Hébert: Risky for PM if new chief justice not a Quebecer

Hébert: Risky for PM if new chief justice not a Quebecer

The leading candidate to replace the formidable Beverley McLachlin as she takes her leave as Canada’s chief justice this month was appointed to the Supreme Court by Stephen Harper in 2012.

Over the three years that followed the accession of Quebec justice Richard Wagner to the top bench, the number of Harper appointees to the Court grew to a majority.

Over the same period, the proportion of split rulings on major decisions increased.

That, at least, is the finding of the Macdonald-Laurier Institute, an Ottawa public policy think-tank. Based on a sampling of 10 high-profile rulings a year, the review conducted by Benjamin Perrin, a law professor at the University of British Columbia and a former legal adviser to Harper, found that from 2014 to 2015, the proportion of unanimous decisions on major cases declined from 80 per cent to 50 per cent.

Under McLachlin the court did speak with one voice on some of the most contentious issues that came its way. It was unanimous in giving the green light to medically assisted suicide. And there was no dissent on the decision to send Harper’s senate reform plan back to the drawing board. A 2014 landmark ruling that extended Indigenous land-title rights was also unanimous.

But in the past few years, Perrin notes that “a vocal cadre” of judges has come to increasingly argue that the court is infringing on the policy-making role of Parliament.

Among that group, Wagner has been one of the more constant defenders of Harper’s law-and order legacy, dissenting with the court’s majority decision to strike down mandatory minimum penalties for repeat drug traffickers and for gun crimes.

He also disagreed with the court’s constitutional recognition of the right to strike.

Whether those opinions signal a more deferential approach to the elected branch of government is debatable.

On issues that happen to be a matter of strong consensus in Quebec, Wagner has tended to go against the federal government.

He was on side with the court’s consensus to nix both the Conservative bid to bypass the constitutional route to reform the Senate and the attempt to expand the eligibility criteria for the selection of Quebec appointees to the top court.

Wagner also joined his two Quebec colleagues in dissent when the court turned down Quebec’s request to force Harper to hand it the provincial data of the defunct federal gun registry.

By any measure, the choice of McLachlin’s successor is one of the most significant appointments Trudeau will make as prime minister and one he will likely have to live with for the duration of his political tenure.

McLachlin was Canada’s longest serving chief justice. Over her 29 years as a Supreme Court judge – 18 of those as chief justice – she outlasted five prime ministers. The decisions she presided over impacted just about every public policy area. If appointed, Wagner, 60, would be looking at 15 years in the leading role.

The chief justice was, if not the most powerful, certainly the most influential woman in Canada’s public life for the better part of two decades. She leaves her successor an institution that is held in significantly higher regard by the public than Parliament and those who inhabit it.

As the uneasy cohabitation between the Supreme Court and Harper demonstrated, the former can act as a major counterweight to the power of a majority prime minister.

It has usually been the practice to alternate between a civil code jurist (i.e., one from Quebec) and a common-law one. Based on that, Wagner has always been considered the prohibitive favourite for the position.

The prime minister has surprised observers in the recent past. Trudeau had been widely expected to select at least one Indigenous appointee for either the post of governor-general or the most recent Supreme Court vacancy. That did not happen.

But in this case, the prime minister would only venture off the beaten path at the risk of a serious backlash in his home province. Both the Quebec legal community and the national assembly expect the next chief justice to be a Quebecer. And with contentious challenges to the province’s secularism policies in the legal pipeline, this is not a good time to alienate Quebec from the Supreme Court.

If, as most expect, Wagner does get the nod from the prime minister this month, Trudeau will be following his head albeit not necessarily his heart.

Chantal Hébert is a national affairs writer.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

A health-care worker prepares a dose of the Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 vaccine at a clinic in Toronto on Thursday, January 7, 2021. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Nathan Denette
Alberta vaccine rollout expanding to front-line health-care workers

More than 240,000 eligible health-care workers can begin booking vaccine appointments starting… Continue reading

File photo
The Red Deer Rebels will have three new assistant coaches when the WHL regular season starts on Friday. Brad Flynn (left), will be on the bench alongside fellow assistant Ryan Colville (right) head coach Brent Sutter (middle). (Photo by BYRON HACKETT/Advocate Staff)
Sutter steps down as Red Deer Rebels head coach

Red Deer Rebels Owner, GM and head coach Brent Sutter has stepped… Continue reading

Premier Jason Kenney announced $200 million more money that will benefit seniors living in continuing care on Wednesday. (photography by Chris Schwarz/Government of Alberta)
Alberta’s in-school rapid screening test program expanding

Alberta’s in-school rapid screening test program will expand to as many as… Continue reading

Parents and students learned Tuesday what the coming school year will look like. It's pretty much back to business as usual, said Education Minister Adriana LaGrange. School precautions include frequent cleaning, keeping students in the same groups where possible, planning the school day to allow for physical distancing and staying home when sick. (photography by Chris Schwarz/Government of Alberta)
Alberta’s largest school board says no to United Conservative draft school curriculum

CALGARY — Alberta’s largest school board says it will not use the… Continue reading

Red Deer-South MLA Jason Stephan is among those who have signed an open letter criticizing the government’s return to stricter health measures. (Advocate file photo).
Updated: Kenney tells UCP caucus COVID-19 dissent OK, breaking health rules means expulsion

15 MLAs released letter on Wednesday critical of new health restrictions

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau watches a speaker appear by videoconference during a news conference in Ottawa, Friday, April 9, 2021. Grassroots Liberals have overwhelmingly endorsed a resolution calling on the federal government to develop and implement a universal basic income — despite Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's apparent lack of enthusiasm for the idea. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Adrian Wyld
Trudeau winds up Liberal convention with election campaign-style speech

OTTAWA — Justin Trudeau wound up a three-day Liberal convention Saturday with… Continue reading

Team Canada skip Brendan Bottcher makes a shot against Italy at the Men's World Curling Championships in Calgary, Alta., Tuesday, April 6, 2021.THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jeff McIntosh
Men’s world curling championship in Calgary in COVID limbo

CALGARY — The men’s world curling championship in Calgary remained suspended Saturday… Continue reading

Pipes intended for construction of the Keystone XL pipeline are shown in Gascoyne, N.D. on Wednesday April 22, 2015. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Alex Panetta
Non-profit Quebec law centre to aid environmental group targeted by Alberta oil firm

QUEBEC — The Quebec Environmental Law Centre is coming to the aid… Continue reading

Conservative leader Erin O'Toole holds a press conference on Parliament Hill in Ottawa on Tuesday, April 6, 2020. Top Tory leaders of past and present will speak with supporters today about what a conservative economic recovery from COVID-19 could look like. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick
Conservatives cite empathy, relationships as ways to help expand their movement

OTTAWA — Conservatives should show empathy with Black residents who say they’ve… Continue reading

NDP Leader John Horgan celebrates his election win in the British Columbia provincial election in downtown Vancouver, B.C., Saturday, Oct. 24, 2020. New Democrats are reconvening for the second day of a three-day policy convention as they look to push past the glitches of the virtual event's opening sessions and rally around keynote speaker John Horgan. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jonathan Hayward
New Democrats reconvene as hiccups, frustrations plague national policy convention

OTTAWA — New Democrats reconvened Saturday for the second day of a… Continue reading

FILE - In this Monday, Oct. 23, 2017 file photo, President Donald Trump speaks during a joint statement with Singapore's Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong in the Rose Garden of the White House in Washington. Former President Donald Trump plans to affirm his commitment to the Republican Party — and raise the possibility that someone else will be the GOP's next presidential nominee — in a closed-door speech to donors Saturday night, April 10, 2021. (AP Photo/Evan Vucci, File)
Trump in 2024? He says only that ‘a Republican’ will win

PALM BEACH, Fla. — Former President Donald Trump plans to affirm his… Continue reading

A cruise ship sits docked waiting for passengers to be evacuated in Kingstown, on the eastern Caribbean island of St. Vincent, Friday, April 9, 2021 due to the eruption of La Soufriere volcano. (AP Photo/Orvil Samuel)
Ash-covered St. Vincent braces for more volcanic eruptions

KINGSTOWN, St. Vincent — People who ignored an initial warning to evacuate… Continue reading

Owner of 4 Point Taekwondo Kevin Mejia holds a board as organizer and martial artist Kevin Olsen breaks it in Edmonton on Friday, April 9, 2021. One hundred martial artists from around the world, will be breaking a board for an event called "Break for a Breakthrough." The idea is for martial artists to unite and re-engage with the arts because they may have drifted away or lost enthusiasm as a result of the pandemic. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jason Franson
Break for a Breakthrough: Canadian hosts international martial arts demonstration

EDMONTON — Whether he’s breaking a wooden board, a clay tile, cement… Continue reading

Most Read