Lots of rhetoric, few policies

Lots of rhetoric, few policies

Parties have been test-driving their competing visions as they head toward a showdown

It’s “build back better” versus “Canada first.”

The Liberals and the Conservatives have almost nailed down their respective recovery slogans and, after a few days of trying out various related phrases, the leaders of both parties seem to have settled on their rhetoric.

Erin O’Toole even adds Latin to his: Per ardua ad strata. “Through adversity, to the stars.”

The policy details, though, need some more work.

The parties have been test-driving their competing visions as they head toward a showdown later this month. On Sept. 23, the Liberals will roll out their plan in a throne speech, setting the tone for an eventual election. And the Conservatives will respond in kind.

They each have some deep thinking to do before then, especially because at least on the surface, both are flirting with major departures from the economic consensus of the past.

O’Toole is plastering social media with bumper stickers. “It’s time to put Canada first,” he says. “Are you with me?”

What does that mean exactly? O’Toole’s answer is a slow reveal, and it’s not entirely coherent — at least, not yet.

In interviews, he has explained that he’s talking about “self-sufficiency” — not just making sure Canada produces its own personal protective equipment, but also our own food and energy.

In particular, he says it means pulling back manufacturing from China because China can’t be trusted, and reconsidering major trade deals that haven’t worked in Canadians’ interests.

In a Labour Day message, he included a few more strands. He wants to see higher wages and to focus on the well-being of families as well as the GDP. He has no time for big businesses that cater to shareholders by chasing cheap labour.

There are a lot of blanks to be filled in here.

Critics would connect dots to say O’Toole is advocating for an economy where one income earner could support a traditional household by working in a heavily subsidized, re-shored factory.

That person’s family would also be eating potatoes all winter, because they would have no more food from other places, and would be living in a country where everything costs a lot more because we have cut off cheap imports.

All while building pipelines through an unwilling Quebec in the name of energy self-sufficiency.

But also: O’Toole says he’s against protectionism and he’s a free trader. And he frequently says that he and his policies are “serious.”

So it might be too early to conclude that he would adopt an economic policy so laden with contradictions and in conflict with our success as independent traders who don’t usually need subsidies to thrive.

Similarly, it’s easy to make a caricature of the Liberal sloganeering.

Justin Trudeau and his ministers speak frequently about “building back better,” but for now, that’s a blank slate that any progressive interest group could write a long and expensive wish list on.

“Our country and our world is facing an unprecedented challenge, but we’ve also been given an unparalleled opportunity,” Trudeau told supporters in a virtual fundraiser on Thursday evening.

“We have the chance to build a Canada that is safer and healthier, a Canada that is greener and more competitive, more welcoming and more fair. This is our moment to define the path ahead.”

The Liberals have begun to sketch in the details, and the throne speech, followed by economic update this fall, will deliver a much more colourful portrait of what they mean.

In the meantime, critics are quick to point to the glaring absence of any fiscal “anchor” or target that keeps spending in line and gives Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland scope to say no to bad ideas.

They imagine a world of free-spending, ever-expanding government that gives out so much money that it discourages work, dumps cash into boondoggles in the name of confronting climate change, and quickly loses the confidence of international investors.

But also: Freeland is deep in consultations about what a suitable fiscal target could be and how it could allow for discipline and generous government support at the same time.

And cabinet ministers are actively grappling with competing goals of getting workers back on the job while also heeding their commitment to cut emissions.

Trudeau himself has vowed, amidst sloganeering, that the plan will be “responsible.”

In the face of populist pressures, and in the face of the pandemic, Canadians have shown themselves to be quite moderate and cohesive in how they approach change.

If those attitudes persist, the more radical versions of the two leaders’ slogans will likely give way to commonly held values of free trade and thrift, coupled with generous support for those who are struggling.

There is already some overlap in the two parties’ approaches. They both anticipate spending lots of money on the recovery. No one is in no hurry to eradicate the deficit.

And they both envision a more muscular industrial policy to make sure Canadian companies thrive and Canada has the emergency goods and services it needs at a moment’s notice.

That kind of consensus would allow us all to be both serious and responsible, while building back better and also putting Canada first.

Heather Scoffield is a columnist with Torstar Syndication Services.


Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

FILE - A firefighter wears a mask as he drives his truck. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jonathan Hayward, File
Flames rip through Edmonton-area seniors complex, but no fatalities

ST. ALBERT, Alta. — Fire has destroyed part of a retirement complex… Continue reading

FILE - This file photo provided by Leonid Volkov and Russian opposition leader Alexei Navalny, right, are seen in Germany in a Sunday, Jan. 17, 2021, handout photo published to social media. The chief of staff to the imprisoned Russian president critic Alexei Navalny is calling on Ottawa to impose new sanctions on who he descripted as “Vladimir Putin’s oligarchs.” THE CANADIAN PRESS/AP-HO, Leonid Volkov
Canada must sanction Vladimir Putin’s oligarchs: Alexei Navalny’s chief of staff

Navalny was arrested on Jan. 17 upon returning from Germany

Alberta Health Services locked the Whistle Stop Cafe in Mirror on Wednesday morning after owner Christopher Scott refused to comply with health orders. (Photo by Paul Cowley/Advocate staff)
UPDATED: AHS shuts down Whistle Stop Cafe for defying health orders

Justice minister promises to get tough with those ignoring public health orders

Max Parrot of Canada competes in the men’s snowboard big air final at the 2018 Winter Olympic Games in Pyeongchang, South Korea, Saturday, Feb. 24, 2018. Parrot has won the Comeback of the Year honour at the Laureus World Sports Awards. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jonathan Hayward
Canadian snowboarder Max Parrot wins Laureus World Sports Award for comeback

Parrot beat out former Washington Football Team quarterback Alex Smith

This Nov. 22, 2015 file photo shows Justin Bieber at the American Music Awards in Los Angeles. Bieber’s world tour is facing another setback as the COVID-19 pandemic rages on. The Stratford, Ont.-raised pop singer is pushing dozens of tour dates including stops in three Canadian cities.	THE CANADIAN PRESS/AP-Photo by Jordan Strauss/Invision/AP, File
Justin Bieber postpones Canadian summer tour dates until 2022

52-date world tour will now kick off Feb. 18, 2022

LtE bug
Letter: Security company can help with shelter

Why don’t we leave Safe Harbour temporary shelter where it is and… Continue reading

LtE bug
Letter: Good job on K-6 curriculum

Many are questioning the quality of the draft K-6 curriculum. It amazes… Continue reading

Treena Mielke
COVID becomes all too real when someone you love is ‘positive’

The third wave of the pandemic is hitting us hard. It is… Continue reading

Wizards beat Raptors in OT, Toronto playoff bid nearly over

Wizards beat Raptors in OT, Toronto playoff bid nearly over

Most Read