NATO choking on its own success

The French city of Strasbourg and the German town of Kehl, which face each other across the river Rhine, will be in lock-down this weekend as the grandees of NATO (the North Atlantic Treaty Organization) gather to celebrate the alliance’s 60th anniversary and protesters home in on the site from all over Europe.

The French city of Strasbourg and the German town of Kehl, which face each other across the river Rhine, will be in lock-down this weekend as the grandees of NATO (the North Atlantic Treaty Organization) gather to celebrate the alliance’s 60th anniversary and protesters home in on the site from all over Europe.

It will be quite a party if you have the right security passes, for NATO is undeniably the most successful alliance in history.

It’s almost 20 years since the original reason for NATO’s creation, the Soviet Union, disappeared, but there is still a queue of countries clamouring to join. Croatia and Albania will become NATO’s 27th and 28th members at this summit, and there are half a dozen more countries waiting at the gates.

Yet behind the festivities, there are two major problems that the alliance needs to confront at this summit.

The one that gets all the public attention is the stalemated war in Afghanistan.

Afghanistan has been a problem for the alliance from the start, for some members were much keener on the adventure than others.

About half of the foreign troops in Afghanistan are Europeans and Canadians who operate under NATO command, and they have taken almost as many casualties there as the U.S. troops – but their losses have been very unequally shared.

Only three countries with a total population of under 100 million people – Britain, Canada and Denmark – have suffered almost two-thirds of all NATO’s fatal casualties in Afghanistan.

France, Germany, Italy, Spain and Poland (total population 280 million) have all together lost fewer soldiers killed than Canada alone.

As you would expect, this disparity generates some bitterness in the ranks of the alliance.

Sooner or later Western troops will leave Afghanistan, having failed to “fix” a country that is very resistant to foreign meddling.

Nothing especially bad will happen elsewhere because of this failure, and the whole episode will quickly be forgotten.

The real threat to NATO’s future lies elsewhere.

Since the Cold War ended 20 years ago, every former eastern European satellite of the old Soviet Union has joined NATO, together with the three westernmost republics of the Soviet Union itself (Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania).

This has caused much distress in Moscow, which thought NATO had promised not to expand into eastern Europe if it freed the satellites. But the promise was never put on paper, and the Russians have taken NATO’s expansion reasonably well in the circumstances.

Now, however, NATO has promised to admit Ukraine and Georgia, two former Soviet republics that lie not west of Russia, but south of it.

The old fear of “encirclement” has revived in Moscow, and the Russians warn that relations will get very frosty indeed if NATO expands into these countries.

There is little enthusiasm for this expansion among the older members of NATO in western Europe, and not much in Ukraine either.

NATO membership is wildly popular in Georgia, but for the wrong reason: President Mikheil Saakashvili’s government stupidly tried to seize the breakaway province of South Ossetia last summer, killing Russian peacekeeping troops in the process, and then rapidly lost the ensuing war with Russia.

There is strong support for Ukrainian and Georgian membership in Washington and among the new NATO members in eastern Europe, and so far the Western Europeans have reluctantly gone along with it. Next year’s NATO summit may well see both countries admitted to membership – but that would ultimately destroy NATO.

The alliance was founded on a guarantee that all members would come to the aid of any member that came under foreign attack. It was a believable guarantee, and therefore a strong deterrent to any attack.

Whereas nobody in their right minds believes that NATO would risk fighting a nuclear war with Russia to save Ukraine or Georgia if they should stumble into a military conflict with Moscow.

So if NATO lets those countries in, it will become a two-tier alliance, with real guarantees for most members and paper promises for the others. In due course, doubts will arise about whether all the existing eastern European members are really covered by the alliance guarantee either. And if that happens, NATO finally dies.

Gwynne Dyer is a London-based independent journalist.

Just Posted

One strong wind leaves years of replanting work for Red Deer parks staff

High visibility boulevards already replanted, neighbourhood work starts next year

Red Deer-area indigenous filmmakers invited to apply for $20,000 grant

Storyhive launches Indigenous Storyteller Edition

Restaurant closed after compliance team patrol

Public Safety Compliance Team checked eight bars and restaurants on Oct. 19

Red Deerians await local cannabis stores

So far 31 stores in Alberta awarded licence to operate

Rimbey RCMP seek missing man with health concerns

Has anyone seen Bill Harris of Ponka County?

WATCH: Make-A-Wish grants Star Wars loving teen’s wish

The Make-A-Wish Foundation granted Anakin Suerink’s wish in Red Deer Saturday afternoon

Local Sports: Rudy Soffo valuable to Kings on the court

When Rudy Soffo first saw the RDC basketball Kings roster he was… Continue reading

Except for 1 kick, Saints, Ravens are evenly matched

BALTIMORE — In a matchup between the league’s highest-scoring offence and top-ranked… Continue reading

Julia Louis-Dreyfus gets a top award for comedy

WASHINGTON — After a 35-year acting career and with two iconic television… Continue reading

Ricky Skaggs, Dottie West enter Country Music Hall of Fame

NASHVILLE — Bluegrass and country star Ricky Skaggs, singer Dottie West and… Continue reading

AP Exclusive: Stephen Hawking’s wheelchair, thesis for sale

LONDON — Stephen Hawking was a cosmic visionary, a figure of inspiration… Continue reading

Canada deemed U.S. a safe country for asylum seekers after internal review

OTTAWA — Canadian immigration officials have determined that the United States remains… Continue reading

Bombardier sues Mitsubishi over alleged theft of aircraft trade secrets

MONTREAL — Bombardier is suing Mitsubishi Aircraft in the United States over… Continue reading

Three strong earthquakes reported in Pacific Ocean off Vancouver Island

Three relatively strong earthquakes were recorded Sunday night in the Pacific Ocean… Continue reading

Most Read