Opinion: Don’t set deadlines you can’t keep, a lesson for Trudeau

Justin Trudeau has broken big promises before. Canada’s budget was not balanced by 2019 and the country still has the same electoral system he once vowed to abolish.

But backing away from a pledge to end boil-water advisories by March 2021 is a significant retreat for a prime minister who has said the relationship with Indigenous people is the most important one for him and his government.

Is this, then, the most important broken promise in Trudeau’s five years in power?

For all the people who will still be boiling their drinking water for the foreseeable future, the answer to that question is clear – as clear as their water is not.

But this candid admission by Indigenous Services Minister Marc Miller also has to be seen in the wider pandemic picture of Trudeau’s government at this moment. Deadlines are being demanded. When will the vaccines arrive? When will this COVID-19 crisis be over?

In that light, the announcement on Wednesday was a backtrack and a future warning all in one: this Liberal government has learned the peril of setting firm deadlines.

Broken promises happen all the time in politics – though not as often as a cynical public might believe. Last year, just before the fall election, an independent group of academics published a book detailing how Trudeau’s government had entirely or partly fulfilled about 90 per cent of its 2015 promises.

What’s rare in politics is the full-fledged admission of a broken promise – the kind of apology and retreat on display at Miller’s news conference on Wednesday.

Normally, governments prefer to let broken promises slide away into the mists of distant history, hoping that they will be forgotten before anyone notices their failure to materialize. Trudeau airbrushed his democratic-reform pledge out of existence, we’ll remember, by leaving the words out of the mandate letter of the new minister after a cabinet shuffle. Former finance minister Bill Morneau jettisoned the balanced-budget pledge with talk of being “flexible” to “circumstances.”

Stephen Harper was of the never-admit-a-mistake school of politics during his time as prime minister. So his Conservative government never really did come out and say that it had failed to deliver on its promise to reduce medical wait times – one of Harper’s five famous priorities on assuming power in 2006. Instead, it quietly faded away from memory.

One of the more explosive retreats from a political promise in Canada took place in the mid-1990s, when Jean Chrétien was prime minister and people were starting to notice that he hadn’t scrapped the goods and services tax.

Chrétien, also not a fan of admitting errors, kept saying that he never really promised to do away with the tax. But his finance minister, Paul Martin, believed that a news conference had to be held to tell Canadians that they were stuck with the GST and all the revenue it brought in to government.

This whipped up a storm inside Liberal caucus, especially because senior cabinet minister Sheila Copps had vowed to resign if her government didn’t kill the GST. One broken promise, thus, was forced to become a promise fulfilled – Copps had to stand down and run again for her seat in Hamilton (which she won easily, this time with no career-threatening pledges).

Politicians break promises for a simple reason. They’re easy to make and harder to keep. Things get complicated. “Circumstances” force governments to be “flexible,” as Morneau put it.

In the 1990s, political parties all over the world became hypersensitive about their reputation for breaking promises and started introducing guarantees – the Liberals’ “red book” in Canada, the U.S. Republicans’ “contract with America,” to name a couple. At the same time, grassroots bids emerged to “recall” politicians if they failed to be the representative as advertised in the election campaign.

There’s less talk of that now, though accountability in general remains a big promise. Politicians have just learned to keep it all vague.

Regrettably, this will be the lesson of the boil-water-advisory pledge for Trudeau’s government. It is a relic of a time when this prime minister believed that sunny ways and “deliverology” were the key to success; when Trudeau wanted to be judged by results, not just money spent.

The pandemic strategy is very much the opposite: talk of a “dark winter” in this week’s economic statement and promises to spend money, a lot of it, at some yet-to-be-determined point in the future.

The demands for deadlines and delivery dates on vaccines are bound to increase in the coming weeks.

But anyone who was watching Wednesday’s news conference will understand why no answer is forthcoming: Trudeau is getting out of the business of making promises with times and dates attached.

Susan Delacourt is a National Affairs writer.

Just Posted

road consturction
Road closures at Red Deer hospital next week

Red Deer drivers are advised of road closures in the vicinity of… Continue reading

A gofundme account has been set up for Lilac the husky, of Blackfalds. (Photo from gofundme)
Dog ends up in coma after a walk in Blackfalds

Dog finds a baggie that likely contained drugs

Red Deer man reported missing

Red Deer RCMP seek public’s assistance

An attendee of the Maskwacis memorial held on May 31, 2021, for the 215 school children found in Kamloops, B.C. the week before, holds a teddy bear. <ins>The grandstand was filled with 215 bears to represent the lost children. They were offered to residential school survivors at the end of the memorial. </ins>(Photo illustration by Emily Jaycox/Ponoka News)
Ermineskin residential school survivor: ‘It just brings me back to the cries at night’

Discovery in Kamloops of remains of 215 children a painful time for survivors

A large number of supporters were out Saturday at a rally intended to bring awareness about including Hinduism in the grade 2 portion of the K-6 draft curriculum. As it stands now, Hinduism won’t be taught until grade 6 in the proposed draft curriculum. (Photo by BYRON HACKETT/Advocate Staff)
Video: Rally to support adding Hinduism to draft curriculum draws crowd in Red Deer

The Hindu community in Red Deer came out in droves on Saturday… Continue reading

Inuk elder Reepa Evic-Carleton light a qulliq, a traditional oil lamp, at a public ceremony to celebrate National Indigenous Peoples Day on the bank of the Ottawa River behind the Canadian Museum of History in Gatineau, Que. on Thursday, June 21, 2018. THE CANADIAN PRESS/David Kawai
Singh blasts Liberal ‘hypocrisy’ on National Indigenous Peoples Day

OTTAWA — NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh says he believes the Liberal government… Continue reading

The border crossing into the United States is seen during the COVID-19 pandemic in Lacolle, Que. on February 12, 2021. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Paul Chiasson
Border measures start easing in July for fully vaccinated Canadians

OTTAWA — Fully vaccinated Canadians and permanent residents returning to Canada will… Continue reading

The border crossing into the United States is seen during the COVID-19 pandemic in Lacolle, Que. on February 12, 2021. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Paul Chiasson
Canada to unveil travel rules for fully vaccinated citizens, permanent residents

OTTAWA — Canada is set to detail what quarantine rules citizens and… Continue reading

Hockey legend Wayne Gretzky poses for a photo in Toronto on Monday, October 17, 2016. Two of Canada’s most prominent athletes are part of the ownership group of a new Las Vegas National Lacrosse League franchise. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Michelle Siu
Wayne Gretzky, Steve Nash join forces with Las Vegas lacrosse team

League’s 15th team will start play in the fall of 2022

Orlando City and Montreal Impact players take a knee before their MLS match, Sunday, Nov. 1, 2020, at Red Bull Arena in Harrison, NJ.  THE CANADIAN PRESS/AP-Eduardo Munoz Alvarez
CF Montreal finds two new home venues as Gold Cup comes to Fort Lauderdale

Exploria Stadium has been Toronto FC’s home field this year

Police and firefighters respond after a truck drove into a crowd of people injuring them during The Stonewall Pride Parade and Street Festival in Wilton Manors, Fla., on Saturday, June 19, 2021. WPLG-TV reports that the driver of the truck was taken into custody. (Chris Day/South Florida Sun-Sentinel via AP)
Officials say deadly Pride parade crash was not intentional

Driver and the victims were a part of the Fort Lauderdale Gay Men’s Chorus family

FILE - In this April 18, 2017, file photo, a conference worker passes a demo booth at Facebook’s annual F8 developer conference, in San Jose, Calif. Facebook is launching podcasts and live audio streams in the U.S. Monday, June 21, 2021, to keep users engaged on its platform and to compete with emerging rivals.(AP Photo/Noah Berger, File)
Facebook launches podcasts, live audio service

Handful of podcasts will first be available to people in the U.S.

Intricate cloth masks with Indigenous design made by Teresa Snow. Facebook/ Masks4Maskwacis
‘Masks 4 Maskwacis’ wins Northern Lights Volunteer Award

The group received recognition for their efforts to support their community during COVID-19.

Most Read