, chief executive officer of the Canadian Olympic Committee, speaks during the Olympic Partnership kick off event at the Sobey’s office in Mississauga, Ont. on Monday, October 7, 2019. Shoemaker says the IOC remains committed to staging the Summer Games in Tokyo this summer. THE CANADIAN PRESS/ Tijana Martin
Canadian Olympic boss says IOC plans to go ahead with Tokyo Games this summer

IOC calls cancellation decision “categorically untrue”

FILE - In this Jan. 24, 2011 file photo, Dustin Diamond attends the SYFY premiere of “Mega Python vs. Gatoroid” at The Ziegfeld Theater in New York. Diamond is undergoing chemotherapy treatments after being diagnosed with cancer, according to his representative. Diamond, best known for playing Screech on the hit ’90s sitcom, was hospitalized earlier this month in Florida. Last week, his team disclosed he did have cancer. (AP Photo/Peter Kramer, File)
Dustin Diamond undergoing chemotherapy treatments for cancer

Diamond hospitalized earlier this month in Florida

Winnipeg Jets' Mark Scheifele, left, and Kyle Connor, right, congratulate Blake Wheeler on his goal during second period NHL action against the Ottawa Senators on Thursday, January 21, 2021 in Ottawa. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Adrian Wyld
Four different Jets score as Winnipeg beats the Ottawa Senators 4-1

Four different Jets score as Winnipeg beats the Ottawa Senators 4-1

Most Read