No easy Senate fix on the horizon

Patience with the Senate has run out on Parliament Hill and beyond.

Patience with the Senate has run out on Parliament Hill and beyond.

With the exception of the Liberals, who have been arguing that the main problem with the upper house is that Justin Trudeau is not appointing its members, every party agrees that business as usual should no longer be an option.

But what can any of them realistically do about it?

On Thursday, a government MP said Prime Minister Stephen Harper would stop appointing senators until they can be elected. Harper’s office immediately denied Eve Adams’ assertion.

To freeze appointments on such an open-ended basis would be irresponsible.

There is no guarantee that any attempt at Senate reform will succeed or at least not in a timely manner.

Like it or not, the Senate is an essential part of Canada’s legislative framework.

Its function is spelled out in the Constitution. To render it dysfunctional through attrition would amount to crippling the operations of Parliament itself.

But there is little to prevent Harper from at least freezing Senate appointments until the 2015 election. Such a gesture would come at little cost to his control of the upper house.

At this juncture, the Conservatives outnumber the Liberals in the Senate by a margin of almost two to one.

There are three vacant seats and nine more retirements to come — including those of three Liberal senators — between now and the fall of 2015.

As an aside, Marjory LeBreton — the government Senate House leader who believes a Liberal is hiding behind every Parliament Hill bush — will reach retirement age (75) shortly before the next campaign. (Mike Duffy’s tenure is set to expire in 2021.)

Between now and the 2015 election, the Supreme Court will wade into the debate. The government has belatedly asked the top court to pronounce on the modalities involved in reforming or abolishing the Senate.

A Quebec reference on the same issue is working its way up the court system.

But any substantial reform of the Senate would require a constitutional amendment, and a high level of provincial support.

The route the Conservatives mapped out early in their first mandate is drafted with the intent of bypassing the constitutional path.

But even if a unilateral federal move to an elected Senate is vetted by the Supreme Court, it will only exacerbate a root cause of the disconnect between the upper house and the political reality of the federation.

Harper’s plan would not address the regional distribution of the seats of the Senate.

His proposal would enhance the legitimacy of an upper house within which Western Canada is chronically under-represented.

The NDP has long advocated the abolition of the Senate and that option has more traction in the public than at any other time in history. If it was put to a referendum against the background of the current spending scandal, a majority would likely support it.

But the Senate could not be abolished without a constitutional amendment.

Unless a clear majority in every province was on side with abolition, one or more premier would likely block the plan or at least try to wrestle some other constitutional concession in exchange for its support. If the constitutional file is re-opened, it will be very hard to limit the discussion to Senate reform.

A third option, also designed to avoid the constitutional route, would see the Senate became a merit-based chamber with its future members appointed by some august body of so-called wise men and women.

Under that scheme, the upper house would be non-partisan but also not terribly accountable. Is Canada really ready to give a hand-picked chattering class elite sway over its duly elected government?

Even with guidance from the Supreme Court, there is no easy Senate fix on the horizon.

But pushing the pause button on replenishing its ranks long enough to have a national discussion as to what to do with it would be a sensible first step.

Chantal Hébert is a syndicated Toronto Star national affairs writer.

Just Posted

Shanna Lydiard is upset to have had mail delivery cut off last month to her West Park street because of water main reconstruction. Delivery is to resume by May 19 at the latest, according to the City of Red Deer. (Photo by LANA MICHELIN/Advocate staff).
Red Deer woman frustrated by mail delivery suspension due to construction

Shanna Lydiard said residents shouldn’t have to drive across the city for their mail

Innisfail-Sylvan Lake MLA Devin Dreeshen received his COVID-19 vaccine Tuesday at Jackson’s Pharmacy in Innisfail. (Devin Creeshen Twitter photo)
COVID-19: Most local MLAs have received their first vaccine shot

Alberta’s NDP is encouraging all MLAs to get vaccinated and publicly promote… Continue reading

Alberta continues to wrestle with high COVID-19 case numbers. (NIAID-RML via AP)
Red Deer up to 858 active cases of COVID-19

Province reports additional 1,799 cases of the virus

Bo's Bar and Grill owner Brennen Wowk said the hospitality industry is looking for more clarity from the province around what conditions must be met to allow for restaurants reopening.
(Advocate file photo)
Frustated restaurant owners want to know government’s reopening plan

Restaurant owners feel they are in lockdown limbo

The Bowden Institution medium security facility near Bowden has 15 active COVID-19 cases. (THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jeff McIntosh)
15 active COVID-19 cases at Bowden prison

Bowden Institution has had 36 positive cases this year with 21 recovered and no deaths

Red Deer Mayor Tara Veer and several members of city council helped kick off the spring Green Deer cleanup campaign on Wednesday. Veer said city workers do their best to keep the city looking good, but need volunteer help to get rid of litter that has blown into bushes onto road sides over the winter. (Photo by LANA MICHELIN/Advocate staff)
Red Deer city councillors launch spring Green Deer campaign

Volunteers are needed to keep the city looking good

Ottawa Senators centre Josh Norris, right, celebrates his game-winning overtime goal against the Toronto Maple Leafs with left wing Brady Tkachuk Wednesday May 12, 2021 in Ottawa. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Adrian Wyld
Norris scored winner, Senators beat Maple Leafs 4-3 in Andersen’s return from injury

Norris scored winner, Senators beat Maple Leafs 4-3 in Andersen’s return from injury

Rafael Nadal, of Spain, holds up the trophy after beating Daniil Medvedev, of Russia, in the final at the Rogers Cup tennis tournament, in Montreal on Sunday, Aug. 11, 2019. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Paul Chiasson
Tennis Canada could move top tournaments to US if Toronto, Montreal plan not approved

Tennis Canada could move top tournaments to US if Toronto, Montreal plan not approved

Philadelphia Flyers' Travis Sanheim (6) and Brian Elliott (37) celebrate with teammates after the Flyers won an NHL hockey game against the New Jersey Devils, Monday, May 10, 2021, in Philadelphia. (AP Photo/Matt Slocum)
Puck luck? Hockey’s secrecy makes betting on NHL a gamble

Puck luck? Hockey’s secrecy makes betting on NHL a gamble

FILE - John Davidson, left, president of the New York Rangers, and Rangers general manager Jeff Gorton pose at a news conference in New York, in this Wednesday, May 22, 2019, file photo. The New York Rangers abruptly fired president John Davidson and general manager Jeff Gorton on Wednesday, May 5, 2021 with three games left in the season. Chris Drury was named president and GM. He previously served as associate GM under Davidson and Gorton. (AP Photo/Seth Wenig, File)
New York Rangers fire coach Dave Quinn, 3 assistants

New York Rangers fire coach Dave Quinn, 3 assistants

Denis Shapovalov, of Canada, returns a shot from Ilya Ivashka, of Belarus, during the Miami Open tennis tournament, Saturday, March 27, 2021, in Miami Gardens, Fla. THE CANADIAN PRESS/AP-Wilfredo Lee
Canadian Denis Shapovalov books meeting with Nadal in third round of Italian Open

Canadian Denis Shapovalov books meeting with Nadal in third round of Italian Open

United States goalie Alex Cavallini (33) deflects Canada's Marie Philip Poulin (29) shot during the first period in the women's 3-on-3 game, part of the NHL hockey All-Star weekend, Friday, Jan. 24, 2020, in St. Louis. Hockey Canada's roster of players invited to try out for the 2022 Olympic women's hockey team indicates the squad will be experienced up front and less so on the back end. THE CANADIAN PRESS/AP-Jeff Roberson
Hockey Canada announces players invited to try out for women’s Olympic team

Hockey Canada announces players invited to try out for women’s Olympic team

Atlanta Braves pitcher Max Fried works against the Toronto Blue Jays during the first inning of a baseball game Wednesday, May 12, 2021, in Atlanta. (AP Photo/Ben Margot)
Hernández 2 HRs as Ryu, Blue Jays improve to 5-0 vs Braves

Hernández 2 HRs as Ryu, Blue Jays improve to 5-0 vs Braves

Toronto Maple Leafs goaltender Jack Campbell (36) makes a save as Maple Leafs defenceman TJ Brodie (78) and Montreal Canadiens forward Tyler Toffoli (73) look for the rebound during first period NHL hockey action in Toronto on Saturday, May 8, 2021. The Leafs and the Canadiens will meet in the playoffs for the first time in 42 years when the 2020-21 NHL post-season gets underway.THE CANADIAN PRESS/Nathan Denette
Leafs, Habs will face off in long-awaited playoff rematch, Oilers will face Jets

Leafs, Habs will face off in long-awaited playoff rematch, Oilers will face Jets

Most Read