Just voluntary slavery

Don’t you find it odd (and ironic) how wealthy people can say that raising the marginal tax rate on the top 10 per cent of income-earners is theft and bad for the economy?

Don’t you find it odd (and ironic) how wealthy people can say that raising the marginal tax rate on the top 10 per cent of income-earners is theft and bad for the economy?

But at the same time they can believe that unemployed people should work for zero pay — for just the privilege and experience of helping the 10 per cent turn a profit for.

Bank of Canada chief Stephen Poloz didn’t suggest that directly when he said recently that unemployed millennials living in their parents’ basements would be better off volunteering their skills in an area close to their university degrees, as a means of padding their resumes.

But the message his unintended audience received was the ironic one.

Poloz said his speculations on why the unemployed should work for no pay at all was “not a monetary policy matter.”

Well, good for that. Can you imagine him saying we should turn our economy around by creating wealth for free?

He said he was merely relating the advice he gives to young people who ask him for advice on starting a career.

But giving something of value away for free, in the hopes you might get paid for it later, is bad career planning.

There are about 200,000 Canadians with recent university training who cannot find work. The unemployment rate among this group is nearly double that for everyone else.

Working for free, says Poloz, would fill the gap in one’s resume between getting a degree or diploma and getting a job. Poloz called the gap the “scarring effect” — the time spent when your credentials erode while others gain experience in your area, and yet others graduate with “fresher” skills.

As governor of the Bank of Canada, Poloz knows that every time he opens his mouth, people will parse every syllable of his sentences. They will search for meaning in every facial tic, while he gives his reasons why the Canada’s central bank will do essentially nothing for another 90 days.

So he should know better than to publicly advise people to work in an underground economy. Can he explain the difference between employers taking on workers but not paying them, and people taking pay for their work but declaring no income for tax purposes?

Both practices are common in Canada — and both are illegal. Unless a worker is required to undertake job experience as part of a certified education program, it is against the law not to pay that person.

It is against the law for a person to agree to work for less than minimum wage, and against the law to ask them to do it.

There is a reason Canada has laws governing labour standards. These internships and Poloz’s suggestion that young people offer their work for free both subvert Canada’s minimum wage and labour laws.

We already have a history of young people literally being worked to death for no pay as interns.

In Edmonton, an intern fell asleep while driving home after a 16-hour (unpaid) shift, and was killed in a car crash.

Bell Canada was the subject of official complaints for rotating hundreds of people a year through unpaid internships, with little or no hope of a job at the end of the “experience.”

Walrus magazine was only one Canadian publication that was forced to stop taking on unpaid internships after their subscribers learned how a high portion of the product they paid for was produced for zero pay.

A business can get pretty used to not paying some of their staff. They can come to regard it as an entitlement.

It’s not as if the work of these interns has no value. If an employer does not have work to offer requiring more skill than flipping hamburgers (which is at least paid work), what are they doing?

Why would an employer demand university training to do work that has zero value?

We already know that interns often do the same work as paid staff in many cases.

Agreed, the thousands of young people coming out of our very expensive colleges and universities with poor job opportunities in their area of training is a problem. Telling these highly-trained (and highly-indebted) people that they have no value is not the answer.

One critic said Poloz was “tone deaf” on the issue. I would say he was being deliberately obtuse.

If Canada’s industry is so uniquely skill-selective that no university or college can prepare someone to do that work, the employers need to provide the training themselves. After all, they’re the ones profiting from it.

St. Paul, the world’s first missionary (and a tent-maker by trade), said that every worker deserves his pay. And every slave must be properly fed, clothed, housed and cared for when sick.

What has changed since?

Greg Neiman is a retired Advocate editor. Follow his blog at readersadvocate.blogspot.ca or email greg.neiman.blog@gmail.com.

Just Posted

Photos: Red Deer barn dance entertains children, adults Tuesday

Hundreds of Central Albertans started their Westerner Days celebrations early with an… Continue reading

Manslaughter charge laid against Red Deer man more than a year after homicide

A manslaughter charge has been laid against a Red Deer man, more… Continue reading

Woman facing charges after pedestrian critically injured in hit and run

A woman is in custody in connection with an alleged hit and… Continue reading

Friday hail storm came at a bad time for farmers

Amount of damage a hail storm does often depends on how far along crops are

Record 10 homers as AL wins All-Star Game 8-6 in 10 innings

American League 8 National League 6 (1o innings) WASHINGTON — A record… Continue reading

Photos: Red Deer barn dance entertains children, adults Tuesday

Hundreds of Central Albertans started their Westerner Days celebrations early with an… Continue reading

Man suffers critical injuries, Red Deer police arrest woman in pedestrian crash

A man is in hospital with critical injuries and Mounties have arrested… Continue reading

Cull hasn’t been able to solve bunny burden in Alberta mountain town of Canmore

CANMORE, Alta. — Problems persist in an Alberta mountain town overrun with… Continue reading

Canada should help Holocaust denier on trial in Germany: civil liberties group

OTTAWA — A civil liberties group is urging the Canadian government to… Continue reading

Westerner Days: Send us your photos

Your reader photo may just make the pages of the Adovcate.

Adam Henrique signs $29.1M, 5-year extension with Ducks

ANAHEIM, Calif. — Centre Adam Henrique has signed a $29.1 million, five-year… Continue reading

Fashion firms upend design routine to focus on speed, trends

NEW YORK — Prototypes? Passe. Fashion company Betabrand saw that knitwear was… Continue reading

Most Read


Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $185 for 260 issues (must live in delivery area to qualify) Unlimited Digital Access 99 cents for the first four weeks and then only $15 per month Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $15 a month