NDP has cause to fear Green Party

For many centre-left Canadian voters, the New Democrats act as the conscience of Parliament.

These voters don’t necessarily want the NDP to win power nationally. But they want enough New Democrats elected to nudge the government of the day in a more humane direction.

Such voters drive NDP stalwarts nuts. They point out that their party has successfully formed government in five provinces.

Why, they ask, are Canadians so reluctant to see the New Democrats in power federally?

New Democrat MPs will tell you privately that they are sick of being the nation’s conscience and would like a real chance to put their ideas into practice. But they will also admit that being seen as the party that represents Canada’s better angels is preferable to the alternative.

Which is why they should be alarmed by the incremental, but steady growth of the Greens.

In 2010, there were no elected Green politicians in Canada. Now, there are Greens in four provincial legislatures and one in Ottawa.

In a world threatened by climate change, the Greens are by definition in a strong position to act as a moral force. The environment is their raison d’etre.

By comparison, Justin Trudeau’s Liberals — with their emphasis on balance — seem wishy-washy, while Andrew Scheer’s anti-carbon-tax Conservatives appear positively antediluvian.

Federal Green Party Leader Elizabeth May, meanwhile, projects an image of calm reason.

In large part, that’s because she doesn’t have to answer the hard questions levelled at those with a much better chance of becoming prime minister.

The Greens’ national platform, for instance, calls for lower personal income taxes, more social spending and balanced budgets — but without specifying how all three might be achieved at the same time.

A Green government would place tariffs on imports from countries that are not taxing carbon emissions. But the platform doesn’t explain how, in the real world of the WTO and trade agreements like NAFTA, it would manage this feat.

Politically, it doesn’t have to.

As a purely moral force, May and her Greens are exempt from the usual questions such as: Does all of this make sense?

She is exempt because, for now at least, not many expect her to become prime minister.

For a long time, this was the happy position the federal NDP occupied. It had plenty of good ideas.

But with the exception of medicare, which was first instituted in NDP-governed Saskatchewan, it was never in a position where it could implement these good ideas.

For a brief moment in 2015, it looked as if this pattern might finally change. New Democrats, by then the official Opposition, seemed poised to win that year’s federal election.

Alas, the voters had something else in mind.

Relegated once again to third-party status, the NDP returned to its traditional role as a moral voice in the Commons, decrying the Liberal government for its broken promises and offering up good ideas, such as universal pharmacare.

But is there room for two parties to act as the conscience of the Commons? More to the point, will disillusioned left-liberal voters do as they have done in the past and gravitate to the NDP in order to express their disapproval of the prime minister?

Or, in an era where climate concerns have become everyone’s concerns, will they cast their ballots for May’s Green Party in the hope that she can persuade whoever wins power in October to do something to halt the destruction of the planet?

Thomas Walkom is a columnist with Torstar Syndication Services.

Just Posted

Walk raises awareness of victims of domestic violence

Central Alberta men and boys will walk a mile in high heels… Continue reading

Speeding a ‘constant concern’ for residents, says Red Deer RCMP

Red Deer RCMP ramps up its efforts to curb speeding in the… Continue reading

Central Alberta firefighters helping tackle High Level wildfires

Three Red Deer County firefighters and one from Innisfail arrived on scene Thursday morning

Dogs and drugs don’t mix: Red Deer business wants to leave downtown after 18 years

One business owner is done with downtown Red Deer after 18 years.… Continue reading

Cast your votes for the Best of Red Deer

Nominations for the Best of Red Deer Readers’ Choice Awards are officially… Continue reading

Seniors: The unheard melodies

The sights and sounds around us enable us to experience our world.… Continue reading

Police find urn with ashes along bank of Red Deer River

RCMP find urn with ashes along bank of Red Deer River Red… Continue reading

North Vancouver RCMP seek skier whose pole caused brain injury to B.C. teen

VANCOUVER — A North Vancouver family is joining with RCMP to urge… Continue reading

Canadian ‘Aladdin’ star eyes diverse career championing homegrown talent

TORONTO — Canadian “Aladdin” star Mena Massoud says his wild carpet ride… Continue reading

Supreme Court will tuck into UberEats case about drivers’ benefit rights

OTTAWA — The Supreme Court of Canada will help decide whether a… Continue reading

Speech from the throne: Read the entire text outlining UCP priorities

The following is the speech from the throne, read Wednesday in the… Continue reading

Canada’s Rebecca Marino drops second-round French Open qualifying match

PARIS — Canada’s Rebecca Marino fell just short in a second-round qualifying… Continue reading

Most Read