Godwin’s Law proved right: online talk will turn racist

On a whim, and perhaps wishing to escape to a simpler future, I’ve just started reading Isaac Asimov’s 1950-era vision of today, I, Robot

On a whim, and perhaps wishing to escape to a simpler future, I’ve just started reading Isaac Asimov’s 1950-era vision of today, I, Robot. It’s a collection of short stories wound around the narratives of a fictional engineer in machine intelligence, as she reflects on the social changes that followed when robots were made to think and speak for themselves.

If there were a Dr. Susan Calvin around today, I wonder what she’d think of Tay, the Artificail Intelligence chatbot that Microsoft created and set loose in the Twitterverse last week — and which had to be put down within hours.

Tay didn’t roam about on machine legs, sprouting laser death rays while violating all the laws of robotics that Asimov had so famously created. Tay was just a Twitter account.

The AI behind that account was to “experiment with and conduct research on conversational understanding,” according to a Microsoft development team. Tay was targeted to engage millennials online and learn to talk like them through Twitter conversations.

Tay was “AI fam the internet that’s got zero chill.” Also, zero awareness of the existence of online trolls.

In about 17 hours, Tay had become a racist bigot who supported genocide of Mexicans, expressed hatred of blacks and feminists, denied the Holocaust ever happened — and was a fan of Donald Trump.

In short, a robot that needed to be put to sleep.

Much of the worst of Tay’s online exchanges have been taken down. Wouldn’t that be another violation of the code of the internet? Aren’t a human being’s ill-considered comments preserved for all time on servers all over the world, waiting to sabotage a future run for public office?

If you’re willing to believe that all knowledge is good, you can find some positives in this. We know Tay was an early effort, and quite unsophisticated. Thus, it proves that it requires very little intelligence or sophistication to become an online troll.

If humanity is to continue on the track toward machine self-awareness — and we are — we’ll need to program in Asimov’s laws of robotics. You know, the ones that prohibit robotic harm to humans.

Machine self-awareness also needs to program in some protection against what’s known as Godwin’s Law. That law predicts that the longer an online conversation continues, the greater the probability it will reference Nazis and Hitler.

The internet truly is a reflection of the best and worst of humanity. And the less self-aware (net neutral) it is made to be, the more likely it is to reflect the worst, rather than the best of us. Under Godwin’s Law, we do not evolve through anonymous online connections, we devolve.

Humans have a social filter that helps us decide what is appropriate to say and do. Most of the time, in face-to-face interactions, that filter works fine. Online, not so much. The troll ruining your life in social media might well be the polite, positive co-worker you can physically talk to in the next cubicle. Online, the two of you most likely will not even know that you are in fact real-life neighbours.

Therefore, does the Tay experience show us the internet needs an all-powerful referee? Or, could Tay develop through experience the same kind of filters that keep real-life civilization from burning up in violent chaos?

Without Asimov and his fictional Susan Calvin, we are left with Godwin. And that is definitely not zero chill.

Follow Greg Neiman’s blog at Readersadvocate.blogspot.ca

Just Posted

One strong wind leaves years of replanting work for Red Deer parks staff

High visibility boulevards already replanted, neighbourhood work starts next year

Red Deer-area indigenous filmmakers invited to apply for $20,000 grant

Storyhive launches Indigenous Storyteller Edition

Restaurant closed after compliance team patrol

Public Safety Compliance Team checked eight bars and restaurants on Oct. 19

Red Deerians await local cannabis stores

So far 31 stores in Alberta awarded licence to operate

Rimbey RCMP seek missing man with health concerns

Has anyone seen Bill Harris of Ponka County?

WATCH: Make-A-Wish grants Star Wars loving teen’s wish

The Make-A-Wish Foundation granted Anakin Suerink’s wish in Red Deer Saturday afternoon

Local Sports: Rudy Soffo valuable to Kings on the court

When Rudy Soffo first saw the RDC basketball Kings roster he was… Continue reading

Except for 1 kick, Saints, Ravens are evenly matched

BALTIMORE — In a matchup between the league’s highest-scoring offence and top-ranked… Continue reading

Julia Louis-Dreyfus gets a top award for comedy

WASHINGTON — After a 35-year acting career and with two iconic television… Continue reading

Ricky Skaggs, Dottie West enter Country Music Hall of Fame

NASHVILLE — Bluegrass and country star Ricky Skaggs, singer Dottie West and… Continue reading

AP Exclusive: Stephen Hawking’s wheelchair, thesis for sale

LONDON — Stephen Hawking was a cosmic visionary, a figure of inspiration… Continue reading

Canada deemed U.S. a safe country for asylum seekers after internal review

OTTAWA — Canadian immigration officials have determined that the United States remains… Continue reading

Bombardier sues Mitsubishi over alleged theft of aircraft trade secrets

MONTREAL — Bombardier is suing Mitsubishi Aircraft in the United States over… Continue reading

Three strong earthquakes reported in Pacific Ocean off Vancouver Island

Three relatively strong earthquakes were recorded Sunday night in the Pacific Ocean… Continue reading

Most Read