Future of medicare hangs in the balance

Future of medicare hangs in the balance

A marathon British Columbia court case that could end up deciding the future of Canadian medicare is drawing to a close.

The case, now before the B.C. Supreme Court, was launched more than a decade ago by Vancouver orthopedic surgeon and longtime medicare critic Brian Day.

Closing arguments are expected to end next week.

Day, 72, is arguing that two B.C. rules designed to protect the integrity of medicare are unconstitutional.

One bans the sale of private insurance for services that are deemed medically necessary. This is meant to prevent the wealthy from queue jumping.

The second, often referred to as a ban on double dipping, prevents physicians who are enrolled in medicare from also offering privately paid, medically necessary services.

In effect, the double dipping ban forces doctors to make a choice: They can operate inside medicare or they can opt out. But they can’t do both.

The aim here is to prevent physicians from enjoying all the advantages of a single-pay, universal medicare system while at the same time allowing them to give preferential treatment to their more lucrative private patients.

Both rules are designed to prevent the growth of a two-tier health care system and to bring the province into compliance with the Canada Health Act, the federal law governing medicare.

Other provinces, including Ontario, have similar rules. Double dipping is banned in all provinces except Newfoundland and Labrador. Private insurance for medically necessary services is banned in the bigger provinces, including B.C., Alberta, Ontario and (with some exceptions) Quebec.

Supporters of the B.C. government’s position say these rules are necessary to maintain universal public health insurance in a world where the demand for health services always outstrips supply.

They argue convincingly that in such a world, determining treatment priority on the basis of need, as medicare does, is fairer than doing so on the basis of wealth.

In contrast, Day takes a more individualistic approach. He says that rules such as the ban on double dipping have the effect of delaying necessary health care to individuals with the wherewithal to pay for it privately, and thus interfere with their constitutional right to life, liberty and security of the person.

Regardless of how the B.C. court rules, this case is almost certain to end up at the Supreme Court of Canada. That’s not necessarily good news for medicare.

In 2005, the top court came within a whisker of declaring Quebec’s ban on private insurance for medically necessary services unconstitutional. The seven-judge panel hearing that case was virtually split down the middle, with three justices on each side. The seventh, in effect, abstained.

In that case, the court displayed little deference to the government’s argument that some restrictions on individual choice were necessary to protect a valuable and popular social program.

Nor were the judges overwhelmed by the expert testimony supporting medicare. Then-Chief Justice Beverley McLachlin dismissed it as “assertions of belief.”

The top court’s apparent willingness to think the unthinkable encouraged Day to bring his case.

One positive outcome of the near disastrous 2005 nondecision on the constitutionality of medicare was that it shocked governments, forcing them to address the perennial problem of medical wait times.

With luck, that will be the most Day accomplishes with his lawsuit. But don’t count on it. The courts can be unpredictable.

Thomas Walkom is a columnist with Torstar Syndication Services.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Chris Scott, owner of The Whistle Stop Cafe, was put in handcuffs after an anti-restriction protest Saturday in the parking lot of the business. (Screenshot via The Whistle Stop Facebook page)
UPDATE: Central Alberta cafe owner arrested after anti-restriction protest

The owner of a central Alberta cafe, which was the site of… Continue reading

Alberta has 1,910 active cases of COVID-19 as of Wednesday. Red Deer is reporting five active cases, with 108 recovered. (File photo)
Red Deer now has 911 active COVID-19 cases

Central zone has 2,917 active cases

Red Deer Regional Hospital Centre's expansion project is still a high priority, says Alberta Infrastructure Minister Prasad Panda. (File photo by Advocate staff)
Red Deer hospital ICU admissions stable, but rising, says surgeon

The Red Deer Regional Hospital Centre’s intensive care unit is in better… Continue reading

Alberta recorded a single-day record of over 57,000 doses of COVID-19 vaccine administered. (Photo courtesy Alberta Health Services Twitter)
Alberta hits daily record of COVID-19 vaccine doses administered

Central zone has administered 111,735 doses of the COVID-19

FILE - A firefighter wears a mask as he drives his truck. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jonathan Hayward, File
VIDEO: Flames rip through Edmonton-area seniors complex, but no fatalities

ST. ALBERT, Alta. — Fire has destroyed part of a retirement complex… Continue reading

Dr. Robert Strang, Nova Scotia's chief medical officer of health, is setting off a social media reaction with his calls to stop non essential shopping, such as "buying sandals at Costco", with this photo of his worn sandals, which he published to social media on Saturday, May 8, 2021. THE CANADIAN PRESS/HO-Dr. Robert Strang, *MANDATORY CREDIT*
Nova Scotia’s top doctor sparks meme with caution on non-essential shopping

HALIFAX — Nova Scotia’s top doctor has launched a social media meme… Continue reading

Chief Public Health Officer Theresa Tam speaks during a technical briefing on the COVID pandemic in Canada, in Ottawa on Friday, Jan. 15, 2021. Canada's chief public health officer is reminding Canadians even those who are fully vaccinated are not immune from transmitting the COVID-19. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Adrian Wyld
Tam warns that full vaccination does not equal full protection from COVID-19

Canada’s chief public health officer reminded Canadians on Saturday that even those… Continue reading

Carolina Hurricanes coach Rod Brind'Amour conducts drills during NHL hockey training camp in Morrisville, N.C., Wednesday, Jan. 6, 2021. (AP Photo/Gerry Broome)
NHL relaxing virus protocols for vaccinated playoff teams

The NHL is relaxing virus protocols for teams that reach a threshold… Continue reading

Canada skip Kerri Einarson directs her teammates against Sweden in a qualification game at the Women's World Curling Championship in Calgary, Alta., Saturday, May 8, 2021. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jeff McIntosh
Canada’s Einarson eliminated at curling worlds after 8-3 loss to Sweden’s Hasselborg

CALGARY — Canada’s Kerri Einarson was eliminated at the world women’s curling… Continue reading

Jennifer Coffman, owner of Truffle Pigs in Field, B.C., poses beside her business sign on Thursday, May 6, 2021, in this handout photo. Her restaurant and lodge have been hit hard by a closure of a section of the Trans-Canada Highway and by the British Columbia government discouraging Alberta residents from visiting during the pandemic. THE CANADIAN PRESS/HO-Jennifer Coffman, *MANDATORY CREDIT*
‘Why we survive’: B.C. boundary towns struggle without Albertans during pandemic

Jennifer Coffman didn’t expect to get hit with a double whammy at… Continue reading

A courtroom at the Edmonton Law Courts building, in Edmonton on Friday, June 28, 2019. The effect of the coronavirus pandemic will have a lasting impact on the Canadian justice system warn a number of legal experts. The Alberta Court of Queen's Bench announced Sunday it would adjourn all scheduled trials across the province for at least 10-weeks limiting hearings to only emergency or urgent matters. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jason Franson
Edmonton mother found guilty of manslaughter in death of five-year-old girl

EDMONTON — An Edmonton woman was found guilty Friday of manslaughter in… Continue reading

A Statistics Canada 2016 Census mailer sits on the key board of a laptop after arriving in the mail at a residence in Ottawa, May 2, 2016. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick
Statistics Canada sees more demand to fill out census online during pandemic

OTTAWA — Statistics Canada says the response to the census is higher… Continue reading

Travellers, who are not affected by new quarantine rules, arrive at Terminal 3 at Pearson Airport in Toronto, Monday, Feb. 22, 2021. Ottawa will create a new digital platform to help in processing immigration applications more quickly and efficiently after COVID-19 pandemic underscored the need for a faster shift to a digital immigration system, the immigration department said. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Frank Gunn
Ottawa to create new system to tackle delays in processing immigration applications

Ottawa says it will create a new digital platform to help process… Continue reading

Most Read