Opinion: Climbing cost of drinking water a drain on low-income earners

Environmentalists and water economists have long argued Canadian households have not conserved water in part because it is priced at excessively low levels.

Somewhat lost in the discussion are the challenges higher water rates present for low-income households.

Over the past few decades, the prices charged by municipalities for residential water and wastewater services in many Canadian cities have increased much faster than increases in the rate of inflation.

The cost of municipal water and wastewater services in 93 Canadian cities shows utility charges in 22 of those cities are exceeding international affordability benchmarks for low-income households.

More than 130,000 low-income households in these 22 cities are already paying more for water than they can afford.

Over the next decade, water is likely to become increasingly unaffordable for low-income households.

The study shows cities in Alberta and Saskatchewan tend to have the most expensive water in the country. Calgary and Regina, for example, have the second- and third-highest prices among the 93 cities surveyed.

A two-person household using 12.2 cubic metres of water per month (a conservative indoor-only volume) would pay $1,265 in Calgary or $1,229 in Regina per year. The community with the highest charges was Saint John, N.B., at $1,368 per year.

At the other end of the continuum, water charges in Torbay, N.L., are $300 per year, regardless of how much water a household consumes.

The Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development affordability benchmark recommends water and wastewater services for low-income households should not exceed five per cent of their after tax income.

Seven of the 22 cities where rates exceed the OECD affordability benchmark are in Alberta and five are in Saskatchewan.

One of the principal drivers of high rates in Alberta and Saskatchewan compared with the other provinces is the quality of the available source water.

In the drier parts of the Prairies, for example, the distance from the source to the municipality may be longer than for other water-rich regions.

Wastewater treatment may also cost more as a number of cities in the Prairies discharge their sewage into streams other communities then use as source water.

Regina, for example, is required by the government of Saskatchewan to take greater care about the quality of wastewater discharge it produces than is the case for some cities in other provinces.

Similarly, the high water utility charges in Saint John reflect the significant wastewater infrastructure investments undertaken to protect the waters of the Bay of Fundy. A city like Victoria, B.C., on the other hand, has lower costs because it is allowed to simply discharge untreated wastewater directly into the ocean.

Federal regulations made under the Fisheries Act in 2014 require that cities cease releasing untreated or inadequately treated effluent into natural water bodies by 2020.

This means a number of cities such as Victoria and Montreal will be required to make significant wastewater infrastructure investments that could have an effect on their water rates. A new plant being built for Victoria is scheduled to be completed this year.

Some municipalities are taking measures to reduce the impact of escalating rates on low-income households. Several cities, such as Saskatoon, Edmonton and Hamilton, Ont., have adopted systems that offer lower rates for basic household water needs and higher rates for consumption levels that reflect discretionary uses such as watering lawns and filling swimming pools.

What has been most effective are measures that lower the cost of utility infrastructure improvements for municipalities. The federal and provincial governments have provided hundreds of municipalities with water and wastewater infrastructure grants over the past two decades.

However, these funding programs are offered irregularly and often change or disappear with election cycles.

Jim Warren is an assistant sociology and social studies professor at the University of Regina. This piece is reprinted from The Conversation under a creative commons license.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Federal minister pledges to meet chiefs in B.C. over natural gas pipeline

OTTAWA — The federal Crown-Indigenous relations minister is offering to meet today… Continue reading

Loblaw reports Q4 profit up from year earlier, but falls short of expectations

BRAMPTON, Ont. — Loblaw Companies Ltd. reported its fourth-quarter profit rose compared… Continue reading

2 former cruise ship passengers with virus die in Japan

TOKYO — Two elderly passengers taken off the Diamond Princess cruise ship… Continue reading

Canada hosts Lima Group meeting to find solutions to Venezuela crisis

GATINEAU, Que. — Canada is hosting the gathering of foreign ministers today… Continue reading

Your community calendar

Feb. 19 A Liberation of Holland event is being held at the… Continue reading

David Marsden: Hospital unfairness makes me ill

The provincial government clearly isn’t without money. If it was, it wouldn’t… Continue reading

Hoarse Hearts; Canadian women’s curling championship hard on skips’ voices

MOOSE JAW, Sask. — Kerri Einarson calls it her “winter voice.” Midway… Continue reading

Saprissa, Impact draw 2-2 in first leg in CONCACAF Champions League

SAN JOSE, Costa Rica — Jonathan Martinez scored in the 90th minute… Continue reading

Former Quebec media star Eric Salvail takes stand in his sex assault case

MONTREAL — Former Quebec media star Eric Salvail was no longer employed… Continue reading

Rising classical star Alexandra Streliski to perform with Dallas Green at Junos

TORONTO — Breakout neo-classical pianist Alexandra Streliski will join City and Colour’s… Continue reading

Pastrnak scores overtime winner, Bruins edge Oilers 2-1

Bruins 2 Oilers 1 (OT) EDMONTON — The Boston Bruins have proven… Continue reading

P.E.I.’s Birt through to championship round at Tournament of Hearts

MOOSE JAW, Sask. — Suzanne Birt reached the championship round at the… Continue reading

Most Read