Opinion: Fireplace ban endangers lives during an emergency

The power has suddenly gone out. Are you ready for such an emergency?

According to the federal government’s Get Prepared website, “you need to be able to take care of your family for at least 72 hours” if the grid goes down and official help is unavailable. Could you survive at home alone without electricity, gas, cell service and water for three days?

Stockpiling water, non-perishable food, batteries, medications and a first-aid kit are all necessities, of course. But what if there’s a blizzard − how will you stay warm? Then your only option, says Ottawa, is to use a “non-electric stove or heater, or a wood-burning fireplace.”

How strange, then, that some of Canada’s biggest cities are doing everything in their power to remove this option. By planning to ban fireplaces and wood stoves, Montreal and Vancouver are denying citizens the means to keep warm during a catastrophic ice storm or similar emergency. It’s apparently more important to protect the environment than it is to allow humans the tools to save themselves in a crisis.

In Montreal, beginning in October 2018, no traditional fireplace or wood stove “may be used or left to be used” by any resident, according to a new city bylaw. Only rigorously certified devices will be permitted.

Similarly, Vancouver is in the midst of a public consultation regarding its proposed ban on fireplaces and wood stoves. If approved, Vancouver residents would be required to register all wood-burning devices by 2022 and, as in Montreal, traditional-style fireplaces and stoves would be ineligible for registration. In 2025, it would become illegal to use any unregistered wood-burning system for warmth, cooking or aesthetics.

Both pending bylaws claim to make exceptions for lengthy power outages, but the broader implication of these policies is clear. They will remove from existence the vast majority of legacy fireplaces and wood stoves and, given a hefty application of red tape, strongly discourage all new installations. The Vancouver proposal actually contemplates an annual fireplace registration renewal process, like a driver’s licence.

And it’s a trend that may be spreading. The Canadian Council of Ministers of the Environment has distributed a draft bylaw that can be used by municipalities looking to ban fireplaces or wood stoves.

The next time a devastating winter storm hits Montreal or something similar is visited upon Vancouver, many homeowners won’t be able to heat their houses off-grid. In cases where official help is unavailable or misdirected, families will thus be deprived of this means of fending for themselves – this despite the explicit recommendation of Ottawa’s emergency preparedness program.

And an exemption during a power outage is of no value if your fireplace or wood stove has already been removed or rendered inoperable, as required by law.

Bans on fireplaces and wood stoves are driven by concerns over global warming, and the notion that heat from wood is inefficient and dirty. While it’s true that burning wood or other biomass such as plant matter can release a range of pollutants, “biomass is generally considered carbon neutral because the carbon dioxide (CO2) released from either burning or decomposing biomass approximately equals the CO2 that trees and plants take in from the atmosphere during their lives,” says the National Energy Board’s review of various energy sources. In other words, there’s no difference between burning a tree and letting it rot on the forest floor. This is why biomass can be considered an environmentally-friendly, cost-effective and renewable energy source.

Emissions released by wood stoves and fireplaces stay in the atmosphere for a very short time. Whereas CO2 can linger for decades or longer, the particulates released by a burning log disappear in days or weeks. And while this is still an issue, a balanced assessment of all available facts suggests an outright ban is the wrong policy solution.

Given the proven usefulness of wood heat in emergencies, it would be better to declare no-burn days when air pollution is a factor, as is already the case in some North American jurisdictions, and let fireplaces and wood stoves remain as a necessary backup in big cities.

For most of Canada’s history, wood has been an important, affordable and practical source of heat and fuel. This remains true in many rural parts of the country. And in urban Canada, wood heat can still be very useful in a crisis.

Canadians shouldn’t be denied the right to help themselves in an emergency. Or, for that matter, the right to a pleasant source of warmth and ambiance any time the mood might strike them.

Troy Media columnist Peter Shawn Taylor is a contributing writer to Canadians for Affordable Energy.

Just Posted

Liberals win most seats in Election 2019

OTTAWA — Justin Trudeau is expected to remain prime minister but the… Continue reading

Union official: Fired Wisconsin school guard gets job back

MADISON, Wis. — A Wisconsin school district is rehiring a black security… Continue reading

Trump bemoans GOP for not sticking together on impeachment

WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump called on fellow Republicans to “get tougher… Continue reading

Quebec man found guilty of first-degree murder in slaying of ex-wife, stranger

ST-JEROME, Que. — A Quebec man was found guilty of first-degree murder… Continue reading

Thunberg interviews leaders for documentary, Alberta Indigenous group says

FORT MCMURRAY, Alta. — Swedish climate activist Greta Thunberg continued her tour… Continue reading

Your community calendar

Tuesday The Small Business Centre at Burman University’s School of Business invites… Continue reading

Liberals win most seats in Election 2019

OTTAWA — Justin Trudeau is expected to remain prime minister but the… Continue reading

Catalan independence remains an obstacle for Spanish leaders

The demonstrations, some of them violent, are still going on in Catalonia… Continue reading

West Division playoff race still has no shortage of twists and turns

Finally, some clarity in the muddled West Division playoff picture. The Edmonton… Continue reading

Union official: Fired Wisconsin school guard gets job back

MADISON, Wis. — A Wisconsin school district is rehiring a black security… Continue reading

Trump bemoans GOP for not sticking together on impeachment

WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump called on fellow Republicans to “get tougher… Continue reading

Quebec man found guilty of first-degree murder in slaying of ex-wife, stranger

ST-JEROME, Que. — A Quebec man was found guilty of first-degree murder… Continue reading

Thunberg interviews leaders for documentary, Alberta Indigenous group says

FORT MCMURRAY, Alta. — Swedish climate activist Greta Thunberg continued her tour… Continue reading

Most Read