Heritage Fund performance is pathetic

Living in Alberta from the end of the Lougheed era to the rise of Redford, I have been subjected to an ideological buffet on the topic of the Alberta Heritage Fund. The Lougheed concept was classic common good pragmatism: clip annual tithes from provincial oil and gas resource royalties and invest them for the future.

Living in Alberta from the end of the Lougheed era to the rise of Redford, I have been subjected to an ideological buffet on the topic of the Alberta Heritage Fund. The Lougheed concept was classic common good pragmatism: clip annual tithes from provincial oil and gas resource royalties and invest them for the future.

Why? Because one day the resources will be completely produced, and like in the Klondike, the miners will return home, leaving Alberta to fend for itself.

Paying down the mortgage

In a post-resource exploitation landscape, Alberta will have to think long and hard about paying the mortgage, and retaining ownership of the provincial farm. Right now, if resource royalties were to completely dry up, the provincial treasury would be short $8.3 billion per year, on an annual operating budget of $29- billion (figs. courtesy Jeffrey Simpson, Globe and Mail: Feb. 10, 2012).

It is hard to see how that revenue stream will be replaced by a full-on return to the agricultural sector or tourism.

Who knows, perhaps throngs of global tourists will stream through the Edmonton airport on their way to view the reclaimed oil sands hillocks, the carefully tended buffalo paddocks, and the glittering lakes of effluent.

More to the point would be middle class jobs in manufacturing. However, those are precisely the kind of jobs that are decreasing in central Canada right now, as Mexican labour and efficiencies produce smaller cars and tools for a leaner North American market.

How Alberta will morph from bitumen production to I-Pad 33 producer in the next 30 years is hard for me to imagine. Doing so without a drastic recourse to deficit expenditure of Grecian proportions is even harder. Suddenly implementing a provincial sales tax, and hiking personal and corporate taxes in a recession (or worse) is also not a winning economic strategy.

And that is precisely why heritage funds make such good, common sense.

Norway’s Sovereign Wealth Fund, with over $500 billion invested, and the Alaska Permanent Fund with over $38 billion are great examples of getting it right.

As their oil and gas resources deplete, so do their funds grow. In this way, a depleting resource is replaced by a sustainable one — invested cash. The goal is to create sufficient annual draws to offset the loss of royalties in the annual national or state budget.

The Alaska Permanent Fund also spins off a dividend cheque for each resident of the state for the preceding year. In 2011, the dividend cheque was $1,174, and is based on a five-year average of the Permanent Fund’s performance.

The re-expenditure effect of these cheques in the Alaskan economy is significant, and accounts for over 5,000 indirect and induced jobs in the local economy.

As well as cutting annual dividends for citizens, the Alaska Permanent Fund also undertakes annual inflation proofing and pays for all of its operating expenses. Over its 30 years of operations, from 1982 to the present, the citizens have shown no enthusiasm for expenditures of fund income for anything else.

In the light of the Norwegian and Alaskan experience, the post-Lougheed-era record of Alberta Heritage Fund investment is pathetic.

It has become a political football, much discussed, often raided for cash, and today (as of September 2011) its value stands at $14.7 billion, or slightly less than two years worth of current royalty payments on Alberta’s resource bounty.

Premier Alison Redford’s 2012 budget makes no commitments, other than having a “conversation with Albertans,” to changing the status quo.

From a conservative ideological perspective it is possible to argue that Alberta is maximizing personal ‘family heritage funds,’ by under-taxing and deferring resource royalty streams to cover capital, operating and maintenance expenditures on the common goods supplied by government.

By allowing Albertans to make more money, they are giving citizens the duty of prudently saving for their own futures. My family and many others have benefitted from this policy.

But we have also made plans to retire outside of Alberta one day, and to take our money with us. The taxes levied in our retirement will benefit B.C. more than Alberta.

Our family heritage funds will feed private pleasures more than the common good. And that is precisely the problem with an ideology that favours individuals over the common needs of citizens.

The purpose of our democratic society must surely be to protect the commons, and those institutions the citizens deem necessary for the common good.

What does the future look like when the wells run dry and the bitumen rivers no longer flow?

Let us face the facts: Alberta’s future without resource royalties and without a Heritage Fund is bleak. A pragmatic government would take action now before the gold rush ends.

Troy Media columnist Mike Robinson has lived half of his life in Alberta and half in BC. In Calgary he worked for eight years in the oil patch, 14 in academia.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Alberta’s chief medical officer of health, Dr. Deena Hinshaw, said the 500 deaths from COVID-19 in the province are a tragic milestone. (Photo by Chris Schwarz/Government of Alberta)
Alberta hits ‘tragic milestone’ with more COVID-19 deaths

Province up to 500 COVID-19 deaths, adds 1,265 cases

A recent investigation by the RCMP Central Alberta District Crime Reduction Unit led to the arrests of 24 people. (Contributed photo)
24 people arrested following RCMP investigation in central Alberta

Twenty-four people are facing a combined 235 charges following an investigation by… Continue reading

Photo from Town of Sylvan Lake Facebook page
Sylvan Lake communities band together on development plan

Sylvan Lake Intermunicipal Development Plan expected to be approved next spring

Tribe restaurant owner Paul Harris, left, consults with manager Brandon Bouchard about how to proceed under pandemic rules that make it hard for eateries to be profitable. (Contributed photo).
New pandemic rules deemed workable for Red Deer retailers

Stricter COVID-19 reduction measures introduced in lead-up to Christmas

Quentin Lee Strawberry
Man accused in 2019 Red Deer murder will stay behind bars

Quentin Strawberry going to trial next year on second-degree murder charge

Hockey Canada suspends world junior selection camp after positive COVID-19 tests

Hockey Canada suspends world junior selection camp after positive COVID-19 tests

Justice Minister David Lametti responds to a question during question period in the House of Commons Thursday, Nov. 19, 2020 in Ottawa. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Adrian Wyld
Liberals to present bill on single-game sports betting

Liberals to present bill on single-game sports betting

Bayern, Man City win to advance to Champions League last-16

Bayern, Man City win to advance to Champions League last-16

FILE - In this March 26, 2006 file photo, former soccer player Diego Maradona smokes a cigar as he watches Argentina's first division soccer match between Boca Juniors and River Plate in Buenos Aires, Argentina. The Argentine soccer great who was among the best players ever and who led his country to the 1986 World Cup title before later struggling with cocaine use and obesity, died from a heart attack on Wednesday, Nov. 25, 2020, at his home in Buenos Aires. He was 60. (AP Photo/Natacha Pisarenko, File)
Argentine soccer great Diego Maradona dies at 60

Argentine soccer great Diego Maradona dies at 60

In this July 1, 2020, photo, Salt Lake Tribune data columnist and Utah Jazz beat writer Andy Larsen poses for a photo. Larsen is a sports writer, but with much of that world sidelined during the pandemic he's been digging into coronavirus data and its sobering implications. So when he found himself with a cache of spare change, partially from his childhood piggy bank, he knew plenty of people could use it. (Francisco Kjolseth/The Salt Lake Tribune via AP)
Tweet on spare change generates big money for virus aid

Tweet on spare change generates big money for virus aid

FILE - In this Wednesday, March 18, 2020 file photo, a view of a 'Matterhorn-Express' gondola lift in front of Matterhorn mountain in the Zermatt ski resort, in Zermatt, Switzerland. Restrictions to slow the curve of coronavirus infections have kept ski lifts closed in Italy, France, Germany and Austria, as well as countries further east. But skiers are already heading to mountains in Switzerland, drawing an envious gaze from ski industry and local officials in mountain regions elsewhere on the continent who lost most of last season due to the virus. (Jean-Christophe Bott/Keystone via AP, File)
As season nears, Europe ponders skiing during pandemic

As season nears, Europe ponders skiing during pandemic

FILE - In this Dec. 10, 2015 file photo, actor John Boyega, right, pose with Star Wars characters during the Japan Premiere of their latest film "Star Wars: The Force Awakens" in Tokyo. Boyega stars in Steve McQueen’s “Red White and Blue,” the third film in the director’s anthology of West Indian life in London from the ‘60s through the ’80s. The five-film series will debut Dec. 4. (AP Photo/Koji Sasahara, File)
John Boyega isn’t going to ‘take the money and shush’

John Boyega isn’t going to ‘take the money and shush’

The Hockley Motel in Mono, Ont., is shown in this undated handout photo. An Ontario motel that served as a backdrop for the beloved CBC sitcom "Schitt's Creek" is up for sale. The Hockley Motel in Mono, about an hour's drive northwest of Toronto, was listed for $2 million today. THE CANADIAN PRESS/HO - Colliers International
Calling all eccentric millionaires: ‘Schitt’s Creek’ motel up for sale for $2 million

Calling all eccentric millionaires: ‘Schitt’s Creek’ motel up for sale for $2 million

Most Read