Opinion: Accomplishments aside, it was time for minister to go

We can certainly thank Bill Morneau for a lot of things he did as finance minister.

He made inclusive growth the centrepiece of his fiscal policy, focusing not just on how the Canadian economy could grow but also pushing, slowly but surely, for a more equal distribution of our collective riches.

Under Morneau’s watch, gender analysis was entrenched into budget-making, forcing all policy-makers to calculate the pros and cons for women in every decision they took.

And more recently, the federal government’s willingness to spend hundreds of millions of dollars in cushioning the blow of the pandemic shutdown has meant the difference between poverty and getting by for many millions of people.

Those policies were hard work, and Morneau was central to all of them.

But he did the right thing in the handing of his resignation on Monday.

As the minister told a news conference after meeting with Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, “like any job, there’s a time when you’re the appropriate person in the role and a time when you have to decide you’re not the appropriate person in the role.”

His official explanation of why he was suddenly, at 7:30 on Monday night, no longer the appropriate person – he never had any intention of sticking around for the long run, and the prime minister needs someone stable by his side – beggars belief. But his time had definitely come.

The ethical conundrum caused by his granting of government funding to the very charity that employs his daughter, flew his family to Africa and Central America, and received $100,000 in recent donations from his wife was only the last straw. Forgetting to repay WE Charity $41,000 for personal travel was too much to ask an already-leery caucus to explain on his behalf when the next campaign rolls around.

Morneau had already weakened his own standing by his mishandling of the small-business tax reforms of 2017, and by running afoul of the ethics commissioner before. A harsh ruling expected this year about the WE Charity affair would only have made a bad situation worse.

But there’s more to the resignation than that. The past few weeks of WE Charity controversy have drawn Morneau detractors out of the woodwork, to the point where public confidence in the finance minister was deteriorating at a very crucial time. Tales of conflict and policy-making dysfunction flew thick.

Under Trudeau, the finance minister needs to be intimately involved in federal-provincial relations in order to deliver many of the Liberals’ election promises. The finance minister needs to be able to deal with the business community and have solid dealings with Bay Street. The minister needs to have a range of allies and friends in the caucus and the cabinet to make fiscal responsibility a central tenet in policy-making.

All of these relationships require that the public, the caucus, the opposition and the business community have the utmost respect of the finance minister, with the knowledge that the prime minister has his back at all times.

Trudeau’s silence and then his awkward statement of support for Morneau spoke so loudly as to suggest that that confidence was too thin to last – especially with so many momentous decisions around fiscal policy on the horizon.

The Liberals need to decide in the next couple of months how they will guide the economy towards recovery from the deepest recession in memory, how they will control their spending at the same time, and how they will make good on their commitment to inclusive growth even as the pandemic hits the most vulnerable populations the hardest.

It’s a puzzle that will require not only the full confidence of the prime minister, but also someone who understands deeply what the pandemic has done to women caring for children and trying to work from home, who can balance fiscal responsibility over the long term with compassion for those hurting today.

Perhaps it’s time for a woman.

Heather Scoffield is a columnist for Torstar Syndication Services.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Flight training academy critical of Red Deer Airport agreement

Sky Wings Aviation Academy said its fuel business hampered by exclusive agreement

Water main installation to close portion of 55 Street in Red Deer

A portion of 55 Street will close starting Thursday to December 24… Continue reading

COVID-19 cases in Alberta up by 153 Wednesday

Central zone sits at 19 active cases

In photos: Gord Bamford raises more than $21K at Lacombe concert

Central Alberta’s Gord Bamford performed at the Lacombe Regional Airport on Saturday.… Continue reading

New benefits for workers hurt by pandemic hits speed bump in Senate

New benefits for workers hurt by pandemic hits speed bump in Senate

Missing ballots, donations, last-minute rule changes undermine Green race: candidates

Missing ballots, donations, last-minute rule changes undermine Green race: candidates

Alberta top court rejects appeal of man who killed Calgary Stampeders football player

Alberta top court rejects appeal of man who killed Calgary Stampeders football player

Rihanna wants to cheer up a troubled world with fashion show

Rihanna wants to cheer up a troubled world with fashion show

Mild to severe: Immune system holds clues to virus reaction

Mild to severe: Immune system holds clues to virus reaction

Lack of funding hampering aid to domestic violence survivors, report says

Lack of funding hampering aid to domestic violence survivors, report says

Racism common in health system says head of Native Women’s Shelter of Montreal

Racism common in health system says head of Native Women’s Shelter of Montreal

Judge reserves decision on evidence in Huawei executive Meng Wanzhou’s hearing

Judge reserves decision on evidence in Huawei executive Meng Wanzhou’s hearing

Most Read