It’s time to get out of Afghanistan

Once there were reasons for the costly, long and deadly Canadian commitment to Afghanistan. Now there are none.

Once there were reasons for the costly, long and deadly Canadian commitment to Afghanistan. Now there are none.

Even if that judgment is arbitrary and contentious, there’s no better time to consider it than this week as the country pauses to remember the sacrifice of this and other wars.

After the best part of a decade on the ground, the military is now actively planning withdrawal from an Afghanistan still steeped in corruption, drugs and violence. Come summer 2011, Canada will pull back — but apparently not completely out — from a conflict so snarled in local and regional intrigues that it’s certain to continue years after the troops are home.

A few glimmering achievements illuminate a bleak situation. Those beating the Afghanistan drum loudest point to the number of girls in school, the infrastructure restored and the first faltering steps taken toward democracy as proof that the investment of lives and money has not been wasted.

Satisfying in themselves, those often-ephemeral advances toward modernity fall well short of justifying a mission that has now claimed 133 soldiers as well as one diplomat and will cost some $20 billion before it’s over. If the effort’s worth is to be fairly weighed, evolving outcomes must be tested against original motives.

Canada’s reasons for its blood and treasure offerings to Afghanistan have never been quite what they seemed or exactly as first Liberal and then Conservative governments explained. Creating a model democracy and civil society from warring factions and feudal customs is a softly engaging narrative that gains veracity through repetition. It’s not the hard-headed stuff that persuades prime ministers to put their political hegemony at risk by putting lives in harm’s way.

Make no mistake, troops were sent south to Kandahar after the Taliban was toppled in Kabul because it was thought to be in Canada’s interest. Taking a point position in the George W. Bush war on terror would prove to Americans that Canadians are serious about U.S. security, help keep the border open to sustaining trade and provide a welcome opportunity for the Armed Forces to prove to allies, as well as to themselves, that this country is again willing and able to do the world’s dangerous work.

What could be accomplished has now been accomplished.

Even if U.S. appreciation isn’t strong enough to see off the current “Buy American” threat to northern access to southern markets, those who matter most in Washington know what Ottawa has done. They understand that Canada got its hands dirty while some other NATO partners were keeping their skirts clean.

Less discussed is how the mission has restored the military. Sixteen years after its reputation was deeply stained by the photographed murder of a Somali teenager, pride in the Armed Forces is back.

Better equipped, sure of itself and its place among national icons, the military has good reasons to trumpet Afghanistan, despite the casualties, cost and continuing insurgency, as a significant victory.

But in politics and war, triumphs are fleeting.

Bowing to U.S. pressure to continue a losing battle won’t appreciably improve cross-border relations now shaped as much by domestic economics as international threats.

Any extension of the combat mission beyond 2011 would jeopardize current military success by demanding more than can be sustained by a small force already stretched too thin.

Whatever the motivations for going to Afghanistan, Canada has no compelling reason to stay longer.

Jim Travers writes for The Toronto Star Syndicate.

Just Posted

Legalizing cannabis cost estimate for Red Deer just under $400k

Although the province of Alberta has announced $11.2 million for cannabis legalization,… Continue reading

WATCH: Every square tells a story: Edmonton expert is exploring Red Deer’s quilting history

Community members can bring in family heirloom quilts for documentation

Red Deer-area dads going through divorce are invited to Man Up

Support group formed to focus on positive activities, networking

WATCH: Two weeks away from Canadian Finals Rodeo in Red Deer

In just two weeks, Ponoka’s Shayna Weir will compete with the best… Continue reading

PHOTO: Say goodbye to City Hall Park flowers

A sure sign that winter is on its way is when City… Continue reading

PHOTO: Chew On This! campaign draws attention to national poverty

Lunch bags were being handed out in front of The Hub downtown… Continue reading

Wickenheiser, Pegula reflect NHL’s trend toward diversity

BUFFALO, N.Y. — With a laugh, Kim Pegula’s competitive nature kicked in… Continue reading

Harry and Meghan bring rain to drought-stricken Outback town

DUBBO, Australia — The Duke and Duchess of Sussex were jokingly thanked… Continue reading

TV Review: A Roseanne Barr-less ‘The Conners’ is a triumph

NEW YORK — Can there be a “Roseanne” without Roseanne? The answer… Continue reading

Canadian manufacturing sales fell 0.4 per cent in August: Statistics Canada

OTTAWA — Statistics Canada says manufacturing sales fell 0.4 per cent to… Continue reading

Brian Mulroney joins board of directors of New York-based pot company

NEW YORK — Former prime minister Brian Mulroney is joining the board… Continue reading

Canadians waking up to legalized cannabis: ‘My new dealer is the prime minister’

ST. JOHN’S, N.L. — Canadians across the country woke up to legalized… Continue reading

Most Read