Thomas Walkom

Opinion: Peace doesn’t need Trump

U.S. President Donald Trump may have cancelled his planned summit with North Korean dictator Kim Jong Un (although even that is unclear). But it seems that plans for bringing peace to the Korean Peninsula will carry on anyway – with or without America.

Both North and South Korea have gone too far along this path to turn back now. As South Korean President Moon Jae-in put it Friday: “Denuclearization and lasting peace on Korean Peninsula cannot be abandoned or delayed.”

Rather, he said, they are historical imperatives. In the U.S. and Canada, the Korean dilemma tends to be viewed through an American lens: Was Trump wise or stupid to agree to a summit in the first place? Are talks the best way to persuade Kim to abandon a nuclear arsenal that threatens the continental U.S.? Or is the threat of war better?

In Korea, however, the issue is far more personal. The 1950-53 Korean War killed millions. A new war would kill more. Yet for decades, neither side could be persuaded to trust the other. The South feared another invasion from the North. The North feared that the South, backed by U.S. forces, would invade it.

Both sides claimed sovereignty over the entire peninsula. Even today, neither country officially recognizes the other. Which is why the attempts to encourage peace between the two Koreas that have been going on intermittently since 1998 are so important. Currently, the Koreas face a unique opportunity to settle their differences. In the South, Moon was elected president in 2017 on a platform to seek better relations with the North. He has only four years left in his term.

In the North, Kim has ruled since 2011. He has pledged to dramatically improve the country’s economy, a task that would best be accomplished through co-operation with Seoul.

And while the youthful leader has been ruthless in killing off rivals at the top, he faces an entrenched national security bureaucracy that has done well from the state of near-war between North and South and may not appreciate his attempts at rapprochement.

In North America and Japan, Kim’s successful pursuit of nuclear weapons technology is seen as an act of belligerence. In North Korea, however, it is viewed as a necessary precondition to easing relations with the country’s former enemies – a security guarantee that allows the regime to focus on improving the economic welfare of its citizens. For that reason, a decision by the North to immediately and unequivocally abandon its nuclear ambitions was never in the cards.

When the North Koreans made that point last week, they weren’t being obstreperous. They were merely stating the obvious. And when Trump responded by cancelling the June 12 summit, he showed that Washington didn’t fully understand what was going on.

Kim’s response to the Trump cancellation has been cleverly temperate. A senior regime official said in a statement that the North was disappointed by Trump’s decision but is still open to the idea of a summit.

“The first meeting would not solve all,” the statement read. “But solving even one at a time in a phased way would make the relations go better rather than making them worse. The U.S. should ponder over it.”

Indeed it should. With or without Washington, the North-South talks are bound to continue. Both sides want an official peace treaty to end the Korean War. The North wants southern economic assistance. The South wants to give that assistance and is looking for a way that will not violate the United Nations sanctions against Pyongyang.

As for those sanctions, they were easy for the world to support when Kim was threatening his adversaries with nuclear war. Some countries, including China, may find them less compelling now that Kim is presenting himself as the voice of sweet reason.

As I write this column, Trump is musing that maybe he’ll change his mind and meet Kim after all. Who knows? But in the long run, it may not much matter.

North and South Korea seem determined to sort out their affairs. America could find itself bypassed.

Thomas Walkom is a Toronto-based columnist covering politics.

Just Posted

Central Alberta school divisions to support rural students through agreement

Wolf Creek to bring Enhanced Learning Model courses to Clearview schools

WATCH: Red Deer Catholic students re-envision a local wetland for school project

Father Henri Voisin Grade 3 teacher introduces ‘real-life’-based education

Manslaughter charge stayed against Maskwacis man

Man was accused of manslaughter in connection with the death of his mother in 2015

Red Deer Mounties make numerous arrests over the past two weeks

Over the past two weeks, Red Deer RCMP have made a number… Continue reading

Leslieville Elks’ new hall rising from the ashes

Leslieville Elks Lodge grateful for outpouring of support

WATCH: Red Deer Catholic students re-envision a local wetland for school project

Father Henri Voisin Grade 3 teacher introduces ‘real-life’-based education

Charges dropped against Alberta property owner in rural shooting

OKOTOKS, Alta. — All charges have been dropped against a man accused… Continue reading

China blocks John Oliver on social media after scathing show

BEIJING — A popular Chinese social media site is censoring discussion of… Continue reading

Most Red Deer Advocate readers would call police when witnessing a crime

An overwhelming number of Advocate readers would call the police if they… Continue reading

So much TV, so little summer: Amy Adams, Kevin Hart, Dr. Pol

LOS ANGELES — The fall television season is months away but that’s… Continue reading

BlackBerry Q1 revenue, adjusted earnings beat estimates but stock falls

TORONTO — BlackBerry Ltd. shares sank almost 10 per cent to their… Continue reading

OPEC countries to pump more oil to contain price increase

VIENNA — The countries of the OPEC cartel agreed on Friday to… Continue reading

Man sentenced for Edson triple murder

EDMONTON — An Alberta man who fatally shot three people has been… Continue reading

‘Hot Dog Water’ seller in Vancouver gets laughs, sales with savvy marketing

VANCOUVER — A Vancouver man who sold bottles of “Hot Dog Water”… Continue reading

Most Read


Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $185 for 260 issues (must live in delivery area to qualify) Unlimited Digital Access 99 cents for the first four weeks and then only $15 per month Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $15 a month