Opinion: Stock market rumbles signal unsound economy

The stock markets are unsettled. But so far there has been no crash. Life goes on.

Still, market gyrations serve as a reminder. Even though the world economy is in better shape than it was a few years ago, it remains structurally unsound.

First, income inequality persists. It affects not only the developing world but so-called advanced economies, such as Canada and the U.S.

As economist Andrew Jackson has pointed out in the Globe and Mail, census data shows that the gap between Canada’s top 10 per cent and the middle class continues to widen.

This is not just a moral problem. It is a practical one. Economies prosper when the broad middle classes make enough money to buy the goods and services produced. They sputter when those conditions are not met.

Second, wage growth is still low. It’s better than it has been since the recession of 2008 – in large part because, with unemployment dropping, workers have slightly more bargaining power.

But the structural forces that conspire to keep wages down – such as the decline of unions and the growth of precarious work – remain.

As well, whenever workers make significant wage gains, central banks threaten to reverse them.

Indeed, that’s what was behind last week’s stock market turmoil. Traders weren’t spooked by fears of a declining economy. Rather they were reacting to news that the economy was doing unusually well.

Specifically, they were reacting to a report that hourly wages in the U.S. had increased by 2.9 per cent over the year.

In bread and butter terms, 2.9 per cent isn’t very much – particularly to those who have gone a decade without a real raise.

But traders worried that even this paltry amount might be enough to persuade the U.S. Federal Reserve to raise interest rates.

Which brings us to the third point: the strange role played by central banks.

In the years leading up to the recession of 2008, central banks – including the Bank of Canada – focused overwhelmingly on inflation.

When prices threatened to rise too quickly, central banks would signal that they wanted a hike in interest rates. This hike would then lead firms to restrict their business activity and lay off workers.

With unemployment up, wages would be depressed, leading workers to buy fewer goods and services. And that in turn would curb price increases.

It was roundabout and brutal. But it worked.

Faced with the recession of 2008, however, most central banks tried something quite different. In an effort to keep the financial system solvent and encourage economic growth, they did everything in their power to drive interest rates down dramatically.

It was a bold and useful strategy. But it had unintended consequences.

One was a real estate bubble as buyers took advantage of cheap mortgage rates to bid up the price of homes.

Another was a stock market bubble as investors took advantage of cheap money to bid up the price of shares.

The task central banks have given themselves now is how to push interest rates back up to normal levels without pricking these bubbles.

As last week’s stock-market events showed, this won’t be easy.

Some governments have understood some of these problems. Stephen Harper’s Conservatives ran big fiscal deficits in order to get the economy rolling – even while pretending not to.

Justin Trudeau’s Liberals talk endlessly about bolstering the middle class and have made some steps in that direction.

As part of her pre-election veer to the left, Ontario Premier Kathleen Wynne has finally begun to address some of the problems posed by precarious work. For example, her Liberal government would make it easier to certify unions in four hard-to-organize areas.

But it is all very hesitant. Meanwhile, the markets rumble.

Thomas Walkom is a national affairs writer.

Just Posted

Art Battle Red Deer to support Women of Excellence Awards

Art Battle Red Deer will be April 6 at the Radisson Hotel

Eliminating racial discrimination events in Red Deer this week

Two upcoming events aim to inspire change and eliminate racial discrimination in… Continue reading

Outfitter facing Wildlife Act charges

It is alleged archery-only hunting licences used out of season

Sunnybrook pies in demand

Just in time for Easter

Red Deer’s Chopped Canada winner takes break from restaurant business

Pete Sok closes Sophear, but plans to eventually relocate

WATCH: Red Deerians can have a say about crime fighting

Municipality will poll citizens about policing priorities

21-year-old charged with drug trafficking in Rocky Mountain House

RCMP seized drugs after conducting a traffic stop and charged a 21-year-old… Continue reading

Liberal bill would tighten controls on sale, licensing of firearms

OTTAWA — Gun retailers would be required to keep records of firearms… Continue reading

Alberta factoring in Trans Mountain pipeline in budget forecasts

EDMONTON — Finance Minister Joe Ceci says Alberta will rely on anticipated… Continue reading

Pooches and pickup truck stolen in Edmonton found in Rimbey

Two old English bulldogs named Rocky and Jersey who were in a… Continue reading

Statistics Canada reports wholesale sales up 0.1 per cent in January

OTTAWA — Statistics Canada says wholesale sales rose 0.1 per cent to… Continue reading

Right whale deaths cost Gulf snow crab fishery its designation as sustainable

HALIFAX — An international organization has suspended a sustainability certificate for the… Continue reading

Financial watchdog says controls to mitigate sales risk at banks ‘insufficient’

TORONTO — Canada’s financial consumer watchdog says there are “insufficient” controls in… Continue reading

Sheriff official: 3 injured in Maryland high school shooting

GREAT MILLS, Md. — A shooting at a Maryland high school Tuesday… Continue reading

Most Read

Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $185 for 260 issues (must live in delivery area to qualify) Unlimited Digital Access 99 cents for the first four weeks and then only $15 per month Five-day delivery plus unlimited digital access for $15 a month