Opinion: It’s too soon to talk of separation

By David Marsden

Albertans have good reason to be dissatisfied with their treatment by the federal government, but it can’t be assumed that separation is the answer.

Since the Oct. 21 election, which resulted in the province electing all but one Conservative MP, interest in fringe groups has exploded.

It’s clear that Albertans have cause for discontent. All the political parties, with the exception of the Conservatives, have made no secret of their desire to shutdown the oilsands.

All but Tory Leader Andrew Scheer are transparent in their determination to abandon fossil fuels, despite the important role they play as a generator of national wealth and employment.

The politicians pay no attention to the fact that renewable energy, while contributing to our needs today, is still very much a work in progress when it comes to fuelling a modern, industrialized economy.

The Liberals bought the Trans Mountain pipeline after they scared private investors away, but they show little interest in the project. When the pipeline’s expansion was challenged in court, they didn’t bother to hire lawyers to represent Canadian taxpayers’ interest.

The Liberals have banned tankers carrying Canadian bitumen from the B.C. north coast, while allowing other fuels to be transported without restriction in the same region. They have shown no desire to stop oil tankers from plying the waters off the East Coast, where a number of aquatic species are at risk.

Liberal Leader Justin Trudeau undermined the justice system in an effort to help the Quebec engineering company SNC-Lavalin, but throws western Canadian energy corporations under the bus. The movement of Encana’s headquarters to the United States is a national shame.

Encana was once the pride of the nation, with roots extending back to the oilpatch’s earliest days, but Trudeau’s attack on the industry proved too much. The company’s executives have decided to move its head office south of the border, where investment is welcomed.

Still, despite all of this, the argument for separation hasn’t been made. Alberta has representation in Parliament today, just as it has always had. And more Canadians voted Conservative last month than cast ballots for the Liberals.

Those who argue in favour of separation may have emotion on their side, but they can’t rely upon the facts.

Every Canadian pays the same amount in federal tax. So when people talk about Albertans contributing more to Confederation than other Canadians, such as Quebecers, they are referencing the reality that our incomes and the number of hours we work exceed the national average.

As a result, Albertans deposit more in the federal treasury than workers in other provinces do. Equalization payments, which have been wildly twisted for political purposes, are an attempt to ensure public services are equally funded across the country.

There is clear reason to be chagrined at our treatment in Confederation, but creating an independent state wouldn’t provide access to tidewater for our energy exports, which is usually cited as the biggest grievance.

If Alberta wants to do more than complain, it should exert its authority in areas it already has control over. It could collect its own income taxes, form a provincial police force and establish its own pension fund.

As other commentators have pointed out, these measure are attainable and would demonstrate a determination to better control our destiny.

That’s a good place to start to test the political will of Albertans.

David Marsden is managing editor of the Red Deer Advocate.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau takes part in a press conference during the COVID pandemic in Ottawa, Tuesday, Oct. 13, 2020. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick
Trudeau Liberals face confidence vote over proposed anticorruption committee

Bloc Quebecois plans to support the Conservative motion

A bottle of hand sanitizer is seen in Vancouver on October 7, 2020. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jonathan Hayward
Experts say counterfeit hand sanitizer recall at Dollarama is a lesson for retailers

Fraudulent version may not be effective at killing bacteria and viruses

George Orme, owner of Jacques-Orme Funeral Home, and Dr. Henry George are seen with the city’s first ambulance at the Red Deer Exhibition around 1925. (Photo courtesy of Red Deer Archives)
Michael Dawe: Red Deer’s first ambulances were also used as hearses

There has been a great deal of media attention in recent weeks… Continue reading

Manitoba skip Tracy Fleury releases a rock as they play Ontario at the Scotties Tournament of Hearts at Centre 200 in Sydney, N.S. on Tuesday, Feb. 19, 2019. Fleury has brought on veteran skip Sherry Middaugh to serve as coach of the Winnipeg-based team. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Andrew Vaughan
Team Tracy Fleury adds longtime skip Sherry Middaugh as coach

Previously coached at the U18 and U21 levels

The main entrance to the Museums Island and the Neue Museum, left, in Berlin, Wednesday, Oct. 21, 2020. A large number of art works and artifacts at some of Berlin’s best-known museums were smeared with a liquid by an unknown perpetrator or perpetrators earlier this month, police said Wednesday. The ‘numerous’ works in several museums at the Museum Island complex, a UNESCO world heritage site in the heart of the German capital that is one of the city’s main tourist attractions, were targeted between 10 a.m. and 6 p.m. on Oct. 3, police said. (AP Photo/Markus Schreiber)
Over 60 exhibits damaged at Berlin museums, motive a mystery

Surveillance camera footage doesn’t show obvious signs of anyone applying the liquid

FILE - This Aug. 13, 2020 photo shows a logo for Netflix on a remote control in Portland, Ore. Netflix Inc. (NFLX) on Tuesday, Oct. 20, 2020 reported third-quarter net income of $790 million. The Los Gatos, California-based company said it had profit of $1.74 per share. (AP Photo/Jenny Kane, File)
Netflix reports a summer slump in subscriber growth

Added 28 million subscribers in the first nine months of the year

Los Angeles Dodgers starting pitcher Clayton Kershaw warms up before Game 1 of the baseball World Series against the Tampa Bay Rays Tuesday, Oct. 20, 2020, in Arlington, Texas. (AP Photo/Eric Gay)
Kershaw, LA stars shine, Dodgers top Rays 8-3 in WS opener

Kershaw, LA stars shine, Dodgers top Rays 8-3 in WS opener

Manchester United's Marcus Rashford leaps over a challenge by PSG's Presnel Kimpembe during the Champions League group H soccer match between Paris Saint-Germain and Manchester United at the Parc des Princes in Paris, France, Tuesday, Oct. 20, 2020. (AP Photo/Michel Euler)
Man United wins again at PSG; Messi scores in Barca rout

Man United wins again at PSG; Messi scores in Barca rout

Most Read